Photo via BBC News

Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does the data show?

Read the original at BBC News ↗
Cite

Copeland, J. H. &. T. (2026, November 17). Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does the data show? BBC News. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cxnv4jlr269eo?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

BBC News · collected 2026-11-17 · by Jake Horton & Thomas Copeland

Quick Summary

Alaska's Senate race remains undecided nearly two weeks after the midterm elections, with Democratic candidate Mary Peltola leading Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan by a significant margin. The race has been complicated by the presence of another Republican candidate, Daniel J Sullivan Jr., leading to claims of voter confusion. However, an analysis by the BBC using ranked-choice voting data shows that Peltola received nearly twice as many second-choice votes from those who first chose Daniel J Sullivan Jr., challenging the notion that Republican voters were confused about which Dan Sullivan to vote for.
Written by AI on 2026-11-17, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

How they differ

19 outlets covered “Democrat Mary Peltola wins election to U.S. Senate”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

BBCThis outlet17 Nov

Alaska's Senate race remains undecided nearly two weeks after the midterm elections, with Democratic candidate Mary Peltola leading Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan by a significant margin. The race has been complicated by the presence of another Republican candidate, Daniel J Sullivan Jr., leading to claims of voter confusion. However, an analysis by the BBC using ranked-choice voting data shows that Peltola…

Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does the data show? (this article)
Toronto Star18 Nov

The Associated Press declared Mary Peltola, a Democrat, the winner of Alaska's U.S. Senate race, defeating incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. The article focuses on the AP's decision to call the race for Peltola without providing additional details about the vote count or the campaign dynamics.

Why AP called the Alaska Senate race for Democrat Mary Peltola →5 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Daily Mail18 Nov

Mary Peltola won Alaska's Senate race, defeating Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan by 4.3 percentage points, according to the Associated Press. With 99 percent of ballots counted, Peltola leads by almost 12,500 votes, securing the 56th Senate seat for Democrats. The race was controversial due to the presence of a second candidate named Daniel J Sullivan Jr., who Republicans accused of being a "decoy" to confuse…

Final humiliation for Trump as Mary Peltola defeats the real Dan Sullivan in Alaska to hand Democrats 56th Senate seat →3 articles from Daily Mail on this story
Washington Examiner18 Nov

Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race on Tuesday, according to the Associated Press. With 99% of the vote counted, Peltola secured 50.1% of the votes compared to Sullivan's 45.8%, leading to a Democratic Senate majority of 56 seats.

Mary Peltola ousts Dan Sullivan in Alaska, giving Democrats 56-seat Senate majority →3 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
New York Post18 Nov

Mary Peltola was declared the winner of Alaska's Senate race two weeks after the midterm elections, securing 50.1% of the vote compared to incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan's 45.8%. The race was notable for the inclusion of a third candidate, "Decoy Dan" Sullivan, who was reportedly recruited to potentially confuse voters and draw votes away from Sullivan. This strategy led to legal and criminal investigations, with…

Mary Peltola finally declared winner of Alaska Senate race 2 weeks after midterms →2 articles from New York Post on this story
Show 13 more outlets
CBS News18 Nov

Mary Peltola won the Alaska Senate race against Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan, as projected by CBS News. This victory solidifies a Democratic majority in the Senate, with Democrats controlling 56 seats to Republicans' 44. Peltola, 53, was the first Democrat to represent Alaska in the House in 50 years and will become the state's first Alaska Native and first Democrat in the Senate since 2008. The race was…

Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, flipping seat for Dems →2 articles from CBS News on this story
The Guardian18 Nov

Mary Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race, securing the state's seat for Democrats and giving them a total of 56 seats in the Senate. This victory follows Democrats' overall gain of nine Senate seats in the midterms, strengthening their majority. Peltola, a former US House lawmaker, is the first Democrat elected to the Senate from Alaska since 2008. Her campaign faced…

Mary Peltola beats Republican Dan Sullivan in Alaska to give Democrats 56 Senate seats →2 articles from The Guardian on this story
The Daily Wire13 Nov

Democratic Alaska Senate candidate Mary Peltola has extended her lead over incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan to 5,800 votes with 88% of the ballot currently reported. The race is characterized by the presence of two "decoy" candidates, including an independent candidate and a self-identified Republican who were reportedly recruited by political operatives to confuse voters and split the GOP vote. This report…

Peltola Inches Toward Victory As ‘Decoy Dan’ Drama Deepens →
Fox News18 Nov

Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska's 2026 midterm elections, flipping a traditionally Republican-held Senate seat. The race gained national attention due to controversy surrounding a secret Democratic effort to recruit a candidate sharing Sullivan's name to split Republican votes, known as the "ballot composition project." Peltola's victory, in a state President Trump won by…

