U.S. import ban on Canadian molasses highlights sticky sugar industry feud
asserted
ban → highlight → feud
Company with Ontario refinery says it's been targeted by U.S. sugar lobby over molasses purity
asserted
it → say → purity
A U.S. ban on Canadian molasses imports has resurfaced allegations of sugar smuggling and an industry battle involving a company with a major refinery in Hamilton, Ont.
asserted
ban → resurface → Hamilton
Spats over dairy, automobiles and booze have become ingrained in the ongoing trade dispute between Canada and the U.S. during President Donald Trump's second term in office.
asserted
Spats → become → office
But when the U.S. announced earlier this month that it would ban the import of molasses, it left some scratching their heads.
asserted
it → announce → heads
The ban is due to take effect Sept. 29 alongside bans on motorcycles, most alcoholic drinks and some dairy products.
asserted
ban → take → motorcycles
It comes after months of American sugar producers lobbying their government to raise tariffs on foreign sugar products, saying they're being undercut by cheaper products from other countries.
asserted
they → come → countries
They're also taking aim at Canadian refineries, who they claim are importing mixes of raw sugar, molasses and water but disguising them as pure molasses as a way to circumvent sugar tariffs and quotas.
uncertain
they → take → tariffs
'Closing the spigot'
Sugaright, a division of Connecticut-based refiner CSC Sugar, said stopping the flow of watered-down molasses from Canada was a main topic of conversation at the International Sweetener Symposium, a major industry event held in Vail, Colo., this summer.
asserted
stopping → close → Vail
"Canadian 'molasses' containing substantial sugar is being viewed as a potential sugar-program circumvention problem, and not only does the U.S. sugar industry want the flow to stop, but now the federal government is fully engaged to 'finish the job' of closing the spigot completely
asserted
government → contain → spigot
," reads an August blog post on Sugaright's website.
asserted
post → read → website
The issue appears to stem from a case in the 1990s, when Michigan-based Heartland By-Products mixed molasses with sugar and water at an Ontario facility to import the mixture tariff-free.
asserted
Products → appear → mixture
The company would then refine it a second time in the U.S. to remove the molasses, sell the purified sugar, and ship the molasses back to Canada to reuse in its next batch.
asserted
company → refine → batch
The scheme was legal and approved by the U.S. government, but pressure from the sugar industry and a series of court cases and legislative restrictions forced the company to shut down operations in the 2000s.
asserted
pressure → approve → 2000s
Sugar companies' claims of disguised molasses still flowing unchecked from Canada appear to be contradicted by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates report from August, which states that molasses imports for sugar extraction are "on a rapid decline" and are currently projected to be "zero" for next year.
uncertain
imports → disguise → year
Company says it was targeted
Don Hill, chair of Sucro Can Sourcing, says the latest round of accusations is specifically aimed at his company, which is headquartered in Florida but has its biggest refinery in Hamilton.
asserted
which → say → Hamilton
"They just don't like the fact that we're legitimately shipping that molasses over to the U.S.
asserted
we → like → U.S.
And they've chosen to link what we do to what Heartland did 20 years ago, just to create that negative aura — just to cast aspersions and to make it seem all dodgy," Hill told CBC News.
asserted
Hill → choose → News
He says his fast-growing company was shipping about 50,000 tonnes of refiners' molasses annually to the U.S., which makes up a fraction of one per cent of the U.S. market — but marks a significant increase from a decade ago, before Sucro entered the picture.
asserted
Sucro → say → picture
U.S. Customs and Border Protection approved Sucro's molasses imports under the Harmonized Tariff Schedule in 2020.
asserted
Customs → approve → 2020
Hill, who is from Toronto but now lives in the U.K., says the sugar lobby has gone "berserk" trying to shut down his operation since then by pulling "every lever possible."
asserted
lobby → live → lever
Congress gave the USDA funding as part of the 2024 American Relief Act to test the purity of molasses coming from Canada through Buffalo, N.Y., the route used by Sucro.
asserted
Congress → give → Sucro
The resulting study found signs of "additives or blending," raising concerns about "potential circumvention of U.S. sugar tariff‑rate quotas."
asserted
study → result → quotas
It was not officially published by the USDA, but appears to have been made public in an April 20 article on the website of brokerage platform Ag Bull Trading.
asserted
It → publish → Trading
The industry has used this study in its arguments for shutting off molasses from Canada and raising tariffs on the product travelling through Buffalo.
asserted
industry → use → Buffalo
Sucro issued a rebuttal to the study, which Hill says does not have "an ounce or shred of legitimate facts behind it."
asserted
Hill → issue → it
He called for its retraction, citing "glaring mathematical errors," and said he offered data and corrections to the USDA.
asserted
he → call → USDA
He said he has not received any meaningful response.
asserted
he → say → response
In a statement emailed to CBC News, the USDA said, "This report was not formally published by USDA.
asserted
report → email → USDA
Sucro stopped importing molasses to the U.S. after completing its latest $135-million refinery in Hamilton in April, Hill says, and has instead been focusing on the Canadian market.
asserted
Hill → stop → market
"It just got to the point where the whole market, including the tariffs, including the sugar lobby, has just made everything so toxic and aggravating that there's just no point in even doing it," he said.
asserted
he → get → it
Sugar lobby backs ban
asserted
lobby → back → ban
The American Sugar Alliance, the main trade association and lobby organization representing major U.S. sugar producers and refiners, emailed CBC News a statement applauding the molasses import ban.
asserted
Alliance → represent → ban
"American sugar producers deeply appreciate President Donald Trump, the U.S. Trade Representative, and the Trump Administration's efforts to ensure that the products being imported into our country under our trade laws are actually the stated products," the statement said.
asserted
statement → appreciate → laws
"The Trump Administration is committed to upholding our laws, restoring fair trade, and putting American farmers and workers first."
asserted
Administration → commit → farmers
CBC News sent follow-up questions regarding Hill's accusations that the group targeted Sucro, but has not heard back.
asserted
group → send → Sucro
David Singerman, an associate professor of history at the University of Virginia and author of Unrefined: How Capitalism Reinvented Sugar, says sugar refining has always been a low-margin, high-volume business.
asserted
refining → reinvent → Sugar
He says this has inspired a long history of smuggling and tariff manipulation — and also of producers and refiners exerting political power to protect their profits.
asserted
producers → say → profits
Singerman says the lobby's influence gives sugar a "special status" in the American trade system, with a quota system backed up by a minimum price guarantee and high tariffs on foreign imports.
asserted
influence → say → imports
"Any time that there's a threat, or these growers perceive that someone is undercutting the system in some way, they get very nervous and they pick up the phone and call their friends in Washington.
asserted
they → be → Washington
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
