The Western Australian government was trying to have its cake and eat it too when it walked into the Court of Appeal last week.
asserted
it → try → Appeal
Child sexual abuse survivor Dion Barber was last year awarded nearly $3 million in compensation for abuse he suffered while in state care in the 1980s and 1990s.
asserted
he → award → 1980s
The government wanted to argue it was too much, or shouldn’t have been given at all — a case even the most talented politician wouldn't be able to sell to the public.
asserted
politician → want → public
So it tried to have it both ways.
asserted
it → try → it
It paid Mr Barber's compensation in full and promised it wouldn't take anything back if it was successful in its appeal.
But at the same time, the government argued the court had made errors in its decision, including that it should be "immune from liability" because staff acted in good faith.
asserted
staff → pay → faith
That's significant because, as the government told the court, there are almost 200 people with similar circumstances currently seeking compensation from the state.
asserted
government → tell → state
A successful appeal would have effectively created a double standard — one for Mr Barber, and one for everyone who came after him.
asserted
who → create → him
The three Supreme Court justices who heard the government's case — including Chief Justice Peter Quinlan — rejected it on the same day, and this week published their reasons for doing so.
asserted
who → hear → reasons
In their view, the state government was seeking a decision "to facilitate its negotiation on those many other claims, presumably on a basis more favourable than the outcome in Mr Barber's case".
uncertain
government → seek → case
"It would be inappropriate," the judges wrote, for the court to trawl back through the "deeply personal" evidence of the case "solely for the purpose of facilitating the state's resolution of other claims".
uncertain
court → write → claims
"If the state wishes to deny another claim, it ought to do so, openly and transparently, in the ordinary course of litigation … rather than on the basis of an advisory opinion from this court.
uncertain
it → wish → court
In other words, if the government wants to reduce compensation for a victim-survivor, it needs to say it to their face, and the face of every Western Australian.
asserted
it → want → Australian
A question of liability
Questioned about the decision on Tuesday, WA Premier Roger Cook said the government acted on "the best legal advice".
asserted
government → question → advice
"We were seeking to clarify elements of the law so that we could provide justice to more people faster," he said.
uncertain
he → seek → people
Having a clear reference point on damages, and clear answers on how the courts interpret the law, can narrow the scope of negotiations with those remaining 200 people.
asserted
courts → have → people
But what the premier didn't mention — and what the Court of Appeal highlighted — was that a reference point could also help reduce the amount the state had to pay, or if they would have to pay at all.
"
uncertain
they → mention → amount
If the Christian Brothers went to the Court of Appeal to say that we knowingly sent a child into the hands of a paedophile but we don't want to be found liable or responsible for it, there would be outrage in the parliament, outrage by the government and outrage in the community," Mr Barber's lawyer, Hugo Seymour, told 102.5 ABC Perth last week.
asserted
lawyer → go → Perth
"Yet that's exactly what the Department of Communities and the Insurance Commission of WA have done in the name of the state."
Shouting match
The Insurance Commission is the state government's insurer.
asserted
Commission → do → match
A spokesperson declined to answer questions, only saying: "We respect the decision of the Court of Appeal."
asserted
We → decline → Appeal
Shadow Attorney-General Nick Goiran said questions about the commission's conduct went beyond Mr Barber's case.
asserted
questions → say → case
"When it comes to the culture of handling these claims, these very difficult, sensitive claims for victims of sexual abuse, the organisation that needs to change is the Insurance Commission," he said.
uncertain
he → come → abuse
"And that's where [Treasuer] Rita Saffioti needs to step up and do something about it."
Saffioti was asked about the matter during question time and pointed to laws Labor passed which removed a time limit restricting when survivors could bring legal action.
uncertain
survivors → need → action
"Over $110 million has been paid to over 300 victims in this state," she told parliament, before getting into a shouting match with the opposition.
asserted
she → pay → opposition
"The attorney-general and I always look at how we can make sure we get the best outcome for Western Australians."
asserted
we → look → Australians
'Further torment'
Behind all of those arguments though is Mr Barber, who despite the government's assurances, said the last year had been "further torment".
asserted
year → say → assurances
Mr Barber has also yet to receive an apology from the government.
asserted
Barber → have → government
"It would be nice to get in one sense, but they're just words," he told 102.5 ABC Perth.
asserted
he → get → sense
"If they're not really meant, then I'd rather see change.
asserted
I → mean → change
How the government chooses to resolve those 200 remaining cases will give an indication of whether this final resolution of Mr Barber's case has prompted the change he hopes for.
asserted
he → choose → change
The Aporia
