Russell Brand has been convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault, and sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison.
asserted
Brand → convict → prison
The Age, The Herald Sun, The Guardian, the ABC and The Australian all reported extensively on the trial, verdict and sentencing.
asserted
Age → report → trial
While it's certainly newsworthy that another public figure has finally been held to account for years of predatory behaviour, the nature of reporting on celebrity rape trials is worth examining.
asserted
nature → hold → trials
As the UK's Channel 4 reported, rape myths were a frequent and misleading feature in Brand's trial.
asserted
myths → report → trial
Research in Australia has found rape myths are routinely relied on in rape trials, not only by defence lawyers, but also by prosecutors, judges, juries and police.
asserted
myths → find → prosecutors
One pervasive one is the "monster myth": the belief that rape is committed by monstrously deviant strangers who attack innocent young girls in public places.
asserted
who → commit → places
Research shows this myth is prevalent in media reporting of rape, which has an impact on public perception and acceptance of the monster myth.
asserted
which → show → myth
In reality, as Australian Bureau of Statistics data shows, the person most likely to rape a woman is a man who is her intimate partner.
asserted
who → show → woman
In my research (which has not yet been peer reviewed) I used the AustLii database to identify 32 rape cases in the County Court of Victoria that resulted in a guilty outcome between July 2025 and August 2026.
asserted
that → review → July
I also searched for news reporting on those trials, finding 198 articles that fit the inclusion criteria.
asserted
that → search → criteria
Between them, Silvagni and Carr received 85 per cent of the media coverage of the entire dataset.
asserted
Silvagni → receive → dataset
They appeared in more than 60 per cent of the non-celebrity cases (almost entirely centred on the monster myth), and just over 40 per cent of the celebrity cases (where the myths that women commonly lie about rape and that men charged with rape are an object of pity predominated).
asserted
men → appear → pity
Every publication in the study included rape myths in some of their headlines about rape trials.
asserted
publication → include → trials
In other words, if media is reporting on a celebrity trial, too often the celebrity becomes the story, not the crime or the victim-survivor.
asserted
celebrity → report → trial
If they're reporting on rape cases, the monster myth is more likely to appear in the headline than the facts.
asserted
myth → report → facts
Of the 32 cases I identified, 13 were cases of rape in a family and domestic violence (FDV) context.
asserted
13 → identify → context
Fewer than 3 per cent of the articles were about the cases involving rape in an FDV context.
asserted
cent → involve → context
Journalists cannot identify the complainant (the legal term for the victim-survivor) in a rape trial, so if they report a FDV-related rape case, they often cannot name the perpetrator because it can identify the victim-survivor.
But the courts often use pseudonyms for both people when they publish sentencing remarks.
asserted
they → identify → remarks
Journalists could report these cases using those pseudonyms, preserving the victim-survivor's anonymity while still informing the public about the rape.
uncertain
Journalists → report → rape
I could not find a single article in my dataset that did this.
uncertain
that → find → this
Focusing such breathless attention on celebrity cases and the rare stranger-danger rape cases endorses exactly the kind of monster myths that The Guardian yesterday praised the judge in Brand's trial for dispelling in his sentencing remarks.
asserted
Guardian → focus → remarks
Suppression orders and the principles of open justice
In both the Silvagni and Carr cases, the men involved had been granted suppression orders that prevented media identifying them before they were convicted.
asserted
they → involve → them
The Age, the Herald Sun, The Guardian, The Australian and the ABC all published editorials or opinion pieces on the principles of open justice and how suppression orders prevented journalists reporting on the functioning of criminal courts — an essential component of a journalist's role in keeping the public informed about the functions of a democratic society.
asserted
journalists → publish → society
The media cannot claim to be serving the principles of open justice and ride a wave of their own self-righteous anger at suppression orders when those orders do not prevent them covering the trial.
uncertain
them → claim → trial
Particularly when they are failing to cover so many trials that do not feature a well-known perpetrator.
asserted
that → fail → perpetrator
The victim-survivor and the effect the person had on their life is the story.
asserted
person → have → life
The structures that allowed someone to commit these crimes can be the story, but breathless sensationalism has no place in reporting on rape.
asserted
sensationalism → allow → rape
This piece first appeared on The Conversation.
asserted
piece → appear → Conversation
The Aporia
.jpeg?trim=60,0,60,0&auto=webp&quality=75&width=1200)
