Israel this week has claimed to have established operational control over the strategically vital Ali al-Taher ridge in southern Lebanon, after an extended operation against positions of the Lebanese armed group Hezbollah.
asserted
Israel → claim → group
In a statement on Friday, Defence Minister Israel Katz claimed Israeli forces had driven Hezbollah fighters out of what he said was a network of tunnels under the contested highland, 15km (10 miles) from the border.
asserted
he → claim → border
Recommended Stories
list of 4 items- list 1 of 4Israel releases five detainees to Lebanon after US-mediated negotiations
- list 2 of 4October 7 attack shapes Israel’s elections and fuels political blame
- list 3 of 4Israeli strike kills three in southern Lebanon amid ongoing escalation
- list 4 of 4Israeli drones drop bombs on southern Lebanon’s Mansouri
“Prime Minister Netanyahu and I are leading a clear and uncompromising policy, reinforced every day by the [Israeli military]: Israel will not withdraw from the security zone in Lebanon until Hezbollah is disarmed throughout Lebanon and the threats to the residents of the Galilee are removed,” he was quoted as saying by Israeli media.
asserted
he → release → media
“The capture of Ali Taher is an important step towards achieving this goal.”
asserted
capture → achieve → goal
Iran-backed Hezbollah has yet to formally comment on the Israeli claims.
uncertain
Hezbollah → back → claims
However, hours before Katz’s comments, Reuters news agency reported that Iran had warned the United States last month that it would respond forcefully if Israeli attacks on the ridge, which rises 600 metres above sea level (1,970 feet), continued.
asserted
which → report → feet
Israel and Hezbollah have been fighting, with varying levels of intensity, since October 2023.
asserted
Israel → fight → October
Israel has twice escalated the conflict – first in September 2024 and then in March this year, following the start of the US-Israeli war on Iran.
asserted
Israel → escalate → Iran
Israel has been working to embed its occupation of southern Lebanon since the latest escalation, when it announced the creation of a “security” or “buffer” zone, which rights groups say has involved the deliberate destruction of civilian infrastructure – potentially a war crime – and is responsible for the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Lebanese.
asserted
groups → work → Lebanese
Israeli strikes and ground operations around the Ali al-Taher ridge continued despite a ceasefire agreed in June, after Israel gained control of nearby Beaufort Castle and part of the higher ground overlooking much of southern Lebanon and northern Israel.
asserted
Israel → continue → Lebanon
According to Mohanad Hage Ali, of the Carnegie Middle East Centre, Israel’s success has partly been down to technological superiority but also due to the complete absence of “inhibition” in their assaults upon Lebanese towns and villages, which have often accrued daily casualty rates of dozens of people.
“There aren’t any consequences to their actions,” he said.
uncertain
he → accord → actions
“They can demolish entire villages and wipe out whole societies in a way they could never do before.
uncertain
they → demolish → way
It’s ethnic cleansing.”
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Politics of resistance
Pitched as a measure to protect citizens of northern Israel, who Israeli analysts such as Ori Goldberg described as being owed an electoral debt by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ahead of crucial elections later this year, the occupation is also a means of exerting additional pressure on the government in Beirut.
asserted
occupation → pitch → Beirut
“The Israeli ‘operational control’ over the ridge is no doubt a tactical, even strategic, gain, enabling Israel a better control over southern Lebanon,” said Ahron Bregman, an Israeli security analyst and senior teaching fellow at King’s College London.
asserted
Bregman → enable → London
“From an Israeli perspective, it is a way to put pressure on the Lebanese government: Tackle Hezbollah head-on, or we stay here.”
asserted
we → put → Hezbollah
Nicholas Blanford, a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and an authority on the group, said Hezbollah’s lack of comment on the Israeli claims raised a number of questions.
uncertain
lack → say → questions
“It could be that a deal’s been done.
uncertain
deal → do → ?
It could be that Israel is exaggerating what it means by ‘operational control’,” he said, noting that neither the extent of Israel’s military control over the ridge, nor the infrastructure contained within it, is known.
uncertain
extent → exaggerate → it
“What we do know is that Hezbollah appears ready to get back into the resistance business, but no longer seems to be making the decisions,” he said.
asserted
he → know → decisions
“Those are coming from Iran, who appear to want to keep things quiet for now.”
asserted
who → come → things
Analysts also suggested that a lack of a response from Tehran may frustrate Netanyahu, who has invested much of his electoral stock in finishing the war with Iran, an opponent he has characterised as posing an existential threat to the country since at least the early 1990s.
uncertain
he → suggest → 1990s
Katz has described an attack against Israel as freeing its military “from all constraints”, and that in such a scenario, the military would “strike all infrastructure – including energy infrastructure – and return Iran to the Stone Age and darkness”, all of which would almost certainly constitute war crimes.
asserted
all → describe → crimes
However, how far Israel – diplomatically, economically and militarily dependent upon the US – can proceed beyond rhetoric is open to question.
asserted
proceed → proceed → question
With Netanyahu predicted to struggle in October’s elections, what happens in southern Lebanon may prove crucial.
uncertain
happens → predict → Lebanon
“Will Iran come to Hezbollah’s aid?” Bregman asked.
asserted
Bregman → come → aid
“One person for sure – a certain Benjamin Netanyahu prays that they do – as it could even postpone the forthcoming elections in Israel in which, if judged by current polls, he will be defeated.”
uncertain
he → pray → polls
The Aporia
