Photo via The Independent

Pope Leo calls assisted dying ‘false compassion’ during visit to shrine known for miraculous cures

Read the original at The Independent ↗
Cite

Winfield, N. (2026, September 27). Pope Leo calls assisted dying ‘false compassion’ during visit to shrine known for miraculous cures. The Independent. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/pope-leo-assisted-dying-lourdes-shrine-france-b3057220.html

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

The Independent · collected 2026-09-27 · by Nicole Winfield

Quick Summary

Pope Leo XIV visited the French shrine at Lourdes on Sunday, where he condemned medically assisted dying as “false compassion” during his Mass before 150,000 attendees. The pope reiterated Catholic teachings against ending life artificially, emphasizing that legal actions do not equate to moral ones. During his visit, Pope Leo also met with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse, highlighting the church’s ongoing efforts towards atonement for past failures in protecting vulnerable individuals.
Written by AI on 2026-09-27, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Pope Leo XIV concluded his four-day visit to France on September 28, 2026, with massive crowds and significant discussions on migration and European unity. The Pope’s trip, the first papal state visit in 18 years, began with an address on artificial intelligence at UNESCO headquarters in Paris and a Mass attended by more than half a million people. In Metz, he emphasized the importance of peace through dialogue and criticized increased arms expenditure, advocating for welcoming migrants and fostering European unity. The visit also highlighted Catholicism’s resurgence, as young people engaged enthusiastically despite France's secular history. Pope Leo met with several European leaders in Metz to discuss these themes further, ending a trip that showcased both religious devotion and political discourse.

Written for “Pope Leo's Visit To France” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 64 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

22 outlets covered “Pope Leo's Visit To France”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

The IndependentThis outlet27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV visited the French shrine at Lourdes on Sunday, where he condemned medically assisted dying as “false compassion” during his Mass before 150,000 attendees. The pope reiterated Catholic teachings against ending life artificially, emphasizing that legal actions do not equate to moral ones. During his visit, Pope Leo also met with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse, highlighting the church’s ongoing…

Pope Leo calls assisted dying ‘false compassion’ during visit to shrine known for miraculous cures (this article)3 articles from The Independent on this story
The Straits Times27 Sep

Pope Leo met with seven French survivors of clergy abuse on September 27 during his four-day visit to France, where he reaffirmed the Catholic Church's commitment to preventing future abuses. The meeting came after a report revealed that over 330,000 children were abused by Catholic clergy and lay leaders in France over seven decades. Leo also addressed an estimated 150,000 people at a Mass near Lourdes, urging the…

Pope Leo pledges action on clergy abuse after meeting French survivors →7 articles from The Straits Times on this story
Toronto Star27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV visited the Catholic shrine at Lourdes, France, on Sunday to deliver a message emphasizing the sanctity of life and opposition to euthanasia and medically assisted dying. During his four-day trip, he met with an estimated 150,000 people and held a private meeting with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse. The visit comes at a time when France has recently enshrined abortion rights and approved laws…

Pope brings message to protect life to French shrine at Lourdes known for miraculous cures →6 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Al Jazeera27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV met with seven adult survivors of clerical child abuse in Lourdes, France, during his four-day visit, reaffirming his commitment to address sexual abuse within the Catholic Church. The meeting followed a 2021 report that found over 330,000 French children were abused by Catholic clergy and lay leaders over seven decades. Survivors expressed mixed feelings about the pope’s actions, appreciating his…

Pope pledges action on clergy child abuse in meeting with French survivors →6 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
BBC27 Sep

Pope Leo addressed French bishops during his four-day visit to France, emphasizing the need to address the "scourge" of sexual abuse within the Church and maintain vigilance against it. The meeting took place at the Sanctuary of Our Holy Lady of Lourdes on the third day of the Pope's trip, following a massive public appearance in Paris where an estimated 700,000 people attended to hear him speak. A 2021 inquiry…

'Scourge' of abuse must be rooted out, says Pope, during Lourdes visit →5 articles from BBC on this story
Euronews28 Sep

Pope Leo concluded his trip to France by visiting Metz, where he honored Robert Schuman and highlighted European unity. During the visit, titled “At the Roots of Europe for Peace and Unity,” Leo met several European leaders including the Prime Minister of Luxembourg and Prince Albert II of Monaco. President Macron joined both the Mass at Saint-Étienne Cathedral and the farewell ceremony at Metz-Nancy-Lorraine…

