When Russian launched its invasion of Ukraine in 2022, reporters asked Washington Capitals captain Alexander Ovechkin for his thoughts.
asserted
reporters → launch → thoughts
Years before, Ovechkin boosted the Russian president in a social media campaign and featured Putin in his own Instagram profile photo.
asserted
Ovechkin → boost → photo
“He is my president,” Ovechkin said of Putin shortly after the invasion.
asserted
Ovechkin → say → invasion
“But [like] I said, I’m not in politics, I’m an athlete.”
asserted
I → say → politics
That’s over.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
He’s in politics now.
asserted
He → ’ → politics
“The thing about the video: I’m Russian,” Ovechkin told reporters Thursday.
asserted
Ovechkin → ’m → reporters
The video in question is one he taped for United Russia, a group supporting Putin, ahead of parliamentary elections.
asserted
he → tap → elections
Ovechkin appears in the video alongside Sergei Lavrov, the Russian foreign minister, Margarita Simonyan, the editor-in-chief of the state-controlled media outlet RT, and others.
asserted
Ovechkin → appear → outlet
“I’m for peace and love, and I hope, in the world, it doesn’t matter who you are,” Ovechkin told reporters.
asserted
Ovechkin → ’m → reporters
“I hope everybody understands everybody wants peace, and everybody hope everything’s going to be OK in the world.”
asserted
everything → hope → world
A day before, the Capitals released a statement that lauded Ovechkin and treated his video participation in the same mundane, neutral tone.
asserted
that → release → tone
“Alex Ovechkin is a Russian citizen who lives in Moscow with his family during the offseason and will live there following his retirement.
asserted
who → live → retirement
This summer, while in Russia, he was asked by his country to participate in a video campaign,” the team said.
asserted
team → ask → campaign
“As the longest-tenured athlete in Washington, DC and a pillar of the community, his focus and ours is on the season ahead and the continued impact he makes on the ice and in our city.
asserted
he → tenure → city
It’s undeniable that Ovechkin has had an impact on DC during his long NHL career, never playing anywhere else, bringing the Capitals their first and only Stanley Cup and becoming the sport’s greatest goalscorer.
asserted
Ovechkin → ’ → Cup
But now that Ovechkin is also into politics – by choice – it’s fair to start asking what the impact of those politics is, too, even if he doesn’t want to talk about it.
asserted
he → ’ → it
In an awkward bit of timing, in an indictment unsealed Tuesday, US federal prosecutors accused five men of being part of a network planning to assassinate Russian dissidents and others on US soil, including one who reportedly lived in Washington.
uncertain
who → unseal → Washington
Just one concrete example of the Putin government in action – its continued impact, if you like – right in Ovechkin’s adopted home town.
asserted
you → continue → town
Elsewhere, on X, former NHL goaltender Dominik Hasek – a Czech icon who has been an outspoken Putin critic for years – tore into the Capitals’ statement on Ovechkin for turning a blind eye to the impact of that politics in Europe.
asserted
who → tear → Europe
“This statement ignores the hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of Ukrainians and Russians killed or maimed – casualties for which Ovechkin bears a significant share of responsibility through his public stance,” Hasek wrote.
asserted
Hasek → ignore → stance
A “significant” share may be stretching it, but Hasek’s broader point is that there ought to be a reckoning here, that the people involved should take ownership.
uncertain
people → stretch → ownership
For Ovechkin, that would probably mean repeating the message that he supported as publicly in the US as he does in Russia, instead of distancing himself from it the moment it becomes uncomfortable and offering “peace and love”.
asserted
it → mean → peace
For the Capitals, taking a moral stand could mean anything from making a donation to a Ukrainian charity to stripping Ovechkin of his captaincy, to barring him from playing.
uncertain
taking → take → him
But that would mean the organization would have to have the guts to address it as more than an uncomfortable topic to be endured just long enough to look like anyone cared, which is also what happened Thursday in the media scrum.
asserted
what → mean → scrum
After answering a couple of questions about the United Russia video, Ovechkin pivoted.
asserted
Ovechkin → answer → video
“All right,” he said, “let’s do hockey questions.”
asserted
’s → say → questions
“Happy birthday,” one reporter said almost immediately, ushering back the illusion of normalcy.
asserted
reporter → say → normalcy
“Did you get a cake?” Ovechkin replied he is on a diet.
asserted
he → get → diet
Everyone laughed.
asserted
Everyone → laugh → ?
No one in the scrum made him answer for anything.
asserted
him → make → anything
When an ESPN reporter pressed him later with questions on the video and the invasion, Ovechkin said he is “not in politics” and “can’t say who’s right and who’s wrong” before abruptly ending the interview.
asserted
who → press → interview
Fans are now left to figure out an unwindable ethical quandary that was never theirs to solve.
asserted
that → leave → quandary
If you keep watching or keep wearing your Ovechkin jersey, you’re liable to be accused of tacitly supporting a repressive regime; if you choose to boycott, you’re accused of “politicizing” sports.
asserted
you → keep → sports
The fans are left holding the bag, searching for accountability, while those responsible for it walk away behind a mealy mouthed word cloud.
asserted
those → leave → cloud
It doesn’t have to be that way.
asserted
It → have → ?
If Ovechkin, the Capitals and, by extension, the NHL, want the fans to hold them all accountable, so be it.
asserted
it → want → extension
Fans can keep asking the questions most of the media room wouldn’t – they make this all mean something.
asserted
this → keep → something
Just because Ovechkin can’t muster an opinion (outside Russia, anyway), it doesn’t mean fans can’t.
asserted
fans → muster → Russia
We don’t have to pretend to be neutral.
asserted
We → have → ?
The Aporia
