We'll be back to normal service Tuesday, with a paywall – so please enjoy this free edition of ‘First Draft’ and then upgrade to paid, so you never hit another paywall again!
asserted
you → enjoy → paywall
Although I did carve out two hours on Wednesday night to watch ‘Mutiny,’ the latest Jason Statham action flick.
asserted
I → carve → Mutiny
If Democrats are expected to disavow Hasan Piker when he isn’t antisemitic, shouldn’t Republicans disavow Elon Musk when he… is?
asserted
he → expect → Musk
And how are we still living in ‘the land of the free’ if Congress is making it illegal for universities, including faculty and personnel, to exercise their First Amendment right to criticize – and boycott – foreign countries like Israel?
asserted
universities → live → Israel
Let’s get into it.
asserted
’s → let → it
World’s Richest Man Calls on Jews to Take DNA Tests to Prove They’re Jewish
Is Elon Musk an antisemite?
Is he, perhaps, like Henry Ford in more ways than one?
asserted
he → call → one
The world’s richest man has always denied being an antisemite, and yet there is the rather inconvenient matter of his record.
asserted
man → deny → record
And, no, I’m not just referring to the way in which Musk-owned Twitter has become a cesspit of open racism and antisemitism; an online refuge for neo-Nazis, Holocaust deniers, and white supremacists.
asserted
Twitter → refer → Nazis
I’m talking about Musk himself.
asserted
I → talk → Musk
Remember in 2023 when he responded to a Twitter user who accused Jewish communities of pushing “dialectical hatred against white people” by saying: “You have said the actual truth”?
asserted
You → remember → truth
Outrage followed, and some advertisers fled his platform.
asserted
advertisers → follow → platform
He eventually apologized and went to Auschwitz with Ben Shapiro on what looked a lot like a rehabilitation tour.
asserted
what → apologize → tour
Remember in 2025 when he celebrated Trump’s inauguration by giving what looked to a lot of people – including Nazis – like a Nazi salute?
asserted
what → remember → salute
The ADL, which never misses an opportunity to accuse a supporter of Palestine of being antisemitic, rushed to his defense, describing it only as “an awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute.”
asserted
which → miss → enthusiasm
Remember how he continues to support and amplify the far-right AfD party in Germany, which has been plagued by scandals involving Nazis and Nazi rhetoric?
asserted
which → remember → Nazis
You might think that would be enough controversy involving one billionaire and antisemitism.
uncertain
that → think → billionaire
On Thursday, Musk went further.
asserted
Musk → go → Thursday
On the social media site that he owns, he decided to question Jewish racial identity in a really weird, pseudo-sciency, even eugenicky way.
asserted
he → own → way
Here is the original poll from a random Twitter account, followed by Musk’s response.
asserted
poll → follow → response
Seriously: What possesses a normal, non-racist, non-antisemitic person to engage with a question like this in the first place?
asserted
person → possess → place
And what possesses them to answer it by suggesting that if Jews who look white cannot provide DNA evidence of their Jewishness, then they must actually be white and their Jewish identity must be “all in their mind.”
asserted
identity → possess → mind
Or as one user quote-tweeted in response to Musk’s comments:
So why am I leading today’s ‘First Draft’ with this one insanely racist, clearly antisemitic post?
asserted
I → tweet → post
First, because it is actually a very big deal when the richest person on Earth, who also owns one of the most influential communications platforms on Earth, starts publicly dabbling in ideas about Jews, bloodlines, DNA, appearance, and racial authenticity.
asserted
who → own → Jews
(You remember the people who did that back in the 1930s and 1940s, right?)
asserted
who → remember → 1930s
To quote political commentator Brian Beutler, reacting to Musk’s post: “The man using his vast fortune to bail out GOP candidates across the country says many white-skinned Jews don’t look super Jewy, and thus may not have Jew blood in them, freeing them to be white if they could just get over themselves.
uncertain
they → quote → themselves
“Subtle” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there, obviously.
asserted
Subtle → do → lifting
But there is a second reason this matters – and it goes far beyond Musk.
asserted
it → be → Musk
He plans to spend at least $100 million in more than a dozen House and Senate races in the upcoming midterms.
asserted
He → plan → midterms
And on the very same day that Musk was opining about Jewish identity and DNA, his America PAC “disclosed the first $800,000 of that spending in 15 races,” according to the New York Times.
uncertain
PAC → opine → Times
So, will we now see a frenzied news cycle in which Republican candidates taking money from Musk are asked to disavow his comments about Jewish identity?
asserted
candidates → see → identity
Will reporters chase those candidates through the halls of Congress asking whether they agree that a Jew’s Jewishness can be determined by their skin color or DNA?
asserted
Jewishness → chase → color
Will Republicans be asked to condemn Elon Musk?
asserted
Republicans → ask → Musk
Haven’t we spent the past few weeks watching media organizations obsess over Abdul El-Sayed ally Hasan Piker, a Twitch streamer, and demanding Democrats condemn him?
asserted
Democrats → spend → him
Piker has never said anything comparable to Musk when it comes to Jews and Judaism.
asserted
it → say → Jews
Nor does Piker fund the Democratic Party with nine-figure sums.
asserted
Piker → fund → sums
Musk funds the GOP.
asserted
Musk → fund → GOP
In Michigan, for example, El-Sayed’s Republican opponent Mike Rogers is now being boosted by Musk’s cash.
asserted
opponent → boost → cash
So, will he be asked to denounce and disavow the world’s richest man?
asserted
he → ask → man
How about Senator Susan Collins in Maine, who castigated former Democratic opponent Graham Platner for his alleged antisemitism?
asserted
who → castigate → antisemitism
Will she be asked to comment on the man who just pumped $170,000 into her campaign?
asserted
who → ask → campaign
…and 89 more, not listed.
The Aporia
