Senator Elizabeth Warren, the Democrat from Massachusetts who is set to take over as chairman of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, is trying to block General Motors from a $20 billion stock buyback plan.
asserted
who → set → plan
A letter from Warren to the GM CEO, Mary Barra, complains that the buyback would "enrich … shareholders" and "prioritize investor profits," Bloomberg News reported.
asserted
News → complain → profits
Isn’t that precisely what corporate managements are supposed to do?
asserted
managements → suppose → what
Senator Warren has frequently expressed concern about the federal deficit and also desire for increased federal spending.
asserted
Warren → express → spending
If longtime GM shareholders sell, they’ll have to pay capital gains tax.
asserted
they → sell → tax
You’d think Warren would be happy about the potential for capital gains tax revenue from the buyback plan.
asserted
Warren → think → plan
Yet even the prospect of more federal tax revenue for Warren and her fellow politicians in Washington to spend apparently isn’t enough to allay her anxiety about the danger that some shareholder, somewhere, might—heaven forbid—make a profit.
uncertain
heaven → spend → profit
If this is going to be Senate Democrats’ attitude toward shareholder profits, it’s going to be a long and rough two years for American investors.
asserted
it → go → investors
Warren appears to have been inspired by the incoming senator from Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed, who campaigned alongside socialist Bernie Sanders.
asserted
who → appear → Sanders
On October 21, immediately after GM announced the buyback, El-Sayed posted, "GM just announced the biggest stock buyback in automotive industry history.
asserted
GM → announce → history
Instead of investing in their workers or new product lines, GM executives are robbing from the future to pay themselves and their shareholders today.
asserted
executives → invest → themselves
If it were left up to El-Sayed, the American auto industry, and our entire economy, would be as pathetically stagnant and impoverished as that of Egypt, his ancestral home.
asserted
industry → leave → Egypt
The per capita GDP there is between $3,000 and $4,000 a year, where it’s been stuck for about a decade.
asserted
it → stick → decade
Warren, along with the Democratic leader, Chuck Schumer, and the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, Ron Wyden, introduced legislation in June proposing to quadruple the tax on stock buybacks.
asserted
Warren → introduce → buybacks
That effectively gives companies an incentive to do the buybacks now before the Democrats take over and quadruple the tax.
asserted
Democrats → give → tax
Schumer, who was first elected to Congress in 1980 and who before that served five years as a member of the New York State assembly, has been a longtime campaigner against stock buybacks.
asserted
who → elect → buybacks
As a Senate Democrats press release put it, "Leader Schumer has been outspoken on the need to increase taxes for stock buybacks.
asserted
Schumer → put → buybacks
In 2019, he penned an op-ed with Senator Sanders calling for a limit to corporate stock buybacks.
asserted
he → pen → buybacks
In 2022, he led the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, which enacted the original stock buyback tax.
asserted
which → lead → tax
Schumer introduced, with Senators Wyden and Bennett (D-CO), legislation that would increase the excise tax on stock buybacks of large oil and gas companies from 1 percent to 25 percent.
asserted
that → introduce → percent
Warren and the rest—except for Sanders, who is an independent socialist who caucuses with the Democrats—call themselves Democrats.
asserted
who → caucus → themselves
What could be more democratic than allowing shareholders to choose for themselves whether to sell back their stock or hold onto it?
uncertain
shareholders → allow → it
That’s essentially what a buyback plan does
asserted
plan → do → what
For shareholders who prefer to reallocate their cash away from GM toward other areas or companies they view as having more future promise for the price—whether super intelligence, space, nuclear energy, quantum computing or nanotechnology—they can do that.
asserted
they → prefer → that
For shareholders who want to stick with GM, they can hold onto the stock.
asserted
they → want → stock
Perhaps some shareholders might even want to take their GM profits and donate them to Harvard, where Warren’s husband, Bruce Mann, is paid $424,873 a year as a law professor.
uncertain
husband → want → professor
GM went bankrupt in 2009—and had a long decline before that—in part because management didn’t pay enough attention to customers or shareholders.
asserted
management → go → customers
The politicians will take shots at corporate management either way—for not making enough money, for making too much money.
asserted
politicians → take → money
The perfect amount of money, from the Schumer-Warren view, is the precise amount that lets the company management and its lobbyists give campaign contributions to Schumer without leaving too much afterward for the shareholders.
asserted
management → let → shareholders
Senator Warren’s office and GM did not immediately respond to inquiries from the Washington Free Beacon.
asserted
office → respond → Beacon
The politicians may have alternative preferred proposed uses for the capital—pay the workers more, or build factories for electric cars.
uncertain
politicians → have → cars
But in a free enterprise economy, it’s the owners of a company—and the management they elect—that get to choose how to allocate capital.
asserted
that → ’ → capital
Allocating private capital is not the job of senators, even those like Senator Elizabeth Warren, who used to be professors at Harvard Law School, or Senator-elect El-Sayed, who has an M.D. from Columbia University (as Columbia has been publicly celebrating in the election’s aftermath) and a D.Phil from Oxford University.
asserted
Columbia → allocate → University
If the senators think they know better than management how to allocate corporate capital, let them buy shares and wage a proxy campaign.
asserted
them → think → campaign
The alternative approach—performatively throwing their weight around with threatening political letters selectively shown to Bloomberg News—befits a dictatorship.
asserted
approach → throw → dictatorship