Pope Leo ends France trip in Metz, spotlighting Schuman and EU unity →5 articles from Euronews on this story
Show 16 more outlets
The Guardian27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV addressed a crowd of around 150,000 people near the Catholic shrine in Lourdes, France, calling on the church to heal from past mistakes without explicitly mentioning recent scandals. During his four-day visit, he met privately with survivors of child sexual abuse by French clergy and urged French bishops to maintain vigilance against abuse. The pope's trip follows reports that 330,000 children were…

Pope Leo urges healing of ‘deep wounds’ before meeting child sexual abuse survivors in France →4 articles from The Guardian on this story
Fox News27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV visited Lourdes on Saturday evening from Paris to pray at the site where Bernadette Soubirous reported visions of the Virgin Mary and lead an open-air Mass attended by hundreds of thousands Sunday. The pope met with people who experienced unexplained healings, such as Sister Bernadette Moriau and Antonietta Raco, whose cases were recognized by the Church. Dr. Alessandro de Franciscis, recently retired…

Pope Leo visits site of miracle cures, meets people whose unexplained healings stunned doctors →4 articles from Fox News on this story
The Hindu28 Sep

During a four-day visit to France in September 2026, Pope Leo XIV urged Europeans to welcome and integrate migrants, emphasizing peace through dialogue rather than increased military spending. In Metz, he highlighted the case of the Canary Islands facing an influx of African refugees and stressed the importance of treating migrants as family members who can contribute to society. The pope's remarks came amid rising…

Pope Leo XIV urges Europeans to welcome migrants →4 articles from The Hindu on this story
New York Post28 Sep

Pope Leo XIV visited medical facilities in Lourdes, France, on Sunday where he criticized medically assisted suicide as “false compassion.” During his visit, the pope emphasized the importance of protecting human dignity and condemned the practice of physician-assisted death, urging healthcare professionals to focus on caring for the sick rather than ending lives. The article also highlights a case from Canada…

Pope Leo calls out ‘false compassion’ of medically assisted suicide during French hospital visit →3 articles from New York Post on this story
CBC26 Sep

Hundreds of thousands of people gathered along the Champs-Élysées in Paris for Pope Leo XIV's mass on Saturday, reflecting the Catholic Church’s enduring influence despite secular trends. The pope greeted attendees from his popemobile during a two-kilometer parade to Place de la Concorde, where more than 600,000 registered participants attended the event. Pope Leo emphasized messages of social justice and…

Hundreds of thousands turn out for Pope Leo along Champs-Élysées ahead of mass in Paris →2 articles from CBC on this story
NPR26 Sep

Pope Leo XIV warned during his trip to France that a reliance on advanced technology could undermine humanity's essence. He addressed these concerns at the Élysée Palace and UNESCO headquarters, discussing topics like artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons. The pope emphasized peace through dialogue and justice rather than military power and criticized nuclear deterrence policies as misguided. Despite declining…

Pope warns a 'paradise of machines' could undermine humanity as he opens France trip →2 articles from NPR on this story
CBS News28 Sep

Pope Leo recently drew large crowds during his visit to France, with an estimated 800,000 people gathering in Paris and over 150,000 attending Sunday Mass at Lourdes. The article explores whether this enthusiasm indicates a resurgence of Catholicism in a historically secular country. While there are signs of renewed interest, such as a significant increase in baptisms, France remains predominantly non-religious…

Pope Leo draws massive crowds in France. Is Catholicism making a comeback? →2 articles from CBS News on this story
South China Morning Post27 Sep

Pope Leo, the first US pope, met privately with seven victims of clerical sex abuse during his four-day visit to Lourdes, France. The meeting follows his promise to reform the Catholic Church in response to the global sexual abuse scandal. On Sunday, Pope Leo waved at believers as he attended mass in Lourdes, a town with significant religious importance despite France’s secular government.

Pope meets victims of sex abuse, urges ‘wise leaders’ as French election looms →2 articles from South China Morning Post on this story
National Post27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV expressed opposition to assisted dying during his visit to Lourdes, France, stating that it is not normal and urging people to reject false compassion that leads to causing death. He emphasized that legal practices do not equate to moral ones, addressing recent legislation passed by the French parliament in June that permits certain adults with incurable conditions to request assistance to end their…

Assisted dying not ‘normal,’ says Pope Leo XIV →2 articles from National Post on this story
ABC News (AU)27 Sep

Pope Leo addressed a crowd of over 150,000 in Lourds, urging the Catholic Church to confront its past failings and heal "deep wounds," particularly regarding child abuse by priests. The Pope met with victims of such abuse in France following a 2021 report revealing that nearly 330,000 French children were abused by Catholic clergy over seven decades. Despite his calls for healing and admitting mistakes, some…

