Nearly 25 years after the Sept. 11 attacks, a Smithsonian affiliate in Michigan continues to use its 9/11 exhibits and anniversary programming to focus on discrimination and government actions in the attacks' aftermath, while giving less attention to the nearly 3,000 people killed that day, Fox News Digital found.
asserted
Digital → continue → people
The Arab American National Museum in Dearborn, Michigan, features an exhibit arguing that Arab Americans "suffered two-fold as a result of the tragic events of September 11th," both from the attacks themselves and from what the museum describes as unfair treatment by the U.S. government afterward.
asserted
museum → feature → government
Since its founding, the museum has repeatedly hosted programs examining what it describes as discriminatory consequences of the U.S. response to 9/11.
asserted
it → host → 9/11
Fox News Digital visited the museum earlier this month, reviewed its exhibits and gift shop, and examined years of anniversary programming and federal funding records.
The AANM has received hundreds of thousands of dollars in grant funding from the National Endowment for the Humanities and is also an affiliate of the Smithsonian Institution.
asserted
AANM → visit → Institution
The Smithsonian has been under intense scrutiny from conservative lawmakers in recent months for allegedly allowing political bias to influence its presentation of history.
uncertain
bias → allow → history
One placard criticizes the government’s post-9/11 detention of immigrants investigated for possible terrorist links, noting that "virtually none were charged" in connection with terrorism.
asserted
none → criticize → terrorism
"The Arab American community suffered two-fold as a result of the tragic events of September 11th.
asserted
community → suffer → 11th
As with all Americans, they suffered the horror and grief.
asserted
they → suffer → horror
However, Arab Americans were unfairly held responsible, yet not a single Arab American was found guilty of any connection to September 11th," it reads.
asserted
it → hold → 11th
On Sept. 11, 2001, 19 al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four passenger planes, crashing two into the World Trade Center, and one into the Pentagon.
asserted
terrorists → hijack → Pentagon
Passengers and crew fought back aboard United Flight 93, the fourth plane, prompting the hijackers to crash the plane in Pennsylvania.
asserted
Passengers → fight → Pennsylvania
The attacks killed 2,977 people and triggered the largest investigation in FBI history.
asserted
attacks → kill → history
The museum placard also argues that Arabs faced harsher immigration enforcement after the attacks, saying some were "deported for minor visa violations or petty offenses which previously would have been overlooked."
In the 11 months after the attacks, immigration authorities detained 762 noncitizens on immigration charges in connection with the FBI’s terrorism investigation, including for overstaying visas or entering the country illegally, according to a Justice Department inspector general report.
uncertain
authorities → argue → report
The watchdog found that some detainees with no terrorism ties were treated harshly and held under unnecessarily restrictive conditions.
asserted
detainees → find → conditions
Public opinion also showed a more complicated picture of the post-9/11 backlash.
asserted
opinion → show → backlash
President George W. Bush publicly urged Americans not to blame Muslims for the attacks, and polling later suggested attitudes toward Muslim Americans actually improved in the immediate aftermath.
uncertain
attitudes → urge → aftermath
The share of Americans who viewed Muslim Americans favorably rose from 45% in March 2001 to 59% in November, two months after the attacks, according to the Pew Research Center.
uncertain
who → view → Center
Beyond its permanent exhibit, AANM has repeatedly used programming around the 9/11 anniversary to examine discrimination and law-enforcement policies affecting Arab and Muslim communities.
asserted
AANM → use → communities
The museum holds a "solidarity" town hall each year, where criticism of the American reaction to 9/11 is often the focus.
asserted
criticism → hold → 9/11
The online description of the event does not mention the deaths connected to the attacks themselves, but rather "offers a safe space for communities to reflect and engage in dialogue about the harmful prejudices that Arab and Muslim (and anyone perceived to be Arab or Muslim) individuals face on both an individual and systemic level."
asserted
individuals → mention → level
One such town hall in 2018 examined "how communities of color have been targeted through the frame of national security and profiled as violent threats."
asserted
communities → examine → threats
A year later, the AANM’s annual town, which received support from the National Endowment for the Arts, criticized how "institutions and communities of color have been infiltrated" by law enforcement as well as how leaders of those groups have been "targeted" following 9/11.
asserted
leaders → receive → 9/11
The AANM was founded in 2005, partially in response to the increased scrutiny directed at the Arab American community following the attack on the World Trade Center.
asserted
AANM → found → Center
In addition to receiving well over half a million dollars in funding from the NEH over its lifetime to support its exhibits and educational programming, the museum also benefited from a $385,000 grant from the Department of Housing and Urban Development which helped it expand its physical footprint in 2013.
asserted
which → receive → 2013
It received further HUD funding, over half a million dollars, between 2017 and 2019 as well as at least $50,000 from the State Department between 2016 and 2017, according to annual reports published by the museum.
uncertain
It → receive → museum
Socialist-aligned Abdul El-Sayed, who is running for the Senate, drew strong support from the city earlier this month.
asserted
who → align → city
The museum’s focus extends beyond its criticism of the U.S. response to 9/11.
asserted
focus → extend → 9/11
On Sept. 10 — the eve of the 25th anniversary of the attacks — the AANM is scheduled to host a screening of "Seeds for Liberation," a film that portrays Hamas’ Oct. 7 terrorist attack as part of a decades-long Palestinian "struggle" and places it within a broader history of "anti-imperialist and decolonial movements."
asserted
that → schedule → movements
During Fox News Digital’s visit earlier this month, a section of the museum was dedicated to art criticizing Israel's alleged "occupation" of Palestinian land.
asserted
section → dedicate → land
One piece of art, the word "wall" presented in a stylized print, accuses the Israeli government of perpetuating a system of "apartheid."
asserted
piece → present → apartheid
The art installation broadly accuses Israel of targeting civilians in military operations, denying basic necessities to Palestinians and unjustly occupying land.
asserted
installation → accuse → land
One placard accompanying a sculpture states that Israel has killed more than 2,000 Palestinian children since Sept. 29, 2000, citing If Americans Knew (IAK).
asserted
Americans → accompany → IAK
Some pro-Palestinian organizations have distanced themselves from IAK over allegations of antisemitism and ties to white supremacists, allegations the group has disputed.
asserted
group → distance → supremacists
IAK also operates a news site that has published articles rejecting the designation of Hamas as a terrorist organization.
asserted
that → operate → organization
Another placard attached to a sculpture pulls a quote from Defense of Children International Palestine, which the Israeli government designated as a terrorist organization in 2021.
asserted
government → attach → 2021
DCIP and human rights groups have disputed the designation.
asserted
DCIP → dispute → designation
The museum gift shop also sells Palestinian-themed merchandise, including map-shaped magnets and key chains, coloring books promising to help children "explore Palestinian heritage" and keffiyehs.
asserted
children → sell → heritage
The AANM, Smithsonian, NEA and NEH did not respond to requests for comment after being reached by Fox News Digital on Friday.
asserted
AANM → respond → Friday
Smithsonian affiliates, like the AANM, are independently operated museums that maintain formal partnerships with the Smithsonian, providing them with access to artifact loans, educational resources and consultations from institutional experts.
asserted
that → operate → experts
In recent months, the Smithsonian has faced mounting pressure from Republican lawmakers and the president over allegations that its museums advance left-of-center ideological causes through their exhibits.
asserted
museums → face → exhibits
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
