My new essay in Civitas tries to make sense of how the midterm election affects the broader conservative legal movement.
asserted
election → try → movement
Here is the introduction:
President Donald Trump's surprise 2016 election saved Justice Antonin Scalia's seat and perhaps the Supreme Court.
asserted
saved → save → seat
Over the ensuing decade, Trump appointed scores of originalist judges at all levels of the judiciary and led a political movement that supported originalist state court judges and attorneys general.
asserted
that → ensue → judges
But that movement came to a screeching halt with the 2026 midterm election.
asserted
movement → come → election
Indeed, the blue tsunami, largely a referendum on Trump, threatens to drown originalism.
asserted
tsunami → threaten → originalism
In deep red states, conservative judges were washed off the bench.
asserted
judges → wash → bench
Also swept from office were conservative governors who appoint judges and attorneys general who litigate in those courts.
asserted
who → sweep → courts
Given the large Democratic Senate majority and unfavorable maps for 2028 and 2030, a Republican Senate with the votes to confirm originalist judges may not return until 2033 at the earliest.
uncertain
Senate → give → earliest
An entire generation of talent will be wasted.
asserted
generation → waste → talent
Legal conservatives need to carefully reconsider the political circumstances best suited to defend the Constitution.
asserted
conservatives → need → Constitution
The conservative legal movement has always existed in conjunction and disjunction with the broader conservative political movement.
asserted
movement → exist → movement
Certain long-term projects concerning the separation of powers and individual rights endure regardless of who is in office, but legal disputes arise with the exigencies of the day.
asserted
disputes → concern → day
The conservative legal movement will often, but not always, coalesce around current conservative political needs.
asserted
movement → coalesce → needs
Likewise, the conservative political movement will often, but not always, coalesce around the conservative legal movement.
asserted
movement → coalesce → movement
During two recent events, Justice Elena Kagan recognized this dichotomy.
asserted
Kagan → recognize → dichotomy
She observed that conservative members of the Supreme Court decide cases that are right "out of the playbook of the conservative legal movement," even as some of President Trump's policies suffer setbacks in the courts.
asserted
some → observe → courts
Indeed, Trump has repeatedly expressed frustration that his appointees rule against him.
asserted
appointees → express → him
And here is the conclusion:
Many legal conservatives came to terms with voting for Trump in 2016 as a way to save the Supreme Court.
asserted
came → come → Court
Many more legal conservatives came around to Trump in 2020 based on his track record of appointing originalist judges--although I think that record is overstated.
asserted
record → come → judges
When Trump was on the ballot in 2024, some legal conservatives supported Trump for fear that Kamala Harris would pack the Supreme Court.
asserted
Harris → support → Court
But 2026 altered the calculus.
asserted
2026 → alter → calculus
Trump, and those candidates he endorsed, were routed in red states.
asserted
he → endorse → states
Moreover, conservative judges and attorney generals were wiped from office.
asserted
judges → wipe → office
When the top of the ticket is no longer able to win elections, downballot judges and attorneys general do not stand a chance.
asserted
judges → win → chance
Red states can only bleed for so long until they turn blue.
asserted
they → bleed → ?
A necessary condition for a successful legal movement is a political party that can produce viable candidates.
asserted
that → produce → candidates
Going forward, the path of advancing the conservative legal movement requires a political reorientation.
asserted
path → go → reorientation
The conservative legal movement can only survive if conservative lawyers are in public office to move the law.
asserted
lawyers → survive → law
The blue tsunami cannot be allowed to drown originalism.
asserted
tsunami → allow → originalism
The Aporia