Pope urges church to admit failings and heal 'deep wounds' →2 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
Dawn20 Sep

Pope Leo XIV's visit to France from September 25 to 28 involves extensive planning and preparation, including security measures with approximately 15,000 personnel. The article details how papal visits require careful consideration of international context, local church conditions, and the pope’s personal priorities. It also covers logistical aspects like chartering a commercial plane for travel and onboard…

Packing for a pope: Behind the scenes on foreign trips →
Daily Mail26 Sep

Pope Leo was welcomed by a crowd of over 600,000 people at Place de la Concorde in Paris for an outdoor mass during his four-day visit aimed at repairing the Church's image after abuse scandals. Before the service, worshippers expressed hope that Pope Leo would address world peace and other global issues, reflecting concerns about materialism and evil in contemporary society. The article highlights Pope Leo’s…

Pope Leo's mass appeal: American pontiff is met by 600,000 crowd as he arrives for outdoor service in Paris before heading for Lourdes →
Washington Examiner26 Sep

Hundreds of thousands of people gathered along the Champs-Élysées in Paris for Pope Leo XIV’s outdoor Mass on Saturday, with an estimated 700,000 attendees. Despite France's secularization trends, the event highlighted the Catholic Church's enduring influence, as evidenced by the enthusiastic crowd spanning multiple generations and faith backgrounds. Pope Leo emphasized messages of social justice during his visit…

Hundreds of thousands turn out for Pope Leo’s popemobile parade along Champs-Élysées ahead of Mass →
Sydney Morning Herald26 Sep

During Pope Leo's visit to Paris, he led an outdoor Mass on Avenue des Champs-Élysées that attracted approximately 800,000 people. The event featured chants and waving Vatican flags as the Pope traveled along the two-kilometer avenue in his Popemobile, blessing attendees. Among those present were French first lady Brigitte Macron and far-right leader Marine Le Pen. In his sermon, Leo emphasized finding happiness…

Hundreds of thousands in Paris cheer Pope Leo in largest event of French tour →
Global News27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV condemned medically-assisted dying as immoral during his Sunday visit to the French Catholic shrine in Lourdes. Addressing a crowd of 150,000 people, many of whom were sick or disabled, the pope argued that such practices represent "false compassion" and are contrary to the inherent dignity of every human being. His visit coincides with recent legislation in France allowing terminally ill adults access…

Pope Francis says medically-assisted dying is ‘false compassion’ →
ABC News (US)27 Sep

Pope Leo XIV criticized medically assisted death during a visit to Lourdes, France, calling it “false compassion” and emphasizing that legal practices are not necessarily moral. Speaking to approximately 150,000 people at a Mass in Lourdes, the Pope reaffirmed Catholic teaching on protecting all human life from conception until natural death, opposing abortion, euthanasia, and medically assisted dying.

Pope blasts assisted dying as 'false compassion' →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • Large crowds are expected at various stages during the Pope's visit to France.37
  • Pope Leo XIV is making his first official papal visit to France in 18 years.27
Quoted from the coverage (4)

Pope Leo shares troubling warning about AI creating ‘paradise of machines’

8 outlets

Marko Rupnik, one of the Catholic church’s best-known mosaic artists, is on trial in a Vatican court, accused by more than two dozen women of having psychologically, spiritually and sexually abused them from the 1990s, including during the creation of his artworks.

7 outlets

The number of adult baptisms in France each year has tripled since 2016, hitting 13,000 this year.

6 outlets

For many French people, the square embodies the Republic: French presidents traditionally celebrate Bastille Day there.

6 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • The impact of Pope Leo's message on life issues may differ due to recent French legislation, according to the Toronto Star and other sources.13
  • Outlets vary in their focus between the religious aspect and political discussions during the visit.14

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The Toronto Star highlights the secular nature of France conflicting with Catholic teachings, while The Guardian emphasizes the first papal visit in 18 years.12
  • CBS News focuses on the potential revival of Catholicism in a secular country, contrasting with Al Jazeera's focus on the mass attendance figures.87
Words to watch (1)

Pope blasts assisted dying as 'false compassion' ABC News

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 65 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 2% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
ABC News (US)
Hedges 0 of 45 claims Outlet record 67/100
Global News
Hedges 0 of 44 claims Outlet record 63/100
Toronto Star
Hedges 0 of 28 claims Outlet record 64/100
The Hindu
Hedges 0 of 6 claims Outlet record 60/100
National Post
Hedges 0 of 6 claims Outlet record 60/100
Fox News
Hedges 1 of 24 claims Outlet record 67/100
New York Post
Hedges 5 of 23 claims Outlet record 66/100
Toronto Star
Leans left Hedges 1 of 28 claims Outlet record 64/100
BBC News
Hedges 2 of 14 claims Outlet record 65/100
“The articles describe different speeches given by Pope Leo during his visit to Lourdes, one on sexual abuse in the Church and another on medically assisted death.”

