A New World Order
Secretary of State Marco Rubio has once again attacked the global system of laws, norms, and principles instituted to place limits on international armed violence.
asserted
Rubio → attack → violence
Advocating for a return to might-makes-right barbarism during a keynote speech on Friday, Rubio threatened to use military force against the International Criminal Court, which prosecutes individuals accused of the gravest atrocities.
uncertain
which → advocate → atrocities
Warning that if the ICC was “foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans, our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general Pompey when he said to those who were trying to invoke their city’s charters against his legions.
asserted
who → warn → legions
Rubio’s effort to undermine the principles and rules that regulate the means and methods of warfare and the humanitarian protection of civilian populations, sick and wounded combatants, and prisoners of war is part of the Trump administration’s wide-ranging effort to upend the rules-based international order that the U.S. has championed — but often failed to abide by — since World War II.
asserted
U.S. → undermine → II
Speaking before the conservative Federalist Society at the National Lawyers Convention in Washington, D.C., Rubio disparaged the ICC as a “fake court” and “an unelected world tribunal, which claims to supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those who never signed up for it.”
uncertain
who → speak → it
Rubio’s tirade was the latest salvo in a long-running campaign against the ICC by President Donald Trump’s administration, which has vowed to cripple the court.
asserted
which → run → court
In October, after former ICC judge Navanethem “Navi” Pillay was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, Trump — who has relentlessly campaigned for the award — was enraged and derided the South African jurist as “a liberal person who works at the United Nations, who nobody has ever heard of.”
asserted
nobody → award → who
Hours after the award was announced, the U.S. imposed sanctions on the ICC.
asserted
U.S. → announce → ICC
These latest sanctions are intended to turn the judicial organ into an economic pariah.
asserted
sanctions → intend → pariah
They prohibited the court from conducting dollar-denominated transactions, froze its U.S.-based assets, and barred the judicial body from using the U.S. banking system or working with American institutions — effectively blacklisting the court.
asserted
They → prohibit → court
The ICC was created by the international community to investigate and prosecute war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, and the crime of aggression — when one country uses armed force against another without legal justification.
asserted
country → create → justification
The Hague, Netherlands-based court is unique as a permanent judicial organ capable of prosecuting anyone, infantry soldiers and sitting heads of state alike, for humanity’s gravest crimes if they are committed in the territories of its 125 member states.
asserted
they → base → states
The ICC is critically a court of last resort that will only intervene when domestic jurisdictions either fail to hold their own service members and political leaders accountable, or when state parties to the court call for an investigation.
asserted
parties → intervene → investigation
While the Trump administration’s timing in sanctioning the ICC
asserted
timing → sanction → ICC
was notable, this latest strike against the court is just one facet of the Trump administration’s yearslong campaign to — in the words of Rubio’s State Department — “dismantle” it.
asserted
strike → dismantle → it
The effort dates back to 2020, when the first Trump administration imposed sanctions on ICC officials after the court opened an investigation into alleged U.S. war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in Afghanistan.
asserted
court → date → Afghanistan
Overturned by the Biden administration in 2021, the first round of U.S. sanctions against the court were replaced last February by a new series targeting the court’s chief prosecutor, its two deputy prosecutors, and six of its judges.
asserted
round → overturn → judges
All of these judges had either investigated the actions of U.S. nationals in Afghanistan or were part of the ICC’s decision to issue arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for their co-perpetration of “the war crime of starvation” and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
asserted
All → investigate → Gaza
Though the litany of prior U.S. sanctions against the court impacted the lives of those nine individuals and their families — cutting them off from their bank accounts, emails, and blocking their travel — the actions were piecemeal and did not fully upend the work of the court.
asserted
actions → impact → court
Now, all of the ICC’s U.S.-based partner organizations have six months to completely cut ties with the court or face legal retribution.
asserted
all → have → retribution
What’s more, since the current global economic system is built upon the U.S. dollar, international — particularly European — organizations often preemptively abide by U.S. sanctions even if their workings fall completely outside of America’s jurisdiction.
asserted
workings → ’ → jurisdiction
For example, when the French company Axa terminated its life and health insurance contracts with the ICC on October 1, the insurer reportedly cited the escalating campaign by the U.S. against the court.
uncertain
insurer → terminate → court
Absent the implementation of effective countermeasures — like amending and enforcing the EU Blocking Statute, which can shield EU individuals and businesses from “unlawful” third-country sanctions — this latest move by the U.S. may not kill the ICC, but it will cut off the judicial organ’s blood supply.
uncertain
it → amend → supply
For over 80 years, the U.S. has enjoyed the privilege of proscribing — and not necessarily abiding by — international law.
asserted
U.S. → enjoy → law
American representatives served as the chief arbiters of the post-World War II Nuremberg and Tokyo military tribunals that prosecuted Nazi and Japanese war criminals, which are seen by many in the field as the birthplaces of modern international criminal law.
asserted
which → serve → law
American arbiters, notably U.S. Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson, led the victors of the Second World War as they tried and prosecuted their former adversaries for novel notions of wrongdoing, including crimes against peace and crimes against humanity.
asserted
they → lead → humanity
These newly defined criminal acts form the bedrock of the ICC’s jurisdiction.
asserted
acts → define → jurisdiction
At the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, all 25 major Japanese leaders were convicted, with seven receiving death sentences.
asserted
seven → convict → sentences
Judge Radhabinod Pal of India argued for the acquittal of all 25.
asserted
Pal → argue → 25
In his dissent, he complained that the tribunal dispensed victors’ justice.
asserted
tribunal → complain → justice
He said that America’s atomic strikes on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were among the most criminal acts of the conflict, yet immune from prosecution.
asserted
strikes → say → prosecution
Indeed, the international criminal justice system was never intended to hold the U.S. or its allies accountable.
asserted
U.S. → intend → ?
And in the decades since, consecutive U.S. administrations have wielded the nation’s political and military strength to avoid any semblance of international legal oversight.
asserted
administrations → wield → oversight
Although relations with the court have oscillated over the course of Democratic and Republican administrations, the U.S. has always been wary of the court’s potential jurisdiction over American nationals.
asserted
U.S. → oscillate → nationals
From the court’s conception, in which the U.S. played a role, the global hegemon has continuously shown its disdain for the court’s territorial jurisdiction.
asserted
hegemon → play → jurisdiction
While the ICC cannot prosecute any American nationals for their actions in the U.S., it does have jurisdiction over acts undertaken, by U.S. nationals or otherwise, within the territories of its member nations including Afghanistan, Libya, and Palestine.
asserted
it → prosecute → Afghanistan
Under the Clinton administration in the 1990s, the U.S. was one of only seven drafting nations to initially veto the Rome Statute — the international treaty that created the ICC — due to its concerns over the court’s territorial jurisdiction.
asserted
that → draft → jurisdiction
Later, in 2002, the same year the ICC was established, the George W. Bush administration signed the Hague Invasion Act into law.
asserted
administration → establish → law
The act, which is still in effect, grants the president the legal backing to use military force against the court in order to free any U.S. or allied person held or imprisoned by the ICC.
asserted
which → grant → ICC
The Bush administration subsequently pressured dozens of countries to agree to never transfer U.S. nationals to the ICC, and threatened to cut military assistance, cease counterterrorism operations, or cut humanitarian aid if these states did not comply.
asserted
states → pressure → aid
…and 33 more, not listed.