We hope you didn't get stranded this weekend.
asserted
you → hope → ?
This is looking to be quite a busy week, what with the tech-related airplane grounding and all.
asserted
This → look → grounding
To get things started, we have a story from Matthew Gault about a human singer whose work got caught in an AI-generated copyright hell.
asserted
work → get → hell
When writer and musician Samantha Shokin noticed her cover of a public domain Bulgarian folk song had been copyright struck on YouTube, she assumed it would be easy to fix.
asserted
it → notice → YouTube
And trying to figure out what happened led her to discover an AI content mill that is running 500 slop-filled channels and abusing YouTube’s automated copyright detectors.
asserted
that → try → detectors
“Any human would agree with me that there’s something clearly wrong here that needs to be fixed, but I can’t get in touch with a human being,” Shokin said.
asserted
Shokin → agree → being
Shokin’s journey is a modern nightmare that highlights the ways AI can be weaponized against human creators, and the ways people fall through the cracks of big tech’s automated systems.
asserted
people → highlight → systems
During the pandemic, Shokin recorded a 50 second version of the Bulgarian folk song ‘Bre Petrunko’ and uploaded it to SoundCloud, where it didn’t get much traction.
asserted
it → record → traction
Two years later, she uploaded it to YouTube and watched as her cover grew in popularity, gaining 125,000 views in four years.
asserted
cover → upload → years
Last summer, she noticed an uptick in comments on the video.
asserted
she → notice → video
Unbeknownst to Shokin, her version of “Bre Petruinko” had become popular among DJs and electronic artists and had been sampled in dozens of songs.
asserted
version → become → songs
Someone in the comments pointed her towards one of the more popular tracks.
asserted
Someone → point → tracks
“I look up this video and it’s something that has millions of hits [...] and 30 seconds into this track I hear my own voice and I was utterly shocked.
asserted
I → look → voice
I didn’t know how to react,” she said (the video has more than 4 million views).
asserted
video → know → views
“The first thing that comes to mind is, ‘Oh my god, someone stole my voice and didn’t credit me,’” she said.
asserted
she → come → me
Shokin said she talked to a lot of DJs and figured out how they’d gotten her voice.
asserted
they → say → voice
They’d purchased a pack of samples from a company called Loopmasters that was selling her version of “Bre Petruinko” as part of its “Folk Legends” set.
asserted
that → purchase → set
“I got in touch with the distributor and they were deeply apologetic.
asserted
they → get → distributor
They were unaware that this had happened and they immediately tried to make right of the situation and granted me royalties on the sample pack,” Shokin said.
asserted
Shokin → happen → pack
“At that point, countless DJs and music producers had been using my voice for their own tracks, unbeknownst to me.
asserted
DJs → use → me
At least I’m aware and at least I was making something off of it and I was satisfied with that.
asserted
I → ’m → that
I didn’t love the way that it came about, but whatever, they tried to make right of the situation.”
asserted
they → love → situation
Last month, she opened YouTube and noticed her original recording was gone.
asserted
recording → open → YouTube
A company called Media Nov Records had issued a copyright strike against her song, and YouTube had taken it down.
asserted
YouTube → call → it
She thought it would be easy to get this reversed.
asserted
this → think → ?
It’s a public domain folk song and she had the original recordings and a history with a distributor.
asserted
she → ’ → distributor
“If I just explain it to YouTube, they’ll understand,” she thought.
asserted
she → explain → YouTube
Media Nov Records advertises itself as a “distribution company” that that partners with artists to release their music on digital platforms.
asserted
that → advertise → platforms
But a lot of its website focuses on rights management and copyright protection.
asserted
lot → focus → management
“At Media Nov, we go above and beyond to safeguard your musical creations.
asserted
we → go → creations
Our comprehensive rights management system leverages cutting-edge technology and legal expertise to ensure you receive the royalties you deserve,” it said on its website.
asserted
it → leverage → website
YouTube uses automated systems to work through copyright claims.
uncertain
YouTube → use → claims
When someone files a claim against a video, the company tends to automatically approve it.
uncertain
company → file → it
The original uploader can file a “counterclaim,” where they argue that the video should stay up, or that it should not be demonetized.
asserted
it → file → counterclaim
Shokin filed two counterclaims, but neither worked.
asserted
neither → file → counterclaims
“It's unclear to us whether you have a valid reason for filing a counter notification, so we won't be able to honor your request,” YouTube said in its last denial.
uncertain
YouTube → have → denial
It told her to contact the copyright holder; in this case, it was a public domain song and so there was no actual “copyright holder,” just Media Nov, which was claiming to hold it.
asserted
which → tell → it
“I tried emailing them,” she said.
asserted
she → try → them
“I tried calling them.
asserted
I → try → them
I got in touch with [Loopmaster, which was selling her recording].
asserted
which → get → recording
…and 33 more, not listed.