Big questions - and key logistical details - loom ahead of China-U.S. summit
asserted
questions → loom → summit
Big questions - and key logistical details - loom ahead of China-U.S. summit
WASHINGTON D.C. –
asserted
questions → loom → summit
With seven days to go before a high-stakes meeting between the leaders of the United States and China, some key logistical details remain undecided, potentially hamstringing planning for the business deals, trade talks, and technology-related discussions for the two countries.
asserted
details → go → countries
Interagency conversations to prepare briefing materials and talking points for President Trump to present to the Chinese leader and his delegation have not yet been completed, some U.S. officials say.
asserted
officials → prepare → leader
Uncertainty over how many seats the Chinese delegation will be given at the state dinner that night has hampered the Chinese delegation from finalizing which tech executives may accompany Chinese leader Xi Jinping.
uncertain
executives → give → Jinping
The details of the planning are according to interviews with 10 current and former U.S. officials as well as three people involved with meeting planning, all of whom requested anonymity because they are not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
they → accord → anonymity
The White House did not provide an on the record statement when asked for comment.
asserted
House → provide → comment
Despite the lingering questions, China remains optimistic about the summit.
asserted
China → linger → summit
"The Chinese are very enthusiastic about this summit because I think it's a way for them to manage the U.S.," said Randall Shriver, former assistant secretary of defense for Indo-Pacific Security Affairs and current chair of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, which provides recommendations to Congress on China.
asserted
which → think → China
Chinese leaders from the country's foreign ministry and elite Politburo Committee have expressed concern to U.S. representatives in the last four weeks that the U.S. has been finalizing an agenda and security and protocol details up until the last days before the summit.
asserted
U.S. → express → summit
"Every meal, every moment they sit down and are photographed, the way that they are positioned on stage in the arrival ceremony, the amount of time which they are asked to speak, if they speak, the kind of composition of the crowd: all of these things are something that Beijing will pay attention to and will want not simply to negotiate but will want to feel certainty about," said Julian Gewirtz, a historian and scholar at Columbia School of Public and International Affairs.
asserted
Gewirtz → sit → Affairs
The Trump administration has embraced its reputation as an ad hoc negotiator.
asserted
administration → embrace → negotiator
Its last-minute working style has flummoxed their counterparts in Beijing, who have tried to avoid a repeat of a preparation process haphazard enough to prompt a top Chinese diplomat to chide some of their American counterparts for their "half-a**ed" planning following President Trump's May visit to Beijing, according to a person in the meeting with the diplomat who requested anonymity because they are not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
they → flummox → anonymity
Yet during a July visit to Washington headed by Vice Foreign Minister Ma Zhaoxu, Beijing posed more than a dozen follow-up logistics questions and clarifications to American officials that did not receive concrete answers because the logistics awaited final confirmation from the White House, according to two people familiar with the contents of the meeting who also requested anonymity because they are not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
they → head → anonymity
A senior U.S. official, speaking on background because they are not authorized to speak publicly, said the Chinese vice foreign minister's visit was unrelated to the planning for the upcoming meeting.
asserted
visit → speak → meeting
U.S. representatives say summit planning has picked up since then, but remains behind schedule compared to preparation for previous state visits of similar magnitude.
asserted
planning → say → magnitude
The paralysis in planning for this meeting is partially due to competing agendas within various agencies in the U.S. government, according to the 10 current and former U.S. officials NPR spoke to.
uncertain
NPR → plan → officials
The U.S. has ceded no more than "perfect reciprocity," according to four of the people, meaning China's Xi Jinping will receive programming and access not exceeding what President Trump enjoyed in Beijing in May.
uncertain
Trump → cede → May
As a result, Xi's team dropped an early proposal to have him speak at an American university in Washington, D.C. during his September trip, because Trump had not been asked to deliver a speech on a Chinese campus during his visit in May, according to two people familiar with trip planning not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
Trump → drop → planning
The senior U.S. official said the White House never received a request for Xi to speak at any event.
asserted
Xi → say → event
One of the most pressing concerns are calls by companies and industry experts for the U.S. and China to cooperate on creating guardrails on developing and using artificial intelligence.
asserted
U.S. → cooperate → intelligence
Hoping to court Chinese investment, the White House has encouraged China to bring along entrepreneurs and executives, according to three people familiar with Chinese diplomatic planning for the trip.
uncertain
House → hop → trip
But with about a week to go before the visit, Beijing has not finalized a list of which executives it will bring, in part due to uncertainty over U.S. planning and because China's Xi does not usually travel abroad with business leaders.
asserted
Xi → go → leaders
The senior U.S. official said they are unaware of any business executives coming as part of the Chinese delegation.
asserted
they → say → delegation
For this visit, the White House is planning a state dinner with about 100 seats available, according to President Trump.
uncertain
seats → plan → Trump
(During Xi's last state visit to the U.S. in 2015 during the Obama administration, Xi was feted with a 200-person banquet.)
asserted
Xi → fete → banquet
Beijing asked for more than half the seats, hoping to accommodate CEOs it may bring, according to two people in the business community who requested anonymity because they were not authorized to speak on the record, leading to White House push back.
uncertain
they → ask → push
The Trump administration has also not answered requests to clarify what kind of meetings Chinese business executives would be able to secure if they came to Washington, according to the two people who meet frequently with Chinese foreign ministry officials but who are not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
who → answer → officials
This is making China even more uncertain about which business executives to bring.
asserted
China → make → executives
Another key issue on the table during Xi's visit to the U.S. is the impending expiration of a moratorium on Chinese export controls on rare earth products, and a parallel, one year delay on American export controls on advanced semiconductor chips which Chinese companies strongly need to further its AI goals.
asserted
companies → need → goals
Both moratoriums expire on November 10.
asserted
moratoriums → expire → November
However, officials from both the U.S. and China accuse each other of not holding up their end of the bargain and of quietly putting pressure on other supply chain chokepoints.
asserted
officials → accuse → chokepoints
The U.S. has objected multiple times to China's ongoing total rare earths export ban on Japan, with whom China has an ongoing geopolitical dispute and where many U.S. suppliers are located, arguing that it is a violation of the rare earths truce, according to two people involved in rare earth disputes but who are not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
who → object → disputes
The senior U.S. official said China's compliance on rare earth exports has been very disappointing.
American companies also have not received some export licenses for rare earths needed in specialized magnets, even after the moratorium, according to the two people in the disputes not authorized to speak publicly.
uncertain
companies → say → disputes
In August, China's commerce ministry sanctioned the Responsible Business Alliance (RBA), a U.S. supply chain monitor which helps run a minerals supply chain audit program, sending a further chill through the Chinese critical mineral industry.
asserted
which → sanction → industry
American companies have also been squeezed by China's ongoing export ban on phosphate, a key ingredient in fertilizer, which Beijing says is needed because of shortages caused by the Iran war.
asserted
Beijing → squeeze → war
Scott Bessent, the U.S. treasury secretary, has hinted at these tensions, saying in a Fox News interview in July after a call with China's vice premier over the summer: "You know, that's not an excuse for them to do things underneath the surface…
asserted
them → hint → surface
We expressed our concern that the rare earths are not flowing as freely as they could, that they have taken some measures that are detrimental to U.S. businesses.
uncertain
that → express → businesses
And we said that if this continues, we will push back."
asserted
we → say → ?
A public commitment from Beijing made during last spring's meeting, when Trump visited China, to buy at least 200 more Boeing planes from the U.S. has hit roadblocks as well.
asserted
Trump → make → roadblocks
…and 13 more, not listed.
The Aporia
