If there was one obvious conclusion from Democrats’ sweeping victories in the mid-term elections on Tuesday, it seemed to be that the Republican effort to redraw congressional districts in their favor backfired.
asserted
effort → be → favor
Starting last summer, Trump and Republican allies undertook an aggressive effort to redraw congressional districts, reconfiguring the lines to give Republican candidates an advantage.
asserted
Trump → start → advantage
Ahead of the midterms, Republicans redrew 15 seats to their advantage.
asserted
Republicans → redrew → advantage
After Tuesday’s election, they appear poised to lose all but two of them.
asserted
they → appear → them
“It was definitely the wrong move,” an unnamed House Republican told Fox News.
asserted
Republican → tell → News
“One of the truisms in politics is never to overreach.
asserted
One → overreach → politics
We did and that was part of the reason for the backlash.”
asserted
that → do → backlash
The Republicans losses included defeats in Texas, Florida and North Carolina where Republicans hoped to pick up as many as 10 combined congressional seats.
asserted
Republicans → include → seats
“The maps themselves did fail, and failed quite epically,” said John Bisognano, the president of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, a Democratic redistricting group.
asserted
Bisognano → fail → Committee
“I would also argue the idea itself was an even bigger failure.
asserted
idea → argue → ?
Allowing an environment to be created around you in which everyone begins to realize how deeply corrupt this administration is and how fearful they are of the American people in elections, so much so that their main tactical path forward is going to be to redraw maps to steal as many voters as they can.
asserted
they → allow → voters
But even though Republicans failed to pick up nearly all of the new seats they drew, it would be misleading to say that gerrymandering did not work at all in this election, said Nicholas Stephanopoulos, a professor at Harvard who studies redistricting.
asserted
who → fail → redistricting
Republicans didn’t pick up the seats because Democrats had the strongest midterm elections in half a century.
asserted
Democrats → pick → century
“Compared to [GOP] dreams of winning like five more seats, all of these maps under-delivered,” he said.
asserted
he → compare → maps
“There’s no reason why the best-case scenario of the gerrymander is the right baseline.”
asserted
scenario → ’ → gerrymander
Compared to a fair map that didn’t favor either party, he added, “a lot of these maps performed very well for Republicans.”
asserted
lot → compare → Republicans
It would be a mistake to interpret the election results to mean that gerrymandering is not a problem, Bisognano said.
asserted
Bisognano → interpret → results
“Democrats should not have needed to overperform by 10 to 15% in order to find the success that they found,” he said.
asserted
he → need → that
“It’s a corrosive problem that still plagues this country regardless of these electoral outcomes, and they’re going to come back with more of it.”
asserted
they → ’ → it
In Texas, for example, Republicans already held 25 of the state’s 38 congressional districts.
asserted
Republicans → hold → districts
Last year, they redrew the map to try and gain as many as five new congressional seats.
asserted
they → redrew → seats
They wound up winning just one of the districts they redrew.
asserted
they → wind → districts
That means Texas will hold 24 of the state’s 38 congressional districts, even though Democrats Gina Hinojosa and James Talarico got more than 50% of the vote statewide.
asserted
Hinojosa → mean → vote
“Nobody should think gerrymandering failed when Republicans are winning 65% of the seats in Texas with 45% of the vote.
asserted
Republicans → think → vote
That’s a massive victory for a gerrymander,” Stephanopoulos said.
asserted
Stephanopoulos → ’ → gerrymander
Adam Kincaid, a Republican mapmaker who drew the Texas maps, said he always saw the seats redrawn for Republicans to pick up in Texas as competitive seats.
asserted
Republicans → draw → seats
And that was on purpose, because in a cycle like this, you didn’t want to put incumbents in jeopardy going into the fall that otherwise wouldn’t have been in jeopardy,” he said.
asserted
he → want → jeopardy
There may be no state that had more of a gerrymandering backfire for Republicans than North Carolina.
uncertain
that → have → Carolina
Republicans already held 10 of the state’s 14 congressional seats, and then redrew them last year to add an additional Republican seat.
asserted
Republicans → hold → seat
The new map made it harder for Don Davis, a Black Democrat in the north-eastern part of the state, to win re-election.
asserted
Davis → make → election
Davis won re-election and Democrats may flip as many as six seats, giving them a 10-4 advantage in the state’s delegation.
uncertain
Democrats → win → delegation
Several Democrats barely won their races, even though Roy Cooper, a Democrat running for US Senate, won his race by nearly 20 points.
asserted
Cooper → win → points
In North Carolina, Republican lawmakers drew their advantage by efficiently distributing Republican votes efficiently – giving each GOP district a solid firewall that was durable under usual election conditions.
asserted
that → draw → conditions
But when the generationally large Democratic wave hit in the state, it completely overwhelmed the map.
asserted
it → hit → map
“The point is not to protect from the flood, it’s to protect from the wave,” Kincaid said.
asserted
Kincaid → protect → wave
“With any gerrymander, there’s literally some electoral tide that’s big enough to overwhelm the gerrymander.
asserted
that → ’ → gerrymander
You almost never see that tide,” Stephanopoulos said.
asserted
Stephanopoulos → see → tide
“North Carolina got the once-in-a-50-year wave that happened to wash out their gerrymander.”
asserted
that → get → gerrymander
Even though the unprecedented Democratic wave neutralized gerrymanders this election, they are poised to give Republicans an advantage in future elections this decade should the electoral environment shift back in their favor.
asserted
environment → neutralize → favor
“In Florida and in Texas and in numerous other places, if we snap back to a more neutral electoral environment in 2028 or 2030, like a lot of these districts will just flip right back to Republicans,” Stephanopoulos said.
asserted
Stephanopoulos → snap → Republicans
The Aporia