Alaska Dem Peltola defeats Sullivan, flipping 9th GOP Senate seat after 'decoy Dan' uproar →
Al Jazeera18 Nov

Mary Peltola won the Senate seat in Alaska, defeating incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan in a race that drew national attention due to allegations of vote manipulation. Peltola’s campaign faced scrutiny over accusations that her aides recruited another candidate named Dan Sullivan to draw votes away from the Republican incumbent. Despite these controversies, Sullivan conceded the race after the Department of…

Mary Peltola flips Alaska Senate seat in another Democratic win →
The Straits Times18 Nov

Mary Peltola won the U.S. Senate race in Alaska, defeating Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan in the 2026 midterm elections. The victory expands the Democrats' majority in the Senate to 56-44, marking their most successful midterm election since 1958. Peltola’s campaign faced controversy over allegations that her team had recruited another candidate named Dan J. Sullivan to split votes with the incumbent, a charge…

Democrat Mary Peltola wins US Senate race in Alaska, beating incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan →
ABC News (US)18 Nov

Mary Peltola won the U.S. Senate race in Alaska, defeating Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan, according to the Associated Press. With 99% of the vote counted, Peltola led with 50% of the vote compared to Sullivan's 46%, a margin of about 12,000 votes. This victory marks the ninth Senate seat Democrats have secured for the next Congress.

Democrat Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race: AP projects →
Just the News18 Nov

The Associated Press declared Democrat Mary Peltola the winner of the Alaska Senate race on Tuesday, two weeks after the election. Peltola received 50.1% of the vote, defeating Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan, who secured 45.8% of the vote. The race was officially called at 10:19 p.m. Eastern time when 99% of the votes were counted.

Democrat Mary Peltola declared winner in Alaska Senate race: AP →
CBC18 Nov

Mary Peltola won the U.S. Senate seat in Alaska for the Democrats, defeating Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan. This victory expanded Democrats' majority in the Senate to 56-44, marking the most Senate seats flipped in a midterm election since 1958. The article highlights Peltola's political comeback despite facing allegations that her campaign helped recruit another candidate named Dan J. Sullivan to split votes, a…

Mary Peltola wins U.S. Senate seat in Alaska for Democrats →
Time18 Nov

Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race, securing 50.1% of the vote to Sullivan's 45.8%. The race was called two weeks after Election Day due to Alaska's 15-day grace period for mailed ballots and ranked-choice voting system. This victory marks Peltola as the first Alaska Native elected to the Senate and the first Democrat in the role since 2008, shifting the Senate…

Mary Peltola Defeats Incumbent Republican in Alaska Senate Race →
Times of India18 Nov

Mary Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan in Alaska's Senate race, contributing to Democrats' gain of nine Republican-held seats, the largest such gain since 1958. With this victory, Democrats now hold a 56-44 majority in the Senate, their strongest position since January 2011. The article highlights the historical context of midterm elections and their impact on the Senate, noting that Democrats have…

Alaska Senate Race: Democrats gain nine seats, largest since 1958; party holds 56-44 majority →
Euronews18 Nov

In a tight race, Democrat Mary Peltola won the US Senate seat in Alaska, defeating Republican incumbent Dan S. Sullivan with 50.12% of the vote. Peltola received 144,302 votes compared to Sullivan's 131,844 votes, even with the inclusion of votes for a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. The race was marked by controversy over allegations that Peltola's campaign had recruited another candidate named Dan…

Democrat Mary Peltola unseats Republican and flips US Senate seat in tight race in Alaska →
The Hindu18 Nov

Mary Peltola won Alaska’s U.S. Senate race on November 17, securing 50% of the first-place votes to defeat Republican Dan Sullivan, who received 46%. This victory gave Democrats a 56-44 majority in the Senate. The race was complicated by allegations that Democrats helped recruit an independent candidate to serve as a spoiler, leading to a state and federal investigation.

Democrat Peltola wins in Alaska, securing 56-44 U.S. Senate majority →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

Reported by outlets on both sides of the middle

Sullivan has denied any contact with Peltola’s campaign or running at the Democrats’ behest.

5 outlets
Show 1 more

If no candidate wins a majority of the vote on the first ballot, the lowest-placed candidate is eliminated and second-choice votes from that candidate’s supporters are counted.

