An Indiana mother who tried to regain sole legal custody of her three children from her former husband and gain access to his mental-health records has lost her appeal.
asserted
who → try → appeal
She must also pay more of his legal costs.
asserted
She → pay → costs
In a ruling issued on 16 November 2026, the Indiana Court of Appeals rejected all the challenges brought by Sember Darland-Chappell against her former husband, Andrew Hahn.
asserted
Court → issue → husband
A three-judge panel upheld a Hamilton Superior Court order that denied her request to change custody, refused to let her see Hahn's therapy notes and ordered her to pay $18,500 towards his trial lawyer's fees.
asserted
her → uphold → fees
The appeals court also approved Hahn's request for appellate legal fees and sent the case back to the trial court to decide how much more she must pay.
asserted
she → approve → more
Judge Cale Bradford wrote the decision.
asserted
Bradford → write → decision
Judges Patricia Riley Bailey and Elaine Brown Altice agreed with the ruling.
asserted
Bailey → agree → ruling
Seven years of court battles
Darland-Chappell and Hahn divorced on 19 February 2020, according to the Indiana Court of Appeals decision.
uncertain
Chappell → divorce → decision
Under their original divorce order, the former couple shared legal custody of their three children, who were born in October 2009, June 2011 and October 2013.
asserted
who → share → October
However, Darland-Chappell had primary physical custody.
asserted
Chappell → have → custody
Hahn had regular parenting time with the children on Wednesday evenings and every other weekend.
asserted
Hahn → have → evenings
The dispute grew in June 2021 when Hahn asked the court to change legal custody and parenting time.
asserted
Hahn → grow → custody
Darland-Chappell filed a request of her own and asked the court to arrange a formal child custody evaluation.
asserted
Chappell → file → evaluation
Clinical psychologist Dr Bart Ferraro carried out the evaluation between February and May 2022.
uncertain
Ferraro → carry → February
He prepared a 131-page report.
asserted
He → prepare → report
The trial court relied heavily on Dr Ferraro's recommendations.
asserted
court → rely → recommendations
On 16 May 2023, it gave Hahn sole legal custody and changed the physical parenting schedule so that the children would spend alternating full weeks with each parent.
uncertain
children → give → parent
Darland-Chappell filed a request to regain custody in November 2023.
asserted
Chappell → file → November
The trial court rejected it in May 2024 after holding a three-day hearing.
uncertain
court → reject → hearing
On 2 January 2025, she filed another request to change custody, along with a motion asking for a different judge.
asserted
she → file → judge
In her filing, Darland-Chappell claimed Hahn "has weaponized his sole legal custody status and has seemed to be more focused on lording that over [Mother], rather than on making sound decisions for the [C]hildren."
asserted
Hahn → claim → C]hildren
She also argued that alternating weeks with each parent "provides no consistency or continuity for the [C]hildren."
asserted
alternating → argue → C]hildren
After a new judge took over the case, Darland-Chappell filed several requests before the custody hearing.
asserted
Chappell → take → hearing
In late January 2025, she asked the court to appoint a guardian ad litem, an independent person who looks after children's interests in court cases.
asserted
who → ask → cases
She argued that a new evaluation was needed because Dr Ferraro's report was almost three years old.
asserted
report → argue → ?
Hahn opposed the request.
asserted
Hahn → oppose → request
He pointed out that the children had been regularly seeing a therapist since 2020.
asserted
children → point → 2020
The trial court rejected her request in March 2025.
asserted
court → reject → March
Darland-Chappell also asked the judge to speak privately with all three children.
asserted
Chappell → ask → children
She also issued a subpoena for records held by Vanessa McCaskey, the family therapist who worked with Hahn and the children.
asserted
who → issue → Hahn
When McCaskey asked the court to cancel the subpoena, Darland-Chappell filed a request in July 2025 to force the release of Hahn's mental-health records under Indiana Code section 16-39-3-3.
asserted
Chappell → ask → section
Both Hahn and McCaskey told the court that releasing the records could harm the therapy process.
uncertain
releasing → tell → process
McCaskey said Hahn might stop speaking openly during sessions if he thought his words could be given to his former wife.
uncertain
words → say → wife
She warned that this could damage the work he was doing to improve his relationship with the children.
uncertain
he → warn → children
Hahn also told the court that Darland-Chappell's earlier involvement with another family therapist, Angela Hardy, had seriously disrupted counselling.
asserted
involvement → tell → counselling
The children's individual therapist, Dr Natasha Anderson, had then recommended finding a new therapist.
asserted
therapist → recommend → therapist
On 8 September 2025, the trial court rejected Darland-Chappell's request for Hahn's records.
asserted
court → reject → records
The judge decided that the possible harm to Hahn as a patient was greater than the need to share the records.
asserted
harm → decide → records
The judge explained that court-ordered counselling was meant to help the children adjust and improve their relationship with their father.
asserted
children → explain → father
This followed an earlier warning from the court that therapy was not ordered "to give either party the opportunity to reload their quivers with arrows to sling at the other party in the next hearing.
asserted
therapy → follow → hearing
…and 16 more, not listed.