Andy Burnham is facing criticism from within his own party over plans to establish regional boards to oversee the UK’s water industry, as an alternative to nationalization. Labour MP Clive Lewis has warned that without the power to take action like banning dividend payments and lowering prices, these boards would be “worse than useless.” Tory shadow environment minister Robbie Moore also criticized the proposal, arguing it will add bureaucracy and cost without improving outcomes for customers.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-16,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
Andy Burnham is facing a backlash over plans to create a series of regional 'boards' to oversee the water industry - as he seemingly retreats from nationalisation.
asserted
he → see → nationalisation
The quango-style bodies including mayors and officials would be tasked with monitoring firms under proposals being considered by the Government.
asserted
bodies → include → Government
The PM has talked up his determination to take back control of water, complaining that privatisation was one of the 'wrong turns' under Thatcher.
asserted
privatisation → talk → Thatcher
Last month he raged at companies for treating their customers 'as a blank cheque' after five suppliers were given the green light to increase bills.
asserted
suppliers → rag → bills
However, officials have raised concerns about the huge costs and legal challenges involved in restoring public ownership.
asserted
officials → raise → ownership
Mr Burnham now appears to be looking at scaled back options, including nine regional boards.
asserted
Burnham → appear → boards
As well as local political leaders, they could feature public health officials, customers and environmental officials.
uncertain
they → feature → officials
Andy Burnham is facing a backlash over plans to create a series of regional 'boards' to oversee the water industry - as he seemingly retreats from nationalisation
This idea was one of the recommendations of Sir John Cunliffe's Independent Water Commission published in June last year, but never taken up by Keir Starmer's Government.
It could now reportedly be included in a '10-year plan' speech being touted by Mr Burnham.
uncertain
It → face → Burnham
Aides said the contents of the plan were 'speculation' at this stage as it is 'way off'.
asserted
it → say → stage
However, even Mr Burnham's own allies have voiced scepticism about the proposal.
asserted
allies → voice → proposal
Labour MP Clive Lewis - who once offered to quit the Commons so Mr Burnham could contest his Norwich seat - warned regional boards would be 'worse than useless' unless they had the power to nationalise water firms.
uncertain
they → offer → firms
Mr Lewis posted on X that devolved powers were 'good' in theory but there was a 'large caution klaxon', adding: 'Given our own national govt can't even exercise effective control over privatised companies, what chance does local govt have?'
The backbencher suggested regional authorities would need to be able to take action such as banning the payment of dividends and cutting prices.
'
uncertain
authorities → post → prices
Will Burnham's regional bodies have the power to decide to end privatisation and take the service back into public ownership?' he added.
asserted
he → have → ownership
If the answer to any or all of those is no, then it's a worse than useless gesture and should be rejected.'
Tory shadow environment minister Robbie Moore said: 'Giving mayors more power over bosses' decisions sounds radical, but when everyone is responsible, no one is accountable, and bills will keep on rising.
asserted
bills → reject → decisions
'More layers of bureaucracy will not mean better outcomes for customers, especially when it means more and more public servants being hired at the taxpayer's expense.'
asserted
servants → mean → expense
Mr Moore said the geographical boundaries of the boards would not match those of the water companies.
'
asserted
boundaries → say → companies
The Prime Minister must stop making promises on water that he cannot keep, particularly with the country facing drought this summer and flooding forecast for the winter ahead,' he added.
asserted
he → stop → winter
Liberal Democrat environment spokesman Tim Farron said: 'After a summer of hosepipe bans and sewage being dumped at the first sight of rain, Andy Burnham thinks the answer is more politicians on boards.
asserted
answer → say → boards
'Water companies shouldn't be controlled by mayors, they should be owned by the people.
asserted
they → control → people
No-one is asking for more politicians and everyone knows there are better solutions.
asserted
everyone → ask → politicians
Labour MP Clive Lewis - who once offered to quit the Commons so Mr Burnham could contest his Norwich seat - warned regional boards would be 'worse than useless' unless they had the power to nationalise water firms
'
uncertain
they → offer → firms
This isn't a solution, it's a stitch-up for the very water companies who caused this mess.
asserted
who → cause → mess
'Bills will keep going up, sewage will keep going in, and when these companies go under it'll be customers who bail them out.
asserted
who → keep → them
'The only real fix is taking water out of the hands of profiteers and putting it into mutual ownership, run by and for the people who actually use it.
asserted
who → take → it
The Aporia
