Stephen Harper warns Alberta separatism will bring 'no benefit'
asserted
separatism → warn → benefit
Former prime minister says staying silent on upcoming referendum 'not an option'
asserted
staying → say → referendum
Former Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper cautioned against the prospect of Alberta separation in a column Friday, writing that even voting just to "send a message" would represent a fraught approach.
"No one will be surprised to learn that I am against separation.
asserted
I → caution → separation
That would involve much risk and be extremely difficult to bring about," Harper wrote in the Calgary Herald.
asserted
Harper → involve → Herald
"Besides, there is nothing resembling the credible leadership necessary to establish a new country."
On Oct. 19, voters will be asked whether Alberta should remain a province of Canada, or whether the government of Alberta should hold a second, binding referendum to separate from Canada.
asserted
government → be → Canada
Follow all of our Alberta referendum coverage
Everything you need to know about the 10 questions in Alberta's Oct. 19 referendum
Earlier this year, as his official prime ministerial portrait was unveiled on Parliament Hill, Harper called for Liberals and Conservatives to come together amid reinvigorated separatist movements in Alberta and Quebec.
asserted
Liberals → follow → Alberta
In September, Harper backed the federal government's decision to walk away from trade talks with the United States at the Canada Investment Summit, arguing that Canada needed to pursue "diminished reliance" on the United States in order to maintain its sovereignty.
asserted
Canada → back → sovereignty
Current Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has also said he supports a united Canada.
asserted
he → say → Canada
Speaking in Edmonton earlier this week, he blamed the Liberal government for what he said was its role in seeding discontent, but said separating from Canada wouldn't help resolve provincial grievances.
asserted
separating → speak → grievances
Harper dismisses voting to send message
While many Albertans may feel alienated from Ottawa, Harper wrote in his Friday column that pursuing independence would pose "significant risk."
"Whatever the results of the Alberta vote, it is incumbent upon Canada to move with immediacy and urgency to address the barriers, many self-imposed, to our long-term stability and prosperity," Harper wrote.
uncertain
Harper → dismiss → stability
"It is on this objective that I believe the passion and legitimate frustration of Albertans should also remain focused."
asserted
passion → believe → Albertans
Polling has consistently indicated that a majority of Albertans are in favour of remaining in Canada.
asserted
majority → indicate → Canada
Separatist leaders have been trying to close the gap.
asserted
leaders → try → gap
They've argued that voting to hold a future, binding referendum would provide Alberta leverage against Ottawa when it comes to resolving its grievances.
asserted
it → argue → grievances
Keith Wilson, a leader of a pro-independence group, often argues on social media that voting for the separation option is an opportunity to send a message that the "status quo with Ottawa is unacceptable.
asserted
quo → argue → Ottawa
"
"For me, Oct. 19 is not simply a debate about staying or leaving; it is also about strategy.
asserted
it → stay → strategy
What position gives Alberta the strongest voice in determining its future?" Wilson wrote on Thursday.
asserted
Wilson → give → Thursday
"My case is that Option 2 creates leverage and strengthens Alberta’s hand at the negotiating table."
asserted
Option → create → table
UCP MLA Jason Stephan argued the same this week after he confirmed to CBC News that he has voted via a mail-in ballot for Option 2: "I've always supported having a referendum on independence because I want Ottawa to be compelled to fix the things that are broken."
asserted
that → argue → things
In his column, Harper disagreed with that argument, writing that "over two generations of Quebec politics were spent debating the goal of the separatists."
asserted
generations → disagree → separatists
"Most voting for it will do so just to 'send a message,' in other words, to keep the threat alive in the hope of retaining the benevolent attention that the province has recently been receiving from Ottawa," Harper wrote.
asserted
Harper → vote → Ottawa
"I believe that approach is mistaken."
asserted
approach → believe → ?
Cory Morgan, who heads the third-party advertiser Pathway to Independence, said the former prime minister's comments were unsurprising, given his reputation as a federalist.
asserted
comments → head → federalist
But he added that recent developments, such as those tied to the West Coast oil pipeline, could be seen as the referendum already sending a message and getting results.
uncertain
developments → add → results
"It is getting attention from Ottawa for the first time in decades," he said.
asserted
he → get → decades
Harper also contended that the federal government under his leadership helped stamp out separatist sentiment, including when it came to its approach to energy policy.
asserted
it → contend → policy
Poilievre also recently claimed that separatist sentiments were wiped out in Alberta and Quebec under Harper’s government — comments that received pushback from the Bloc Québécois.
asserted
that → claim → Québécois
A spokesperson for Harper declined to provide additional comment.
asserted
spokesperson → decline → comment
The Aporia
