Municipal bylaws are 'patchwork solutions' to a widespread issue, advocates say
Canadian cities are trying to stop invasive plants from being sold in local garden centres, as advocates push Ottawa to create a national approach to regulating the horticultural trade.
asserted
advocates → say → trade
With invasive plants threatening biodiversity across the country, municipalities are increasingly trying to fill gaps in a regulatory system that varies by jurisdiction.
asserted
that → threaten → jurisdiction
Canada, meanwhile, has set a target of reducing the rate of introduction and establishment of known invasive species by at least 50 per cent by 2030.
asserted
Canada → set → 2030
The Canadian Coalition for Invasive Plant Regulation (CCIPR) wants the federal government to establish a regulatory body for the horticultural industry and create a national database identifying invasive plants and their risks in different regions.
asserted
government → want → regions
"Even if we don't prohibit them, we need to let the public know when there is potential harm," said CCIPR co-founder Cathy Kavassalis.
asserted
Kavassalis → prohibit → them
"We do this on other products, and we should do it on plants too.
asserted
we → do → plants
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency regulates some invasive plants, while provinces and territories have their own invasive species or weed-control legislation.
asserted
provinces → regulate → legislation
CBC News reached out to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency for comment but did not receive a response by publication time.
asserted
News → reach → time
In July, Nanaimo council passed a motion to pursue a bylaw amendment restricting the sale of plants on a list maintained by the Invasive Species Council of B.C. A week later, Surrey moved to ban sales by businesses including nurseries, large retail chains and florists.
asserted
Surrey → pass → nurseries
In May, London, Ont.'s, environmental committee recommended requiring retailers that sell invasive plants and animals to provide information to customers at the point of sale.
uncertain
that → recommend → sale
Kavassalis said a problem that could be addressed at higher levels of government is being pushed down to municipalities.
uncertain
that → say → municipalities
"These are all patchwork solutions that, in some ways, just waste a lot of resources," she said.
asserted
she → waste → resources
Kirsty MacDonald, Nanaimo's parks manager, said invasive plants are already affecting the local landscape, with some posing potential risks to human health.
asserted
some → say → health
Most local plant suppliers were aware of the problem, she said, though invasive species can still appear in plant mixes or popular varieties such as English ivy.
asserted
species → say → ivy
"Banning the sale of new introductions [of invasive plants] in backyards, especially, is one method," she said.
asserted
she → ban → backyards
"It's a many-pronged approach that we need to be looking at to make some headway."
asserted
we → need → headway
"All levels of government really need to be part of the solution," she said.
asserted
she → need → solution
What advocates want Ottawa to do
Kavassalis said meeting the federal government's 2030 target will require addressing the horticultural trade.
asserted
meeting → want → trade
A 2021 study by University of Massachusetts Amherst researchers identified the sale of ornamental non-native plants as a "primary pathway" for introducing invasive plants in the United States.
asserted
study → identify → States
A 2023 study found plant nurseries could contribute about 80 per cent of invasive plant introductions there.
uncertain
nurseries → find → introductions
Kavassalis said the same problem exists in Canada.
asserted
problem → say → Canada
"Our gardens are actually the source of a lot of harm being done to our environment and economy," she said.
asserted
she → do → environment
The CCIPR says a national database could give provinces, territories, retailers and gardeners a shared source of information about which plants pose risks in different regions.
uncertain
plants → say → regions
Kavassalis also wants invasive plants removed from shelves or clearly labelled.
asserted
plants → want → shelves
What would new rules mean for nurseries?
asserted
rules → mean → nurseries
Jim Hole, a horticulture and agriculture expert who previously owned Hole Greenhouses and Gardens in St. Albert, Alta., said most garden centres would support efforts to prevent the spread of invasive plants.
asserted
centres → own → plants
When purple loosestrife was identified as invasive to wetlands, he said his greenhouse stopped selling it.
asserted
greenhouse → identify → it
With thousands of plants available, Hole said removing a species is unlikely to threaten a business.
asserted
removing → say → business
"It's not like you think, 'Oh well, there goes my business.
asserted
business → think → ?
That was a plant that I made all the money off of,'" he said.
asserted
he → make → money
He said stronger research, regulation and public education could also help greenhouse owners and farmers who spend time and money controlling unwanted plants.
uncertain
who → say → plants
"The payback is huge if you can keep even one more invasive species out," he said.
asserted
he → keep → species
Why gardeners still matter
Native plant advocate and author Lorraine Johnson said consumers often don't know which plants are invasive, while nurseries have significant influence over what people put in their gardens.
asserted
people → matter → gardens
She said the horticultural industry is "deeply implicated" in biodiversity loss.
asserted
industry → say → loss
"Their main bread and butter is selling non-native plants, introduced plants that have not co-evolved with those insects that we want to support, [or] with the pollinators," she said.
asserted
she → sell → pollinators
Kavassalis said regulating garden centres can also help gardeners get past "plant blindness," where every green thing can seem equal.
asserted
thing → say → blindness
"We need to help the public … treat the plants in their gardens not simply as garden decor, sort of outdoor living space, but as something that's connected to the greater living world."
asserted
that → need → world
The Aporia