4 outlets
The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 33 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 19% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Guardian
Hedges 7 of 24 claims Outlet record 64/100
BBC News
Hedges 2 of 27 claims Outlet record 66/100
“Article A discusses the logistical challenges of vote-counting in Alaska's midterm elections, while Article B focuses on the specific Senate race results and the confusion caused by two candidates with similar names.”
Daily Mail
Leans left Hedges 0 of 14 claims Outlet record 70/100
“Article A discusses the gubernatorial race and Democratic victory, while Article B focuses on the ongoing Senate race and voter confusion regarding the two Daniels Sullivan.”
The Independent
Hedges 0 of 30 claims Outlet record 59/100
“The articles discuss different elections: the governor's race won by Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins and the Senate race involving Mary Peltola and Dan Sullivan.”
NBC News
Hedges 1 of 10 claims Outlet record 78/100
“The articles describe different stages of the same election but do not cover the exact same specific moment or outcome.”
Reason
Hedges 3 of 38 claims Outlet record 67/100
“The articles cover different aspects of the election: Article A focuses on the vote to keep ranked choice voting, while Article B discusses the confusion around the Senate race due to another candidate with a similar name.”
The Guardian
Hedges 1 of 21 claims Outlet record 64/100
The Daily Wire
Centre Hedges 3 of 23 claims Outlet record 59/100
“The articles cover different aspects of the same race but describe distinct time points and events: the first discusses Peltola's lead one week after Election Day, while the second covers the situation almost two weeks later and includes commentary on confusion around two Dan Sullivans.”
New York Post
Leans left Hedges 4 of 18 claims Outlet record 66/100
“Article A describes Mary Peltola declaring victory in the Alaska Senate race based on vote count, while Article B discusses potential confusion due to two candidates with similar names and the impact on vote counting, which are different aspects of the same election event.”
NBC News
Hedges 6 of 32 claims Outlet record 78/100
“While both articles discuss the ongoing vote count in the Alaska Senate race, Article B introduces a new detail about confusion potentially caused by two Dan S. Sullivan names on the ballot, which Article A does not mention.”

Story

Democrat Mary Peltola wins election to U.S. Senate
Other · 33 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
36
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
19%
7 of 36 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
66/100
BBC News's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
33
Other
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-17 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

BBC News · 6134 article(s) · 8 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 8 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Jake Horton & Thomas Copeland
1 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
This Senate contest has drawn scrutiny after another Dan Sullivan entered the race earlier this year - with ballot papers listing both the incumbent Dan S Sullivan and a Daniel J Sullivan Jr. Republicans have said this could have confused voters, prompting an unsuccessful legal challenge and President Donald Trump claiming votes for "the fake Dan Sullivan" were supposed to be for "the real Dan Sullivan".
The only article under this byline in the corpus.

Topics

Alaska Democratic Democrats Republican Senate

Subjects

Alaska GPE · 7× Peltola PERSON · 6× Dan S Sullivan PERSON · 5× Republican NORP · 5× Daniel J Sullivan Jr PERSON · 3× Democratic NORP · 3× Senate ORG · 3× Sullivan PERSON · 3× Dan Sullivan PERSON · 2× Mary Peltola PERSON · 2×

Narrative

- Published Almost two weeks after the Democrats swept to victory in the midterm elections, votes are still being counted in the race to elect a senator in Alaska, with Democratic candidate Mary Peltola ahead of her Republican rival - Senator Dan S Sullivan.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-17
This Senate contest has drawn scrutiny after another Dan Sullivan entered the race earlier this year - with ballot papers listing both the incumbent Dan S Sullivan and a Daniel J Sullivan Jr. Republicans have said this could have confused voters, prompting an unsuccessful legal challenge and President Donald Trump claiming votes for "the fake Dan Sullivan" were supposed to be for "the real Dan Sullivan".

Claims (36 extracted, 7 hedged)

