NSW Premier Chris Minns was warned about the impact of the underquoting overhaul on Sydney’s cooling property market a month before his government shelved the laws at the last minute.
asserted
government → warn → minute
The government’s eleventh-hour reversal on Monday, hours before the changes designed to prevent price manipulation were due to come into effect at midnight, means the laws will be on hold until after the state election in March.
asserted
laws → design → March
Industry figures raised alarm about one aspect among the suite of changes at an underquoting roundtable on October 22, notably a ban on real estate agents being able to advertise a price that was lower than a previously rejected written offer.
asserted
that → raise → offer
While intended to stop agents from setting property price guides unrealistically low, the industry was concerned agents would be unfairly punished as prices dropped.
asserted
prices → intend → guides
Those at the roundtable asked for their concerns to reach Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong but were told he would not budge.
Minns said on Monday morning the issue had “come across my desk from real estate agents in my electorate” and “we need to look at it”.
asserted
we → ask → it
The premier’s office would not say when Minns changed his mind before the decision was made public at 6pm on Monday.
asserted
decision → say → Monday
The rules that were passed in
Among the changes that had been due to start on Tuesday:
- Mandatory inclusion of price guides on all marketing and information for buyers based on three comparable sales.
- A five-fold increase in the penalty for agents caught underquoting, from $22,000 to $110,000 or three times the agent’s commission, whichever is greater.
- The penalty for dummy bidding at auctions will also double to $110,000.
asserted
penalty → pass → 110,000
- Agents will also be prohibited from advertising a selling price that is lower than a previously rejected written offer or the highest unsuccessful bid at an auction.
asserted
that → prohibit → auction
He defended the change in question time on Tuesday, saying: “It would have the perverse effect … of potentially denying a buyer a cheaper price when it comes to the listed price because the real estate agent and the buyer had previously received a higher offer.
asserted
agent → defend → offer
“If market conditions have deteriorated in that three-month period, well, that doesn’t suit anybody.
asserted
that → deteriorate → anybody
It doesn’t suit the buyer.
asserted
It → suit → buyer
It doesn’t suit the seller, and it’s a regulatory environment that, by any objective measure, has changed.”
asserted
that → suit → measure
While the laws have passed parliament, the regulation governing their introduction was amended at ministerial discretion to defer their introduction for 12 months.
asserted
regulation → pass → months
Chanthivong described the deferral as reasonable, pragmatic and evidence the government was “always listening”.
asserted
government → describe → deferral
Laing & Simmons chief executive Leanne Pilkington said she wrote to Chanthivong and copied in Minns on October 16, outlining her concern that the legislation would penalise home owners who genuinely revised their expectations.
asserted
who → say → expectations
“I would welcome a meeting with you and NSW Fair Trading to work through these scenarios and
identify whether legislative amendment or another legally effective mechanism is required,” she wrote.
asserted
she → welcome → scenarios
She urged the government to establish a mechanism for documented price revisions which would be supported by written confirmation; an updated, evidence-based estimate of the likely selling price; records explaining the reduction; and clear obligations when a property transfers.
asserted
property → urge → reduction
Pilkington said the unanimous concern among members of the underquoting roundtable, including buyers’ agents, was conveyed to NSW Fair Trading at the October 22 meeting.
asserted
concern → say → meeting
Pilkington said she wrote to Chanthivong again a few weeks ago without response and was stunned to discover the government had shelved the entire legislation, saying some of the changes were positive.
asserted
some → say → changes
Unicorn Buyers Agents founder Dan Sofo was also surprised, saying it felt like a backwards step when the real estate industry was starting to improve.
“I don’t think there’s been enough caveats on why the minister withdrew or has put a pause on [the reforms],” he said.
asserted
he → say → reforms
“It feels to me like that’s a bit of a nail in the coffin [for the reforms].”
asserted
that → feel → reforms
Kieren Sainsbury, a 34-year-old who bought his second property in August, said underquoting was worse now than when he was a first home buyer in 2018.
asserted
he → buy → 2018
He said he could tell when an apartment would go for more than what the real estate was advertising it for, but first home buyers often did not have that knowledge and would get taken advantage of.
“You do make the mistake of trusting the real estate agent because you feel like they’re on your side,” he said.
uncertain
he → say → side
Sainsbury said the withdrawal of the reforms would allow real estate agents to continue to lie to first home buyers.
asserted
agents → say → buyers
Opposition fair trading spokesman Tim James said concerns were raised with him “six to eight weeks ago” about the inability to revise values down, but no one was advocating for the reforms to be scrapped entirely.
asserted
reforms → say → values
“I think there is a problem here in terms of how much this government actually consults, listens, understands, works with stakeholders.
asserted
government → think → stakeholders
All of this was avoidable, I think, from the very outset.
asserted
I → think → outset
But this government has steamed ahead,” he said.
asserted
he → steam → ?
“The sector has given them ample notice with which to respond.”
asserted
sector → give → which
The decision to park the underquoting policy came at the start of the last parliamentary sitting week of the year.
asserted
decision → park → year
It marked another significant reversal by Chanthivong; the third time he has been overruled by the premier on legislation in his portfolio.
asserted
he → mark → portfolio
Chanthivong was offered a political lifeline after the embarrassing backdown on Monday.
asserted
Chanthivong → offer → Monday
A senior Labor source, speaking on condition of anonymity to detail confidential deliberations, said the party was likely to save the 49-year-old minister after weeks of speculation over his future.
asserted
party → speak → future
“Given what Anoulack has had to go through in the last 24 hours, there was recognition he had done the right thing in reversing the policy,” the source said.
asserted
source → give → policy
“It wasn’t a quid pro quo (but) fundamentally he had been humiliated enough, and we didn’t want him to go through a torrid preselection.”
asserted
him → humiliate → preselection
Chanthivong used a social media post on November 4 to spruik the government’s policy as “cracking down on underquoting”.
asserted
Chanthivong → use → underquoting
“Underquoting gives homebuyers an inaccurate picture of a property’s selling price, wasting their time and money on a home that was never in their price range,” he wrote.
asserted
he → give → range
“This is unfair and needs to stop.”
Get the day’s breaking news, entertainment ideas and a long read to enjoy.
asserted
This → need → news