Anthony Ralphs has been showing up to San Diego City Council meetings to speak against Flock's presence in his city for a year.
asserted
Ralphs → show → year
At first, he took the podium during public comment in business casual — dress shirts, pants, suits, "respectable" clothing — to voice his concerns about the city's deal with the surveillance company.
asserted
he → take → company
"I did all the right things.
asserted
I → do → things
I wore the suits.
asserted
I → wear → suits
I said all the correct talking points.
asserted
I → say → points
I made all the compelling arguments," Ralphs told me in a phone call.
asserted
Ralphs → make → call
He cited Supreme Court precedent, like Chatrie v. United States, which challenged the constitutionality of geofence warrants where police could collect location history data from cell phones.
uncertain
police → cite → phones
It seemed like no matter how many cases I brought up, no matter how many violations of the Constitution this technology breaks, no matter how many constituents, no matter how many organizations, no matter how well I dress, no matter how fine my talking points, they weren't listening," he said.
asserted
he → seem → Constitution
"That was when I realized, you know, you can't spell activism without 'act,' right?
asserted
you → realize → act
And I decided, well, maybe I'll try something different."
asserted
I → decide → something
On August 19, Ralphs stood before city council members in a Darth Vader cape and mask, complete with mechanized breathing and voice changer.
asserted
Ralphs → stand → breathing
"The emperor is a fan of Flock," he began, and, speaking as the Dark Lord, laid out in three minutes why the Empire depends on Flock's warrantless network of automatic license plate readers and surveillance cameras.
asserted
Empire → begin → readers
The video went extremely viral; after our coverage of Ralph's comments, every news outlet on the planet seemingly wrote about the mysterious San Diegan Vader.
asserted
outlet → go → Vader
Coverage of his speech was published in Singapore and translated to Spanish and Arabic.
asserted
Coverage → publish → Spanish
Ralphs is an event producer and has been hosting raves and music festivals in the area for the last 13 years.
asserted
Ralphs → host → years
He founded an event space, Eden Art Garden, about an hour outside of the city.
asserted
He → found → city
He recently started DeFlock San Diego and works with the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology San Diego (TRUST SD) Coalition as well as other anti-surveillance and privacy rights groups to educate people and organize more widely.
asserted
He → start → people
"But now we need the musicians, we need the artists, we need the painters, the actors, we need the thespians to bring this together and get some wheels on the movement to help it gain traction," he said.
asserted
he → need → traction
"I think it's a character that resonates.
asserted
that → think → ?
He's an archetype for the Empire," Ralphs said.
asserted
Ralphs → say → Empire
Framing it into that context, I think was what was needed to bring this conversation into like a theatrical global component is really framing it in that kind of good versus bad framework.
asserted
what → frame → framework
It is such an Orwellian technology being utilized by such comic book villain forces of evil trying to do dastardly things."
asserted
It → utilize → things
One of Ralphs' first city council meetings was in December 2025, when hundreds of people spoke in person, attended via Zoom, or sent comments online opposing Flock.
asserted
hundreds → speak → Flock
After six hours of deliberation and debate, and despite the vast majority of public comment coming from constituents who wanted Flock out of San Diego, the council voted to continue the program.
asserted
council → come → program
After that meeting, where city council decided that none of their constituents' opinions mattered and that they were going to vote how they wanted to vote regardless...
asserted
they → decide → opinions
After that, the movement was so discouraged, and all of us were so deflated that it was really hard to summon the collective energy and to muster the kind of the vitality that we needed to keep pushing forward," Ralphs said.
asserted
Ralphs → summon → that
He came back to another city council meeting a week later, and was "shocked and really disappointed," he said, to see the chamber was completely empty of members of the public.
asserted
chamber → come → public
In that moment, he said, he realized he had an opportunity to attend as many city council meetings as he could — once every two weeks, then once a week, then twice and week and eventually every council and subcommittee meeting by spring 2026.
uncertain
he → say → spring
"Then by May and June, I was so familiar with the process of giving public comment, of looking at the agenda items ahead of time to know what was going to be discussed, knowing how to cede time and get time ceded to you, I started organizing people to join me to speak to city council.
uncertain
people → give → council
After Vader's appearance went viral around the world, Ralphs wondered if he'd let the character remain anonymous or take ownership of it.
asserted
character → go → it
"But I think that it's a good time now to follow up with what the intention was, and what the reason and method was behind it," he said.
asserted
he → think → it
"I think it's important for people to know this wasn't just some antic from somebody who just decided to show up one day and make some noise.
asserted
who → think → noise
This was a thought out plan that was exacted only after cumulative frustration from hundreds of people being ignored and months and months and months of trying things quote unquote the right way and it not working."
asserted
it → exact → things
On Monday afternoon, Ralphs returned to San Diego City Council.
asserted
Ralphs → return → Council
He carried the mask to the podium with it wheezing on its own, and sat it down on the table.
asserted
it → carry → table
"I think we know who the bad guy is now.
asserted
guy → think → ?
But I think what the whole world wants to know is who wants to be the good guy," he said.
asserted
he → think → what
"I have requests to be interviewed this entire week.
asserted
I → have → requests
And what I would like to ask is, of the five council members that voted for Flock: When will this end? When will you listen to the vast majority of your constituents?"
asserted
you → like → constituents
The Aporia
