If a Republican president gains more power to pressure broadcasters, the next Democratic president can use it, too.
asserted
president → gain → it
Stephanie Slade, an editor at Reason magazine, raised that prospect in a conversation with Sean Speer on Hub Dialogues.
asserted
Slade → raise → Dialogues
For conservatives who feel shut out of major media outlets, taking them on can feel overdue.
asserted
taking → shut → them
Slade asks what they stand to lose when they give Washington more say over who gets heard.
asserted
who → ask → say
The dispute goes to the heart of Slade’s book, Fusionism: Liberty, Virtue, and the Future of the American Right.
asserted
dispute → go → Right
For much of the postwar period, she argues, American conservatives saw limited government and strong moral traditions as reinforcing each other.
asserted
conservatives → argue → other
A growing faction on the Right, dubbed the New Right, now sees government as a way to advance those traditions.
asserted
faction → grow → traditions
Slade discussed the consequences in an episode produced in partnership with the New North America Initiative at the University of Calgary’s School of Public Policy.
asserted
Slade → discuss → Policy
1. Fusionism held that liberty and virtue need each other
Slade defines fusionism as the idea that “both liberty and virtue are necessary for human flourishing.”
asserted
liberty → hold → flourishing
Frank Meyer, writing in National Review in the 1950s and 1960s, saw a connection between two traditions that shaped American conservatism.
asserted
that → write → conservatism
Classical liberalism supplied the case for individual rights and limits on government.
asserted
liberalism → supply → government
The Judeo-Christian tradition offered guidance on how to use that freedom and what people owe each other.
asserted
people → offer → other
Meyer argued that a free society depends on people capable of governing themselves, and that developing good character requires the freedom to make choices.
asserted
developing → argue → choices
That idea predates Ronald Reagan’s winning coalition of economic libertarians, social conservatives, and Cold War hawks.
asserted
idea → predate → libertarians
Slade found it in thinkers whose reputations might put them in different camps.
uncertain
reputations → find → camps
Russell Kirk, a traditionalist, opposed the Vietnam-era draft on grounds of individual liberty.
asserted
Kirk → oppose → liberty
Friedrich Hayek, the free-market economist, emphasized that markets depend on rules and habits of cooperation passed down over generations.
asserted
markets → emphasize → generations
Slade shares some of the New Right’s concerns about cultural decline
Slade thinks the New Right is asking a fair question about who helps young people work out how to live a good life.
asserted
people → share → life
She also thinks libertarians have too often brushed it off by treating questions of character as entirely personal.
asserted
libertarians → think → character
Her answer starts with families, religious congregations, and neighbourhood groups, where people can pass down what they’ve learned and put it into practice together.
asserted
they → start → practice
That is also the point on which she breaks with thinkers such as Patrick Deneen, the postliberal political theorist and author of Why Liberalism Failed.
asserted
Liberalism → break → Deneen
Where postliberals see an opportunity for government to revive weakened institutions, Slade worries that government can displace them.
asserted
government → see → them
She gives the example of mutual aid societies.
asserted
She → give → societies
When a public program takes over an association’s work, she argues, people may lose a reason to show up for their neighbours and a place to get to know them.
uncertain
people → take → them
In a country where people disagree about what a good life looks like, she puts her faith in “the hard work of persuasion.”
asserted
she → disagree → persuasion
Cultural resentment helps explain the New Right’s appeal
Slade sees the New Right’s ideas gaining traction among some young men online.
asserted
ideas → help → men
She points in particular to young white men who believe diversity programs have made it harder for them to get ahead in school or at work.
asserted
them → point → work
If they see universities and the media as hostile to them, they may have little patience for conservatives who urge restraint.
uncertain
who → see → restraint
A movement that promises to hit back has a ready audience.
asserted
that → promise → audience
She sees a related pattern in the broader Trump coalition.
asserted
She → see → coalition
In January 2021, 60 percent of Trump voters surveyed by YouGov said foreign trade helped the U.S. economy.
asserted
trade → survey → economy
On a separate question, 60 percent said it reduced the number of jobs for Americans.
asserted
it → say → Americans
About nine in 10 said Christianity was under attack in America, and a similar share saw the mainstream media as aligned with Democrats.
asserted
share → say → Democrats
For Slade, that helps explain how voters with different views about the economy could find common cause in Trump.
uncertain
voters → help → Trump
Institutional neutrality protects conservatives, too
asserted
neutrality → protect → conservatives
Speer asked why conservatives should try to restore neutral rules in institutions they believe have already taken sides.
asserted
they → ask → sides
Slade pointed to the room the First Amendment gives people to build their own outlets.
asserted
Amendment → point → outlets
A conservative who thinks the major television networks overlook a story can cover it on a podcast or YouTube channel.
asserted
networks → think → podcast
Those protections matter most when the people in power dislike what the speaker has to say.
asserted
speaker → matter → what
She also pointed to Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, a 2014 ruling in which the U.S. Supreme Court held that applying a federal contraceptive-coverage mandate to business owners with religious objections violated a federal religious-freedom law.
asserted
applying → point → law
…and 13 more, not listed.