Multiple trustees at the Canadian Museum for Human Rights raised concerns beginning last fall that a new exhibit on the Palestinian Nakba could damage the institution’s reputation and hurt fundraising efforts.
uncertain
exhibit → raise → efforts
But the board members were rebuffed by management, who told them content curation is not their responsibility, according to internal meeting minutes.
uncertain
curation → rebuff → minutes
The minutes, obtained by The Globe and Mail, include around 200 pages of records from November, 2025, to this past May.
uncertain
minutes → obtain → May
Coupled with interviews conducted separately with one former and four current trustees, they demonstrate that the high-profile museum’s 11-member board was divided over the exhibit from its announcement last year until its launch in late June.
asserted
board → couple → June
Some board members were particularly concerned about the Nakba display linking historic events of the 1940s to the present-day war between Israel and Hamas.
asserted
members → concern → Israel
Records show that the apprehension was bolstered by multiple major donors pausing their funding campaigns ahead of the exhibit’s opening.
asserted
donors → show → opening
This had caused the Winnipeg-based museum to fall short of its financial targets.
asserted
museum → cause → targets
The small exhibit, which occupies two walls on the fifth floor of the seven-level museum, has been denounced by many Jewish groups as an attack on Israeli statehood.
asserted
which → occupy → statehood
One trustee has resigned in protest, and the issue has led to wider public blowback, especially in Ottawa, where it has become a frequent topic of debate.
asserted
it → resign → debate
Heritage Minister Marc Miller, meanwhile, has criticized the display’s “regrettable” language about the Israel-Hamas conflict.
asserted
Miller → criticize → conflict
Several trustees at the museum, a Crown corporation, had proposed delaying the display to allow more time to address what they perceived as the “reputational risk” associated with it.
asserted
they → propose → it
They wanted to invite public consultation on the matter, the minutes confirm.
asserted
minutes → want → matter
They also wanted the museum to create a policy for what the minutes referred to as “quality control” for such exhibits.
asserted
minutes → want → exhibits
“There was concern from some Trustees that not allowing the public to ask questions was a missed opportunity on the part of the Museum, particularly as it related to the new exhibit, Palestine Uprooted: Nakba Past and Present,” stated a board package from May recapping previous meeting minutes.
uncertain
package → be → minutes
At least five formal motions, ranging from a call for postponement to a call for restructuring the display, were presented at meetings in November, February and May.
uncertain
motions → range → November
But the minutes reveal that a majority of trustees voted against those proposals.
asserted
majority → reveal → proposals
Board trustees and the museum’s chief executive are all appointed with approval from the federal Heritage Minister.
asserted
trustees → appoint → Minister
The board is kept separate from the day-to-day responsibilities of content curation, leaving direct oversight and approval of exhibits to management.
asserted
board → keep → management
The Nakba exhibit, which will remain on display for at least two years, examines what the museum describes as an “ongoing process” beginning in the 1940s, when hundreds of thousands of Palestinian Arabs were displaced from what is now Israel.
asserted
what → remain → Arabs
Israel has been at war with Hamas since Oct. 7, 2023, when the militant group launched a surprise attack, killing around 1,200 people.
asserted
group → launch → people
Israel’s retaliatory offensive has killed more than 72,000 Palestinians as of May, according to UN officials, and displaced about 90 per cent of Gaza’s population, causing a humanitarian crisis.
uncertain
offensive → kill → crisis
Internally, the matter at the museum became especially heated at meetings held from Feb. 25 to Feb. 26, when CEO Isha Khan told board members that they are not her “boss” and that she worried about their trust in her abilities, said five trustees who were in attendance.
asserted
who → become → attendance
The Globe is not identifying four of the trustees because current board members are prohibited from speaking publicly about their work at the museum.
asserted
members → identify → museum
Former trustee Mark Berlin, who resigned from the board just a few days before the exhibit opened on June 27, confirmed the account of the February meeting, describing it as “egregious.”
asserted
exhibit → resign → it
During this meeting, a motion to delay the exhibit was put up for a formal vote after a months-long back and forth during many board sessions, trustees told The Globe.
asserted
trustees → delay → Globe
Those who raised worries about the display were not unsupportive about its intention to spotlight Palestinian displacement; rather, they were concerned about its accuracy and the internal oversight that led up to its announcement, the trustees said.
asserted
trustees → raise → announcement
The minutes from February show that the postponement was voted down, with three in favour of postponing and six against.
asserted
postponement → show → postponing
The documents do not indicate who abstained and who spoke in favour or against the motion.
asserted
who → indicate → motion
In an interview, Ms. Khan acknowledged that several meetings about the exhibit were similarly “animated.”
asserted
meetings → acknowledge → exhibit
Although, referring to the votes on the various motions presented before June, she noted that a majority of the 11-member board repeatedly showed support for the display.
asserted
majority → refer → display
“I think the public reaction to the exhibit, of course, was far more than other exhibits that we’ve opened that have also been contentious for various communities,” she said.
asserted
she → think → communities
“Ultimately, for me, I did have the confidence of our board; or I would not proceed or we would’ve paused, should the board have directed that.”
asserted
board → have → that
Ms. Khan, whose tenure was renewed by Ottawa last fall for a second five-year period, said that during her time at the helm of the museum the board has never been shown the text or content of an exhibit before it went on display.
asserted
it → renew → display
Nor is she aware of any policies or conventions for the boards of other museums to examine or screen exhibits.
asserted
boards → examine → exhibits
Ms. Khan said there are several policies to ensure quality control when approaching contemporary issues.
asserted
Khan → say → issues
However, she said, after discussions on the Nakba exhibit, the museum is working on distilling those policies into a single document as a future reference.
asserted
museum → say → reference
Trustees in February voted in favour of this document being ready for their September board meeting.
asserted
document → vote → meeting
On the issue of fundraising, Ms. Khan said museum management continues to monitor the effect on donations.
asserted
management → say → donations
“What I can tell you is that I don’t believe, at this stage, we’ve seen a significant impact on fundraising as a result of opening the exhibit,” she said, though she did not provide specific figures.
asserted
she → tell → figures
The museum receives more than $28-million annually from the federal government to cover its operating costs, as well as around $1-million from donations.
asserted
museum → receive → donations
…and 31 more, not listed.
The Aporia