Story

Pope Leo's Visit To France
World · 65 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
44
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
2%
1 of 44 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
59/100
The Independent's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
65
World
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-27 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Independent · 4554 article(s) · 10 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 10 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Nicole Winfield
39 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Pope Leo XIV said his recent lung cancer surgery has not altered his agenda, outlook or even sense of mortality, as he projected a long pontificate focused on unity and healing within the church.
Leo emerged from the Vatican’s residence in Lima to begin his final morning, visiting a care home for the elderly that he tended to during the COVID-19 pandemic, ahead of a huge Mass at a capital air base expected to draw up to 1 million people.
Leo emerged from the Vatican’s residence in Lima to kick off his final morning, visiting a home for the elderly that he tended to during the COVID-19 pandemic, before a huge Mass at an air base in the Peruvian capital that’s expected to draw up to 1 million people.
On the penultimate day of his visit to his adopted homeland, Leo is expected to echo Pope Francis, emphasizing Catholic teaching that links care for the most vulnerable with care for God’s creation.
Back then, Prevost would make the arduous drive to Santa Cruz de Succhabamba himself.
When Susana Baca, the Latin Grammy-winning Afro-Peruvian singer, serenaded Pope Leo XIV upon his arrival in Peru, it was a sign that the visit would provide an unparalleled spotlight on the culture that grew out of the African slave trade in this country.
But much of the world heard about it on the night of Leo’s election, May 8, 2025, when he gave Chiclayo a shoutout, in Spanish, from the loggia of St. Peter’s Basilica.
He joked with the bishops that some “doubting Thomases” had predicted he wouldn't be able to come.
Leo thrilled the crowd by looping around the plaza in his popemobile before accepting the keys to the city from Lima’s mayor.
Pope Leo XIV will wrap up his visit to Argentina with two poignant moments on Wednesday — a meeting with inmates at a prison with a history linked to the country’s military dictatorship, and a final Mass at Argentina’s national shrine.
Also by Nicole Winfield
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 39 articles by Nicole Winfield →

Topics

Catholic France French Lourdes U.S.

Subjects

Leo PERSON · 9× Lourdes GPE · 5× Catholic NORP · 3× France GPE · 3× French NORP · 2× U.S. GPE · 2× Vatican ORG · 2× Independent ORG · 1× Leo XIV PERSON · 1× the Catholic Church’s ORG · 1×

Narrative

A message about end-of-life care Leo’s visit to the once staunchly Catholic and officially secular France has been marked by huge crowds — 800,000 at Leo’s Mass on Paris’ iconic Place de la Concorde — and his messaging against abortion and assisted dying.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-27
“I never thought I would have a pope before me.”

Claims (44 extracted, 1 hedged)

