Puberty blockers should remain an option for trans youth, new national advice finds
In short:
New national advice has recommended puberty blockers remain a clinical option for certain children with gender dysphoria.
asserted
blockers → remain → dysphoria
The medication has been the subject of fierce debate and is restricted in parts of Australia and overseas.
What's next?
asserted
What → restrict → Australia
Puberty blockers should remain a clinical option for certain trans and gender diverse children, despite low-certainty evidence about their benefits and harms, according to long-awaited national advice.
uncertain
blockers → remain → advice
The National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) interim advice could have significant policy implications for the Queensland and Northern Territory governments, which have banned or restricted puberty blockers in the public system.
uncertain
which → have → system
Gonadotropin-releasing hormone analogues (GnRHa) or puberty blockers, are injections that pause aspects of physical development by suppressing sex hormones.
asserted
that → release → hormones
They are a form of medical intervention prescribed to children with gender incongruence, a clinical term for a difference between a person's gender and their sex recorded at birth.
asserted
They → prescribe → birth
Some people with gender incongruence also experience distress, which is known as gender dysphoria.
asserted
which → experience → dysphoria
Advocates argue pausing puberty temporarily buys patients time to decide if they want to take the next steps towards transitioning with hormones like oestrogen or testosterone.
asserted
they → argue → oestrogen
However critics say the medication is experimental and potentially dangerous.
asserted
medication → say → ?
In 2025, Health Minister Mark Butler asked the NHMRC to develop national guidelines for the care of trans and gender diverse young people, including priority interim advice on puberty blockers.
asserted
Butler → ask → blockers
The interim advice, released on Monday for public consultation, used what is known as the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach, which rates the certainty of evidence and how strong a recommendation for or against a healthcare option should be.
asserted
recommendation → release → option
The Gender Guidelines Development Committee (GGDC) made a conditional recommendation for the use of the medication for certain young people.
asserted
Committee → make → people
It said conditional recommendations were more common than strong recommendations in clinical guidelines.
"
asserted
recommendations → say → guidelines
A conditional recommendation is made in cases where shared decision-making is essential because different options may be appropriate for different individuals and they might make different choices, or where the overall certainty of available evidence is low.
uncertain
certainty → make → evidence
Both are the case here," the report said.
asserted
report → say → ?
The committee suggested that based on a shared decision between the patient, their carers and clinicians, puberty blockers could be considered for a young person who had gender incongruence with or without distress, were assessed as suitable for treatment and had begun puberty.
uncertain
who → suggest → puberty
"Not all young people will want or need the same intervention at the same time or age, and care that is in one young person's best interests may not suit another," the report said.
uncertain
report → want → another
The NHMRC review included 15 non-randomised studies, most with follow-up of six months to two years.
asserted
review → include → years
The committee found that the overall certainty of evidence was low, with studies largely observational and generally short-term.
asserted
certainty → find → studies
"Although the available evidence indicates that serious adverse events are rare, a young person using GnRH agonists should be monitored for signs or symptoms that may warrant additional investigations and management," the report said.
uncertain
report → indicate → investigations
The reviewers said the available evidence showed puberty blockers may improve psychosocial functioning and may reduce suicidality behaviours, and found no eligible evidence on the impact on fertility, fractures or other measures of bone health.
uncertain
blockers → say → health
The advice isn't legally mandatory
The medication has increasingly been the subject of fierce debate, with countries like the UK, Finland and many US states seeking to restrict its use.
asserted
countries → seek → use
The New Zealand government introduced a ban on new prescriptions of puberty blockers for children with gender dysphoria last year, however the High Court recently ruled the regulations unlawful, meaning doctors can prescribe them again.
asserted
doctors → introduce → them
Last year, Queensland became the first state in Australia to restrict access to puberty blockers for children with gender dysphoria who were not already on them in the public system.
asserted
who → become → system
The Northern Territory also banned puberty blockers in the public system for people under 18.
asserted
Territory → ban → 18
As it paused access to the medication, Queensland ordered an independent review by prominent psychiatrist Ruth Vine.
asserted
Queensland → pause → Vine
It found the evidence base about the use of puberty blockers for gender dysphoria and on the impact of fertility was limited, with evidence the medication could impact bone health in the short to medium term.
uncertain
medication → find → term
However, it found the effects were "reversible" and with proper oversight "there can be benefit for a young person" in accessing the medication.
asserted
effects → find → medication
The Queensland government said it would continue the pause until 2031, while awaiting the results of an upcoming UK trial known as PATHWAYS, which has been delayed because of safety concerns and legal challenges.
Because the NHMRC guidance is advisory rather than legally mandatory, states and territories can ultimately decide how they implement it.
However it does set up a policy test for Queensland and the Northern Territory, who will now have to decide whether to maintain the restrictions in the face of the new national advice.
asserted
who → say → advice
Mr Butler previously told the ABC he expected state and territory governments to give "proper consideration" to the advice.
asserted
governments → tell → advice
The Endocrine Society recently examined the use of puberty blockers for children who go through puberty early, known as precocious puberty.
asserted
who → examine → puberty
The reviewers also made a conditional recommendation for the use of the medication, based on very low certainty evidence.
asserted
reviewers → make → evidence
Ethical and practical limitations around the way research is conducted, particularly when it comes to children, means high certainty evidence about puberty blockers is very difficult to obtain.
asserted
evidence → conduct → blockers
The gold standard of scientific studies is known as randomised controlled trials, which compares two groups randomly selected.
asserted
which → know → groups
One is given the treatment, and the other is given something else, like a placebo, or even the same treatment at a different time.
asserted
other → give → time
However, this approach raises ethical concerns when it comes to puberty blockers, because it can mean delaying or withholding treatment for children.
asserted
it → raise → children
In addition, double blind trials — where neither the participants nor researchers know who is receiving the treatment — are also off the table, because the drugs stop physical changes like menstruation, meaning people can guess if they are receiving them.
asserted
they → know → them
That has left a reliance on observational studies, where scientists observe individuals without manipulating the environment, however these are considered to be lower quality because without comparison, researchers cannot be sure what impact the treatment itself has had.
asserted
treatment → leave → impact
Proponents argue that low certainty evidence is very common for other areas of paediatrics, and does not mean an absence of evidence or evidence of harm.
asserted
evidence → argue → harm
But opponents interpret it as a reason for greater caution, saying the benefits have not been established with enough confidence to justify their use.
Critics have also condemned the lack of transparency about how many children are on puberty blockers nationwide.
asserted
children → interpret → blockers
…and 4 more, not listed.