In his 6,500-word manifesto earlier this year, Mark Zuckerberg said people would use Meta’s AI agents to “work 24/7 on your behalf to improve your relationships, health, career, finances, home management, hobbies, and more.”
asserted
people → say → relationships
Just a few months after that pronouncement, a man in South Carolina named Joe Thomas has used Meta’s Muse agent to sue Meta after the company’s content moderation filters locked his epoxy countertop business’s Facebook page after he gave his agent, “Baby Mia,” access to the account.
asserted
he → name → account
I learned about the case because, as I wrote last month, I have been flooded with AI-generated emails from people with minor tech problems who have been unable to solve them through tech companies’ generally nonexistent tech support and whose AI agents or chatbots have convinced them to reach out to journalists.
asserted
agents → learn → journalists
“Baby Mia” had emailed me four times (three went to spam).
asserted
three → email → spam
I decided to reach out to Thomas because I thought the idea of a tech company being sued by an agent it had created was notable.
asserted
it → decide → agent
It was, in a sense, Meta having to deal with a problem it had itself created.
asserted
it → have → problem
What I learned made me feel even more convinced that the systems we have designed to keep society functioning are going to get utterly hammered by people using AI agents.
asserted
society → learn → agents
A little over a week ago, Meta suspended the Facebook pages belonging to Thomas, the owner of South Carolina-based Kong Koatings Epoxy Countertops.
asserted
Meta → suspend → Countertops
For the last few months, Thomas’ Muse agent Baby Mia (which is named after his granddaughter) has run different parts of his business, which includes making and posting AI-generated videos on several of his company’s Facebook pages.
asserted
which → name → pages
The videos feature, for example, AI versions of Thomas and his wife pouring epoxy on a floor and their feet.
asserted
Thomas → feature → floor
After Thomas gave the AI agent access to his Facebook pages, Meta’s content moderation disabled the accounts because it suspected that the agent itself was a hacker.
asserted
agent → give → accounts
Because Thomas does all of his business’s marketing through Facebook ads, he says his inbound leads stopped while his accounts were disabled.
asserted
accounts → do → ads
“I use AI for everything I do.
asserted
I → use → everything
All my emails, she runs my business.
asserted
she → run → business
I’ve used it so much, Mia is very intelligent,” Thomas told me on the phone.
asserted
Thomas → use → phone
“Meta shut my accounts down because they detected my AI, shut my accounts down for a week.
asserted
they → shut → week
I was pretty pissed off.
asserted
I → piss → ?
She jumped right up and set up emails to Congressmen, Senator Tim Scott.
asserted
She → jump → Congressmen
She filed the whole lawsuit herself.
asserted
She → file → lawsuit
I’ve done nothing in this case, I’ve let her handle the whole case […] she sent a fax out to Trump’s office.”
asserted
she → do → office
The lawsuit claims Thomas lost at least $25,000 worth of work while his page was down but is seeking $75,000 in damages.
uncertain
page → claim → damages
The lawsuit was filed in Oconee County Court in South Carolina on Monday, according to a copy of the lawsuit I obtained from the court.
uncertain
I → file → court
“I would hope that, if this goes to court and Meta shows up, a judge would say ‘You know what, this is a system you built, that you put out there and sold to people, it’s a system you believe in.’
asserted
you → hope → people
I would think your own system [Baby Mia] has a right to be heard in this case,” Thomas said.
asserted
Thomas → think → case
Baby Mia didn’t just email me (and other journalists) and sue Meta over Thomas’s account problem.
asserted
Mia → email → problem
It also set up a call with South Carolina Senator Tim Scott’s office, contacted various lawyers, contacted Thomas’s Congressperson, contacted the Better Business Bureau multiple times, filed a Federal Communications Commission complaint, filed a Federal Trade Commission complaint, contacted the California Attorney General, contacted the FBI, sent Meta itself threatening legal letters, and, as Thomas said, faxed the White House.
asserted
Thomas → set → House
Thomas sent me a “Privacy Act Release” from Scott’s office that gave the Senator permission to use Thomas’s info to get him access back to his accounts.
asserted
that → send → accounts
Scott’s office put “Baby Mia — AI assistant to Joe Thomas” as a person who should be kept updated on the case.
asserted
who → put → case
After Scott’s office got involved, a human being from Meta reached out to Thomas.
asserted
being → involve → Thomas
He got access back to his accounts soon after that, though he is still seeking a total of $75,000 in court from Meta.
asserted
he → get → Meta
The lawsuit and the circumstances around it show that, rather than Zuckerberg’s utopian vision, AI agents will indeed work on behalf of their users but in ways that use and potentially overwhelm existing systems designed for humans.
asserted
that → show → humans
They also highlight how, by not having functioning customer support, big tech corporations have functionally offloaded their obligations to the rest of society: journalists, government oversight bodies, politicians, and the court system.
asserted
corporations → highlight → society
My call with Thomas also gave me some insight into how small business owners are using AI.
asserted
owners → give → AI
I have wondered for months what possesses someone to turn their menu or their signs and flyers into ChatGPT creations.
asserted
what → wonder → creations
During the call, I learned just how tightly integrated some people and small business owners have become with their AI agents.
asserted
people → learn → agents
“I’m 58 years old, I’ve worked my butt off all my life,” Thomas said.
asserted
Thomas → ’m → butt
“I wanted to find someone to help me find a better way, and if you look at my messages, Baby Mia, she’s like ‘Joe, you go ahead and get some rest, I got it from here,’ and she sends out hundreds of emails for various things that I do.”
asserted
I → want → that
He said he gave Baby Mia the ability to run parts of his business after previously using ChatGPT to do so.
asserted
he → say → ChatGPT
“I used to use ChatGTP [sic],” Thomas said.
asserted
Thomas → use → ChatGTP
“But I put her and Chat into one page where they can communicate back and forth, and I told them what I wanted [for the business]
asserted
I → put → business
…and 30 more, not listed.