A few weeks ago, the worst thing you could say about Ed Sheeran was that his music was a bit bland.
uncertain
music → say → Sheeran
A Guardian music writer once compared it to “aural wallpaper”.
asserted
writer → compare → wallpaper
Which was a little bit rude to wallpaper: there are some very interesting designs out there!
asserted
Which → be → wallpaper
I don’t need to tell you what people are saying about Sheeran now, do I?
asserted
I → need → Sheeran
The pop star has been in the news for days after he apparently crumbled when billionaire Robert Kraft demanded Macklemore be pulled from his tour because of the rapper’s pro-Palestine advocacy.
asserted
Macklemore → crumble → advocacy
As if he didn’t already look pathetic enough, Sheeran then released a statement throwing Macklemore under the bus.
asserted
Sheeran → look → bus
“After Macklemore’s performances at my New Jersey shows, venues on my upcoming tour dates communicated that they would pull the shows if he was still supporting,” Sheeran wrote on Instagram.
asserted
Sheeran → communicate → Instagram
Macklemore, he said, had “asked to join my tour last year and I agreed, because I respect him as an artist”.
asserted
I → say → artist
(In other words: “I barely know the guy!
asserted
I → know → guy
Macklemore begged to be on my tour and I was kind enough to say yes!’)
asserted
I → beg → tour
The pop star also gave the both-sides treatment to the ongoing genocide in Gaza and he said he didn’t like to be “political”.
asserted
he → give → Gaza
Except, of course, when it comes to causes like Ukraine, which he knows he won’t get into any sort of trouble for supporting.
asserted
he → come → trouble
I won’t rehash everything that’s been said about Sheeran’s cowardice, but please enjoy this viral TikTok where a woman called Erin Tatum cheekily welcomes Sheeran to the disability community.
asserted
woman → rehash → community
“My back is full of metal,” she says, “so I too know exactly what it feels like when your spine doesn’t work like it used to!
asserted
it → say → what
Kraft isn’t the only billionaire trying to stifle criticism of Israel and stamp out speech: it’s a prevailing theme of our times.
asserted
it → try → times
Pro-Israel billionaires like Kenneth Griffin have used their donation money to pressure universities like Harvard to oppose students’ criticism of Israel.
asserted
billionaires → use → Israel
Meanwhile our billionaire president and his administration have aggressively cracked down on pro-Palestinian protesters, sanctioned law firms perceived to be political enemies, restricted how news outlets cover the White House, and interfered with academic freedom at higher education institutes.
asserted
outlets → crack → institutes
The Trump administration had also updated its immigration guidelines so foreigners could potentially be denied a green card for expressing anti-American or anti-Israeli political opinions.
uncertain
foreigners → update → opinions
As the ACLU attorney Jonathan Hafetz has noted: “We are seeing the gravest assault on freedom of speech at least since the McCarthy era.”
asserted
We → note → era
Normally news stories about billionaires trying to stamp out free speech are depressing.
asserted
stories → try → speech
But watching Kraft’s intimidation attempts backfire on him and his little buddy Ed has been an absolute joy to watch.
asserted
attempts → watch → him
It seems Kraft didn’t realize that, for some people, morality is more important than money.
asserted
morality → seem → money
It seems he didn’t foresee that all of Sheeran’s opening acts and his live band would withdraw in solidarity with Macklemore and Palestine, amplifying the pro-Palestinian statements that he was so desperate to quash.
asserted
he → seem → statements
“I cannot stand by and allow billionaires to use their position of power to silence the rightful voices of those who speak up against Israeli genocide and who highlight the savage murder of children,” the Irish singer Aaron Rowe said in a statement announcing his departure from the tour.
asserted
singer → stand → tour
Kraft may have succeeded in removing Macklemore from Sheeran’s tour, but he hasn’t silenced him.
uncertain
he → succeed → him
Macklemore, to his credit, has kept trying to steer the conversation back to what is happening to Palestinians, rather than what is happening to Sheeran’s brand.
asserted
what → keep → brand
On Wednesday, Macklemore said he’d donate the entirety of the $1m he has earned from Sheeran’s Loop tour to organizations supporting Palestinians and urged Kraft to match his donation.
asserted
he → say → donation
Kraft responded by saying Sheeran had “called me and asked me to commit $2 million to match his donation to aid in the region to fight this humanitarian crisis”.
asserted
Sheeran → respond → crisis
He did not specify if he would do this or who he might donate to.
uncertain
he → specify → who
Kraft also insisted he wasn’t trying to diminish the “suffering of innocent Palestinians”; he just didn’t want to “obscure the responsibility of Hamas”.
asserted
he → insist → Hamas
There is only one person trying to obscure responsibility here, and that is Kraft.
asserted
that → be → responsibility
What is happening in Gaza and the West Bank cannot be glibly boiled down to a conflict against Hamas that has resulted in unfortunate suffering.
asserted
that → happen → suffering
It is, as many experts and human rights organizations, have said, a genocide that US taxpayers are helping to fund.
asserted
taxpayers → say → that
There are no real plans for peace or Palestinian self-determination on the horizon: the goal seems to be cleansing all the Palestinians from the territory so Trump can build luxury buildings.
asserted
Trump → be → buildings
As Macklemore has stated, the focus of this story shouldn’t be on pop stars, it should be on what is happening to Palestinians.
asserted
what → state → Palestinians
So let me recount just a few of the things that have happened recently.
asserted
that → let → things
Starting with last weekend, when a 27-year-old woman who was almost eight months pregnant was shot in the head in Gaza by Israeli forces, while she was sitting in her tent.
asserted
she → start → tent
Both Iman Shalouf and her unborn baby died a few hours later.
asserted
Shalouf → die → ?
At least nine other people were killed in the span of 48 hours during what the media still persists in calling a ceasefire (or sometimes, if they’re being daring, “a fragile ceasefire”.)
asserted
they → kill → hours
Kids continue to be killed in Gaza at staggering rates.
asserted
Kids → continue → rates
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
