The Supreme Court of Canada on Thursday agreed to hear an Aboriginal title case from British Columbia, where the provincial government is challenging the amount of land awarded to a small First Nation.
asserted
government → agree → Nation
In 2024, the Nuchatlaht won Canada’s second-ever declaration of Aboriginal title on Nootka Island, on the western edge of Vancouver Island.
asserted
Nuchatlaht → win → Island
But the lower court in B.C. at the time granted title to only a small portion of the Nuchatlaht’s claim.
uncertain
court → grant → claim
In April this year, the B.C. Court of Appeal ruled the declaration of Aboriginal title applied to the Nuchatlaht’s entire claim: 201 square kilometres – more than a third of Nootka Island.
uncertain
declaration → rule → Island
The Supreme Court’s decision to take the case comes amid a provincial election in British Columbia this month during which the array of Indigenous court cases involving Aboriginal title and other rights have vaulted such legal questions to the fore of public debate.
asserted
array → take → debate
The new case also lands as judges on the top court are saying yes to twice as many appeal applications than they had this decade.
asserted
they → land → applications
There had been criticism in the legal profession that the Supreme Court was not hearing enough cases.
asserted
Court → hear → cases
On Thursday, the Nuchatlaht appeal was one of five the court agreed to hear, increasing the total of new cases this year to 48, the most since 2017.
asserted
court → agree → 2017
A hearing on the Nuchatlaht case has not yet been scheduled and likely wouldn’t happen before next spring or possibly next fall.
uncertain
hearing → schedule → spring
The Nuchatlaht case centres around questions of what amounts to sufficient Indigenous occupation of land in the mid-1800s to establish Aboriginal title, when the British asserted sovereignty in the region, and how to delineate the geographic breadth of a claim if occupation of the land was variable.
uncertain
occupation → centre → land
The case will feature arguments over how courts apply the Supreme Court’s landmark Aboriginal title judgment in 2014, the Tsilhqot’in Nation ruling that marked the country’s first declaration of Aboriginal title to land in northwestern B.C.
asserted
that → feature → B.C.
In the B.C. government’s application to the Supreme Court to have its appeal of the Nuchatlaht ruling heard, the province cited a “time of intensifying Aboriginal title litigation in British Columbia and beyond” that urgently requires the consideration of the country’s top court.
asserted
that → hear → court
The provincial government argued that the B.C. Court of Appeal’s backing of the full Nuchatlaht claim to 201 square kilometres amounted to a “loosening of the test for Aboriginal title” and that the original declaration to about 11 square kilometres should be restored.
uncertain
declaration → argue → kilometres
Jack Woodward, counsel for the Nuchatlaht, said in an interview on Thursday that B.C.’s decision to appeal could backfire if the Supreme Court reaffirms the appellate-court ruling.
Mr. Woodward, who was one of the Tsilhqot’in Nation’s lawyers in 2014, also called on the next provincial government to pull out of the Supreme Court case and allow the B.C. Court of Appeal declaration of Aboriginal title to stand.
uncertain
declaration → say → title
The incumbent NDP is contesting a tight election against the opposition B.C. Conservative Party.
asserted
NDP → contest → Party
The final day to vote is Oct. 24.
asserted
day → vote → ?
“There’s no reason to continue with this,” Mr. Woodward said.
asserted
Woodward → ’ → this
“I would encourage a re-elected NDP government or the new government to think hard of whether they want to do this.”
asserted
they → encourage → this
The B.C. government declined to comment on Thursday, citing the election campaign and a government in caretaker mode with communication limited to critical health and safety information.
asserted
government → decline → information
Its case for Aboriginal title did not include land claimed by other Indigenous groups or private land.
asserted
case → include → groups
This is a contrast to last year’s Cowichan Tribes ruling at the trial court in B.C., which recognized Aboriginal title over about 800 acres of land in the Vancouver suburb of Richmond and sparked worries over implications for private-property ownership.
asserted
which → recognize → ownership
After the Nuchatlaht’s initial victory in 2024, winning Aboriginal title to a portion of their claim, the B.C. provincial government quietly gave up a portion of Nuchatlitz Park on the northwestern tip of Nootka Island as a result of that ruling.
uncertain
government → win → ruling
In the B.C. Court of Appeal ruling this year, the judgment noted that the province’s Forest Act and Park Act no longer applied to the 201 square kilometres to which the Nuchatlaht won a declaration of Aboriginal title.
asserted
Nuchatlaht → note → title
That means public access to the park is no longer assured.
asserted
access → mean → park
The Aporia