- Published Almost two weeks after the Democrats swept to victory in the midterm elections, votes are still being counted in the race to elect a senator in Alaska, with Democratic candidate Mary Peltola ahead of her Republican rival - Senator Dan S Sullivan. asserted
Peltola → publish → rival
This Senate contest has drawn scrutiny after another Dan Sullivan entered the race earlier this year - with ballot papers listing both the incumbent Dan S Sullivan and a Daniel J Sullivan Jr. Republicans have said this could have confused voters, prompting an unsuccessful legal challenge and President Donald Trump claiming votes for "the fake Dan Sullivan" were supposed to be for "the real Dan Sullivan". uncertain
votes → draw → Sullivan
US media has not forecasted a winner in the race - the last Senate seat still without a winner after the 3 November election. asserted
media → forecast → election
But with 97% of the vote counted, even if Senator Dan S Sullivan's votes were combined with Daniel J Sullivan Jr's votes, this would still not overcome Peltola's lead. asserted
this → count → lead
Alaska uses a ranked-choice voting system, which means voters can vote for five candidates in order of preference. asserted
voters → use → preference
If no candidate reaches more than 50% of the first preference votes, then voters' other choices will be used to decide who wins. asserted
who → reach → votes
BBC Verify has analysed voting data showing voters' second choices. asserted
Verify → analyse → choices
It shows that over a third of voters who put Daniel J Sullivan Jr first left their second choice blank. asserted
who → show → choice
The next highest second-choice preference was for the Democratic candidate Mary Peltola - receiving nearly twice as many second-choice votes as the Republican Dan S Sullivan. asserted
preference → receive → Republican
This calls into question claims that Republican voters may have been confused about which Sullivan they were voting for. uncertain
they → call → Sullivan
How did two Dan Sullivans end up in the race? asserted
Sullivans → end → race
Republican Dan S Sullivan has held the US Senate seat in Alaska since 2015 and was running for his third term. asserted
Sullivan → hold → term
Daniel J Sullivan Jr - a retired school teacher from a remote fishing village in Alaska - entered the race in May and has run a low-key campaign. uncertain
Jr → enter → campaign
A New York Times story, external published the week before Election Day claimed that Democratic operatives with links to the Peltola campaign had tried to recruit "spoiler" candidates in the Senate race, including Daniel J Sullivan Jr. asserted
operatives → publish → Jr.
The report said it had seen text messages and interviewed 12 people who participated in or were told of the plan, or were would-be candidates who the team also tried to recruit. asserted
team → say → who
The BBC has not independently verified the reporting. uncertain
BBC → verify → reporting
Peltola has denied all knowledge of the alleged "scheme" and Sullivan Jr has denied any links with the Peltola campaign. asserted
Jr → deny → campaign
President Trump has posted multiple times on Truth Social since the election, claiming that the race has been "rigged". asserted
race → post → election
But experts note it's not an illegal tactic, if it was employed. asserted
it → note → ?
"There is nothing to prevent a campaign from recruiting someone else to run, even if for political reasons," said Joshua Douglas, an election law expert at the University of Kentucky. asserted
Douglas → be → Kentucky
How does voting work in Alaska? asserted
voting → work → Alaska
Voters in Alaska select their first choice candidate, followed by options to rank up to four other candidates in order of preference. asserted
Voters → select → preference
"There is no specific law preventing people with the same name running, but many states have laws or regulations about how names appear on the ballot. asserted
names → be → ballot
One of those regulations was used in Alaska" said Ruth Greenwood, director of the election law clinic at Harvard Law School. asserted
Greenwood → use → School
On Alaskans' ballots the two Sullivans were listed as: - Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr. - Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent There was a second registered Republican candidate, Gerald Heikes - who was also allegedly recruited into the race according to The New York Times. uncertain
who → list → Times
As of Monday, Peltola holds 49.94% of the vote. asserted
Peltola → hold → vote
In the event that Peltola were not to clear 50%, officials eliminate the candidate in last place and reallocate those ballots to the voters' next choices. asserted
officials → clear → choices
This process continues until two candidates remain, with one clearing the 50% hurdle. asserted
one → continue → hurdle
Daniel J Sullivan Jr is the listed candidate in last place with 1.65% of the vote. asserted
Jr → list → vote
What does ranked-choice voting data show so far? asserted
data → rank → What
Senator Dan S Sullivan and his allies have accused the Democrats of trying to confuse voters. asserted
Sullivan → accuse → voters
Trump said last week: "Anybody that voted for that second Dan Sullivan, the fake Dan Sullivan, was supposed to be a vote for the real Dan Sullivan". asserted
that → say → Sullivan
Of the ballots analysed by BBC Verify that ranked Daniel J Sullivan Jr first, 38% of them recorded no valid second choice. asserted
% → analyse → choice
We do not know how many of these voters may have thought they had voted for the Senator Dan S Sullivan and then not ranked any other candidates. uncertain
they → know → candidates
A further 29% of Daniel J Sullivan Jr voters ranked the Democratic candidate Mary Peltola second, almost double the 15% that ranked the incumbent Republican Senator Sullivan as second. asserted
that → rank → second
"The likelihood that any confusion might play a significant role is diminished in Alaska," Richard Pildes, a professor of constitutional law at New York University, argues, "because any voter who was unsure which Dan Sullivan candidate they meant to vote for could rank them first and second." uncertain
they → play → them
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support