Pope Leo XIV condemned the legalization of medically assisted death Sunday as immoral “false compassion,” reaffirming Catholic teaching on the sanctity of life during a visit to Lourdes, the French shrine associated with miraculous healings. asserted
XIV → condemn → healings
On the third day of his visit to France, Leo again waded into the end-of-life debate unfolding in his native U.S. and countries around the world. asserted
Leo → wad → world
The issue roiled French politics for years before lawmakers recently approved legislation allowing adults with incurable illnesses to receive lethal medication. asserted
adults → roil → medication
Leo also met on Sunday with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse, in what has now become a regular appointment for popes on foreign visits. asserted
what → meet → visits
The aim is to atone for the Catholic Church’s failure to protect its youngest and most vulnerable members from predator priests. asserted
aim → atone → priests
“It was extraordinary,” said survivor Jean-Marie Delbos, who joined four others at a press conference afterward to praise Leo for the encounter, saying he listened and was informed of their cases. asserted
he → say → cases
“I never thought I would have a pope before me.” asserted
I → think → me
A message about end-of-life care Leo’s visit to the once staunchly Catholic and officially secular France has been marked by huge crowds — 800,000 at Leo’s Mass on Paris’ iconic Place de la Concorde — and his messaging against abortion and assisted dying. asserted
visit → mark → abortion
France’s National Assembly in 2024 enshrined abortion as a constitutional right and recently gave final approval to its end-of-life bill. asserted
Assembly → enshrine → bill
On Sunday, the American pope celebrated Mass before some 150,000 people — many in wheelchairs — on the prairie next to Lourdes’ main basilica. asserted
pope → celebrate → basilica
He then visited a care center for sick people on the sanctuary’s grounds. asserted
He → visit → grounds
He sought to encourage especially those who live in “terrible pain” that they have inherent dignity that no law or algorithm can “eliminate.” asserted
law → seek → that
“On the contrary, it is precisely in the name of this inalienable dignity of the human person that we must reject the temptation to cause death under the guise of false compassion,” he said. asserted
he → reject → compassion
"What is legal is not necessarily moral,” Leo said to applause from the crowd. asserted
Leo → say → crowd
Catholic teaching holds that all human life must be protected and defended from conception until natural death, leading to its firm opposition to abortion, euthanasia and medically assisted dying. asserted
life → hold → abortion
Leo had specifically criticized a medical-aid-in-dying law that took effect on Sept. 12 in his home state of Illinois — the 13th U.S. state with such a law. asserted
that → criticize → law
Lourdes became a major pilgrimage destination after the Catholic Church officially recognized visions of the Virgin Mary reported here by a young girl in 1858. asserted
Church → become → 1858
The site near the Spanish border draws millions of pilgrims each year, especially sick and disabled believers hoping for a cure from the famed spring water in the Lourdes grotto where the visions purportedly occurred. asserted
visions → draw → grotto
As a result in Lourdes, where the church has recognized 72 “miraculous” cures as authentic, the question of respecting even the most frail, sick and vulnerable is particularly acute. asserted
question → recognize → frail
Survivors visit Lourdes as part of their healing process More recently, Lourdes has also become a place of healing for survivors of clergy sexual abuse, and it was chosen as the site for Leo's encounter with victims. asserted
it → visit → victims
Leo met with them in a group and one-on-one in an encounter that lasted nearly two hours asserted
that → meet → encounter
, the Vatican said. asserted
Vatican → say → ?
The pope "listened to their stories, the pain and suffering they had endured — sometimes, unfortunately, with the complicity or silence of those who could have helped them — and their suggestions for ensuring that this does not happen again,” the Vatican said in a statement. uncertain
Vatican → listen → statement
Olivier Mardi, co-founder of Voix Libérées de Touraine, a survivor group, said he perceived that Leo was a decisive “man of engagement” who had done his homework going into the meeting. asserted
who → say → meeting
He said Leo knew Mardi's case and asked him precise questions. asserted
Leo → say → questions
“He's not fooled; he knows that these incidents will continue and that we must remain vigilant,” he said. asserted
he → fool → ?
“There was an emotional side to it, and at the same time, something very powerful when he spoke.” asserted
he → be → time
The French church has faced a brutal reckoning with its legacy of abuse. asserted
church → face → abuse
An independent report in 2021 estimated 330,000 children had been abused over 70 years by some 3,000 priests and church workers. asserted
children → estimate → priests
Despite criticism of the report’s methodology and conclusions, French bishops put in place an independent system of compensation for victims that to date has recommended the church pay out more than 20 million euros ($22.7 million). asserted
church → put → euros
During a meeting with French bishops on Sunday morning, Leo praised their response to victims and urged them to continue. asserted
Leo → praise → them
But he also acknowledged that the cratering in priestly vocations in the French church is related to the scandal, given the priesthood is now sometimes viewed with suspicion. asserted
priesthood → acknowledge → suspicion
“For priestly vocations to flourish, the priest must be welcomed, accepted, and loved,” Leo said. asserted
Leo → flourish → ?
Monsignor Pierre-Antoine Bozo, spokesperson for the bishops’ conference, said Leo intentionally wanted to keep the encounter with victims small to facilitate an intimate encounter. asserted
Leo → say → encounter
“When it comes to listening to them, you can’t have 50 people in front of you,” he said. asserted
he → come → you
“So I think that’s really what the pope chose: to listen so that we can act and respond more effectively.” asserted
we → think → what
Mosaics are a painful reminder of alleged abuse In Lourdes, Leo was also reminded of a prickly abuse case inherited from Pope Francis. asserted
Leo → remind → Francis
The façade of one of the Lourdes basilicas was designed by the Rev. Marko Rupnik, a religious mosaic artist. asserted
façade → design → Rupnik
Rupnik is currently on trial in a Vatican court, accused by more than two dozen women of having psychologically, spiritually and sexually abused them starting in the 1990s, including during the creation of his artworks. asserted
Rupnik → accuse → artworks
His case was covered up for three decades by his Jesuit superiors, and even Francis was suspected of having protected his fellow Jesuit. asserted
Francis → cover → Jesuit
…and 4 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support