Downing Street has declined to rule out welfare reforms that would affect existing claimants after the Government’s independent reviewer of youth unemployment suggested some could receive less financial support under his proposals.
uncertain
some → decline → proposals
No 10 said the UK cannot afford to “continue paying the cost of failure” when young people fall out of work, education or training and should instead “invest earlier” in their success.
asserted
people → say → success
Ahead of his report on youth unemployment next week, Alan Milburn has acknowledged his proposals will not be “pain-free”, with some people potentially seeing reductions to their benefits entitlement under the recommendations.
asserted
people → acknowledge → recommendations
Under-25s would no longer be able to claim the health element of universal credit (UC) or personal independence payments (Pip), according to a Times report on some of the former Labour health secretary’s plans.
uncertain
Under-25s → claim → plans
They would instead move on to a “youth allowance”, paid at the same level as the standard rate of universal credit, prompting campaigners and MPs to voice concerns over the extent of future support.
asserted
They → move → support
No 10 declined to guarantee that existing claimants would not fall within the scope of any changes adopted following Mr Milburn’s review, but insisted the “safety net” would be maintained for those unable to work.
asserted
net → decline → those
Asked about the Times report, a Downing Street spokeswoman said the Government would consider its recommendations “in full”, adding: “The Prime Minister has already been clear that we need fundamental change in how we support young people to grow up in this country.
“
asserted
people → ask → country
As he has set out, we face a choice: we can either invest earlier in young people’s success or pay the cost of failure through the benefit system, but we cannot afford to do both.
asserted
we → set → both
“As you know, our focus is on creating jobs and opportunity, not crude cuts that push young people into crisis and simply move costs elsewhere in the system.”
asserted
that → know → system
Pressed on whether the Government is committed to ensuring its reforms do not affect existing claimants, the official said: “I think we’ll respond to the recommendations when the reports are published.
asserted
reports → press → recommendations
Read More
“But, again, I would just set out what the Prime Minister has said on this, and that is that we face a choice as a country.
asserted
we → read → country
“We can either invest earlier in young people’s success or continue paying the cost of failure when they become detached from education and work, and end up relying on the benefit system.
asserted
they → invest → system
We cannot afford to do both.”
asserted
We → afford → both
Opening the door to changes for existing claimants will risk reigniting a row with Labour MPs who last year pressured Sir Keir Starmer’s government to water down proposed welfare cuts, with protections for people already receiving Pip a key sticking point.
asserted
protections → open → Pip
Facing a major backbench rebellion, the Prime Minister ultimately shelved plans to tighten eligibility for the benefit at all in order to get the legislation through the Commons.
asserted
Minister → face → Commons
Mr Milburn was commissioned under Sir Keir to review the issue of so-called Neets – 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training – which topped a million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade.
asserted
which → commission → decade
He has previously warned the figure could rise to one in six by 2031, representing 1.25 million young people, and estimated the crisis is costing the UK around £125 billion a year – taking in factors including losses in taxes alongside higher health and welfare spending.
uncertain
crisis → warn → spending
Statistics out earlier this month also showed just under half (45.3%) of Neets were classed as disabled in the year to March – a proportion which has more than doubled in just over a decade.
asserted
which → show → decade
Charities representing disabled people have expressed concern at how Mr Milburn’s proposals, which he has described as a “big rewriting of the welfare system”, might work.
uncertain
he → represent → system
Labour MP Bell Ribeiro-Addy, who was part of the revolt which forced the Government to abandon proposals in summer 2025, expressed doubt as to whether she would be able to vote for the plans set out so far.
asserted
she → force → plans
“I am not sure I could vote for cuts unless it’s very clear what we’re voting on,” she told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.
uncertain
she → vote → programme
She said she did not believe “you get a disabled young person into work by taking away the money that helps them to get into work”, noting that Pip is not an out-of-work benefit.
asserted
Pip → say → work
“This report was meant to be all about young people out of work, you know the Neets, as we call them, but the cuts seem to land on young disabled people, and many of them are in college already or already at work.
asserted
many → mean → work
I don’t see how you fix the first by punishing the second,” she said.
asserted
she → see → second
Labour MPs Neil Duncan-Jordan and Rachael Maskell, who both temporarily lost the whip after voting against last year’s Bill, said there was not enough public information yet to say whether they could support the changes.
uncertain
they → lose → changes
Asked whether young people facing any reduction in their benefits should have another source of income guaranteed in its place beforehand, Mr Duncan-Jordan told the Press Association: “Absolutely.
asserted
Jordan → ask → Association
“And what if the employment doesn’t work out.
asserted
employment → work → ?
Does the individual start over again?”
asserted
individual → start → ?
He also questioned whether the Department for Work and Pensions staff would have the resources and skills to deliver the employment support programme Mr Milburn was suggesting.
asserted
Milburn → question → programme
Ms Maskell told PA: “Disability is complex, as it can be about the barriers that society creates as well as the challenges people experience in being able to gain independence or optimise activity.
asserted
people → tell → activity
Conflating this with a stick approach to work is wrong, which is why Pip was a separate benefit to UC.
asserted
Pip → conflate → UC
This is why I really need to see the detail.”
asserted
I → need → detail
Dame Meg Hillier, who was a leading rebel against the initial welfare proposals under Sir Keir, defended Mr Milburn’s approach and argued the plans set out so far were “very different to what was happening a year and a half ago”.
“(It) is a real vision for what needs to be done,” she told BBC Radio 4’s World at One programme.
“Some of these proposals are perhaps not a surprise that he’s got to coalesce around the problem.
asserted
he → lead → problem
He’s now proposing some of these solutions, and I think it’s quite radical and quite bold to be looking at… but quite right to be looking holistically at the person in the middle of this, not just about the money or the structure of the benefits.”
asserted
it → propose → benefits
Chrystyna Chymera-Holloway, from the National Autistic Society, said the plan will “live or die on the sequencing”.
asserted
plan → say → sequencing
She told PA: “Jobs and support to get into those jobs have to exist, and bespoke autism support to get into jobs has to exist before any changes that remove vital funds from people.
asserted
that → tell → people
Some 268,965 Pip claimants were classed as having autistic spectrum disorders as of July 31 2026, according to data published in September by the Department for Work and Pensions.
uncertain
claimants → class → Work
This is up from 79,395 in January 2019 when data began, according to PA analysis.
uncertain
data → begin → analysis
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation said young disabled people “shouldn’t have to trade financial security for better employment support”, adding they “need both”.
asserted
they → say → both
James Taylor, executive director of strategy at disability equality charity Scope, said the proposals trailed so far are “concerning”.
asserted
proposals → say → Scope
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
