For some bizarre reason, more and more Americans are embracing the failed economic and political ideology of democratic socialism.
asserted
Americans → embrace → socialism
History teaches us that socialism, however it is dressed up, fails.
asserted
it → teach → us
In the early decades of the modern state of Israel, many Israelis lived in kibbutzim, agrarian communities structured around shared property and radical egalitarianism.
asserted
Israelis → live → property
These communities operated under the utopian Marxist principle of “from each according to their ability, to each according to their needs.”
uncertain
communities → operate → needs
Over time, however, the ideal of shared economic rewards was undermined by the reality that some members of the kibbutzim could free ride on the efforts of those who worked harder and produced more.
uncertain
who → share → more
This weakened social cohesion and eventually pushed many communities toward a basic principle of free markets: Those who produce more should earn more.
asserted
who → weaken → more
When economic incentives were introduced, productivity increased.
asserted
productivity → introduce → ?
In the United States, the basic economic principles of free market capitalism have produced extraordinary wealth.
asserted
principles → produce → wealth
Still, despite the overwhelming economic and social evidence, Americans who are unhappy with their circumstances want to experiment with socialism.
asserted
who → want → socialism
Growing in influence over the Democratic Party, the Democratic Socialists of America advocate a national system of free healthcare, government-sponsored affordable housing, free childcare, and a universal basic income.
asserted
Socialists → grow → healthcare
That sounds wonderful in theory.
asserted
That → sound → theory
But when the cost of these programs is measured against the resources of the nation, the numbers don’t add up.
asserted
numbers → measure → nation
The U.S. already carries roughly $40 trillion in federal debt.
asserted
U.S. → carry → debt
The U.S. now runs an annual budget deficit of about $2 trillion, or roughly 6% of GDP.
asserted
U.S. → run → GDP
“Medicare for all” has alone been estimated to cost more than $30 trillion over a decade.
asserted
Medicare → estimate → decade
Housing subsidies, free childcare, and a universal basic income could cost trillions more.
uncertain
subsidies → cost → trillions
Who would pay for all this spending?
asserted
Who → pay → spending
Democratic socialists want Americans to believe that billionaires such as Elon Musk and Amazon founder Jeff Bezos have enough money to finance their utopian dreams.
asserted
billionaires → want → dreams
But they are lying.
asserted
they → lie → ?
Even confiscating the entire wealth of America’s billionaires would not provide a permanent source of funding for socialists’ spending ambitions.
asserted
confiscating → confiscate → ambitions
What democratic socialists rarely emphasize is that implementing a European-style welfare state would require much higher taxes on the middle class, not merely on billionaires.
asserted
implementing → emphasize → billionaires
European governments finance expansive social programs through very high taxes that hit their middle classes hard.
asserted
that → finance → classes
America’s middle class would have to pay dramatically more to finance a comparable system.
asserted
class → have → system
Embracing democratic socialism could also undermine the dynamism of the U.S. economy.
uncertain
Embracing → embrace → economy
France, for example, combines a large welfare state with substantially higher taxation and government spending than the United States.
asserted
France → combine → States
Yet, Americans enjoy considerably higher levels of disposable income than the French.
asserted
Americans → enjoy → French
Economic growth suffers when governments attempt to substitute political decision-making for market signals.
asserted
governments → suffer → signals
Central planners cannot efficiently balance the supply and demand of millions of goods and services.
asserted
planners → balance → goods
Resources are misallocated.
asserted
Resources → misallocate → ?
No centralized authority can aggregate and process economic information as efficiently as millions of households and businesses making decisions in a competitive marketplace.
asserted
authority → aggregate → marketplace
Incentives matter.
asserted
Incentives → matter → ?
The very high tax rates required to finance democratic socialist ambitions would discourage investment, weaken innovation, and encourage both human and financial capital to flee.
asserted
rates → require → capital
When the state controls more of the economy, political leaders gain greater influence over the lives of the people.
asserted
leaders → control → people
History provides numerous examples of socialist governments that accumulated economic power and then used that power to enrich loyal cronies and restrict liberty.
asserted
that → provide → liberty
But its core strength is that it disperses economic power, rewards innovation, and gives individuals the freedom to make their own economic choices.
asserted
it → disperse → choices
Democratic socialism promises greater equality and security.
asserted
socialism → promise → equality
But its promises collide with the realities of incentives, arithmetic, and human nature.
asserted
promises → collide → incentives
And, as former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher aptly noted, socialists always eventually run out of other people’s money.
asserted
socialists → note → money
James Rogan is a former diplomat who later worked in law and finance for over 30 years.
asserted
who → work → years
Now he writes a daily note on markets, economics, politics, and social issues.
asserted
he → write → markets
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
