Two legal groups are challenging Ontario’s new cash bail rules in court on Thursday, arguing that the system violates the Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
asserted
system → challenge → Rights
The province instituted the widespread use of cash bail last week, and it sparked confusion in bail courts over how to administer the rules.
asserted
it → institute → rules
Premier Doug Ford’s government said the new system, which was first announced last November, will improve public safety.
asserted
which → say → safety
Cash bail in Canada was mostly eliminated in the early 1970s and the Supreme Court of Canada has said judges should impose it only in exceptional circumstances.
asserted
judges → eliminate → circumstances
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Criminal Lawyers’ Association argue that Mr. Ford overstepped Ontario’s constitutional powers and are calling on the Ontario Superior Court to strike down the province’s new rules.
asserted
Ford → argue → rules
The case is scheduled in Toronto on Thursday morning, to be heard by Justice William Chalmers.
asserted
case → schedule → Chalmers
If a ruling is not rendered that day, the two legal groups plan to ask for an injunction from the judge to put cash bail on pause until a judgment is released.
asserted
judgment → render → pause
The legal groups, in their court filing, assert that Ontario’s cash bail rules “unconstitutionally rewrite the law of bail by eliminating the promise to pay.”
asserted
rules → assert → promise
The groups argue cash bail encroaches on exclusive federal jurisdiction over criminal law, as outlined in the Constitution.
asserted
bail → argue → Constitution
They further state that the federal Criminal Code specifically requires a court to favour a promise to pay rather than have actual cash handed over.
asserted
cash → state → promise
The groups also contend the cash bail rules violate the Charter of Rights’ provision that reasonable bail not be denied without just cause.
asserted
bail → contend → cause
In 1972, the federal government ended the system of paying cash to be freed from prison ahead of a trial, because it was deemed overly harsh for lower-income people.
asserted
it → end → people
In the Canadian system, when a person accused of a crime is required to provide a financial component as part of their release ahead of trial, it is generally a pledge of assets.
asserted
it → accuse → assets
Ontario, under Mr. Ford’s tough-on-crime ethos, has sought to make it harder to get bail by reviving the common use of cash bail.
asserted
it → seek → bail
New regulations in mid-August, enacted after legislative changes became official in early June, demand that any financial component in a bail release order be “paid in cash or by money order or bank draft” within two business days of release.
asserted
component → enact → release
This makes Ontario an outlier in Canada, the only province to pursue such a strategy.
asserted
Ontario → make → strategy
Ottawa recently toughened federal bail laws, to make it harder for accused people to gain release from jail ahead of trial, but the question of cash bail hadn’t been raised until Ontario surprised everyone in the justice system with its plan last November.
asserted
Ontario → toughen → plan
Nicole Myers, a criminology professor at Queen’s University, said Ontario’s move is an obvious violation of the Constitution and an egregious attack on accused people who are presumed innocent ahead of trial, especially those with lesser financial means.
asserted
who → say → means
Cash bail, she said, creates a two-tier justice system in which wealthier people buy their freedom before trial and the poor are incarcerated.
asserted
poor → say → trial
In the United States, research from the Prison Policy Initiative advocacy group showed that several hundred thousand people were jailed in 2023 ahead of trial, presumed innocent, because they couldn’t afford cash bail.
asserted
they → show → bail
“It’s a disaster of a law,” said Prof. Myers of cash bail in Ontario.
asserted
Myers → ’ → Ontario
Ontario Attorney-General Doug Downey last November said the province would craft regulations that abide by the Constitution.
asserted
that → say → Constitution
In mid-August, when Mr. Downey announced the system was ready to go, he cited the need to keep violent and repeat offenders behind bars.
asserted
he → announce → bars
Shakir Rahim, a director at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, said such rhetoric does not jibe with the system Ontario introduced.
asserted
Ontario → say → system
Any accused person, whether a first-time offender or someone charged with a serious crime, must produce cash if there’s a financial component in their bail release order.
asserted
person → accuse → order
Last Friday, a spokeswoman for Mr. Downey, Julia Facca, said in a statement: “Our government will never apologize for the actions we are taking to strengthen the bail system.”
asserted
we → say → system
Adam Weisberg, president of the Criminal Lawyers’ Association, said the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments in the Constitution is clear.
asserted
division → say → Constitution
Criminal law, including how bail works, belongs to Ottawa.
asserted
bail → include → Ottawa
“We have a strong argument,” said Mr. Weisberg.
asserted
Weisberg → have → argument
“The province doesn’t have the power to do what it’s done.”
asserted
it → have → what
The legal groups’ case against Ontario is being argued in court by Matthew Gourlay of Henein Hutchison Robitaille LLP.
asserted
case → argue → LLP
The Supreme Court of Canada in 2017, in a major ruling known as Antic on how bail laws should work, spoke strongly against cash bail.
asserted
laws → know → bail
The top court instructed judges to order cash bail only in exceptional circumstances and, if levied, to choose a figure the accused could afford to pay.
uncertain
accused → instruct → figure
Richard Wagner, who wrote the unanimous Antic judgment a few months before he became Chief Justice, highlighted the history of bail and cited Ottawa’s reforms in the early 1970s that effectively ended cash bail.
“Parliament limited cash bail for good reason,” he wrote in the judgment.
asserted
he → write → judgment
