The Justice Department faces an uphill legal battle in its bid to overturn a federal judge's dismissal of its Alaska Senate election lawsuit, according to legal experts who questioned whether the government can secure meaningful relief before voting ends Tuesday — even as a separate criminal investigation continues.
uncertain
investigation → face → relief
DOJ filed a notice of appeal after Obama-appointed U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed its lawsuit Sunday over the presence of two candidates named Dan Sullivan on Alaska's Senate ballot.
asserted
Gleason → file → ballot
The judge ruled that federal officials lacked standing because they had not demonstrated how its proposed remedy could address potential voter confusion without compromising ballot secrecy.
uncertain
remedy → rule → secrecy
With voting ending Tuesday, attorneys told Fox News Digital that even a successful appeal could leave the government scrambling to obtain an injunction or return to district court, while a defeat would leave the civil case dismissed without necessarily affecting potential criminal charges arising from the alleged recruitment of the second Sullivan.
uncertain
defeat → end → Sullivan
"The federal judge dismissed on a procedural issue — standing," election attorney Jason Torchinsky of Virginia-based firm Holtzman Vogel told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Torchinsky → dismiss → Digital
"So if the government were to prevail, it would either have to seek injunctive relief from the appeals court in the first instance; a very high bar, or go back down to the district court to seek relief.
asserted
it → prevail → relief
"
"Given the time available between now and close of polls [Tuesday], this is a heavy lift for the government," Torchinsky added.
asserted
Torchinsky → give → government
A reversal would not automatically change Alaska's election results.
asserted
reversal → change → results
DOJ would still need to obtain specific judicial relief, potentially requiring further proceedings in district court.
asserted
DOJ → need → court
Former federal prosecutor and ex-Pentagon official Cully Stimson similarly said that DOJ will have difficulty securing any immediate relief in its effort to pause the Sullivan-Peltola contest.
asserted
DOJ → say → contest
While Gleason was appointed by Obama, Stimson suggested the ruling did not appear partisan and said uncertainty remains because voting had not yet concluded.
uncertain
voting → appoint → Obama
"I'm not surprised that the judge did this.
asserted
judge → do → this
I don't think it would matter whether an Obama judge or any other judge appointed by any other president," Stimson told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Stimson → think → Digital
"Asking for injunctive relief way before anything even happens is a reach," he said, adding Alaska falls under the San Francisco-based Ninth Circuit, which will hear any appeal.
asserted
which → ask → appeal
But Stimson suggested DOJ may have a longer-term objective beyond winning an immediate injunction: establishing a legal record that could support further proceedings after the election, once the votes are counted.
uncertain
votes → suggest → election
"They may be filing these suits to establish a record and force Alaska and others supporting the status quo to defend what's happening, knowing that there's some level of confusion and they have the legal wheels churning," he said.
uncertain
he → file → confusion
"So after the vote is [over], they've started the legal wheels rolling."
asserted
wheels → start → ?
Former Assistant U.S. Attorney for North Florida Zack Smith added that if the Ninth Circuit does not hear the case promptly, DOJ could seek emergency review from the U.S. Supreme Court.
uncertain
DOJ → add → Court
While the Alaska case is considered unprecedented, according to the experts, the idea of a Supreme Court expedition at election time is not.
uncertain
idea → consider → time
On Dec. 9, 2000, one day after the Florida Supreme Court ordered a manual recount of disputed ballots in the Bush v. Gore presidential election dispute involving "hanging chads," then-Texas Gov. George W. Bush’s legal team successfully sought emergency intervention.
asserted
team → order → intervention
The court ultimately decided in Bush’s favor within a week.
asserted
court → decide → week
Since the disputed 2000 election, which featured "hanging chads" on hole-punched paper ballots and the Brooks Brothers Riot at the Miami-Dade elections office, DOJ has become well-accustomed to the expedited-review process, the experts said.
asserted
experts → feature → process
"DOJ is familiar with kind of working quickly, getting things to the Supreme Court, and so I wouldn't be completely surprised if you were to see something like that," Smith said.
asserted
Smith → work → that
Bush v. Gore offers a procedural parallel because federal courts were asked to intervene in the administration of a state-run election.
asserted
courts → offer → election
"Florida was conducting the election in the manner under Florida law, under this time, place and manners set out by Florida law even though it was a federal election," Stimson said.
asserted
Stimson → conduct → law
"They used a particular type of ballot, which had those so-called dangling chads, which were punch-holes that didn't come the whole way off, so the hole was left with a little tag, essentially like a skin tag, and eventually the Supreme Court of Florida ruled.
asserted
Court → use → Florida
"But because there were federal violations, eventually the Supreme Court weighed in and stopped it, And at no point in time had the vice president’s (Albert Gore) vote count ever surpassed that of the governor (Bush) and because it was a federal interest, the Supreme Court stepped in and stopped this counting at the state level."
asserted
Court → be → level
Alex Charns, an attorney who has argued in federal court, told Fox News Digital that the clock has run out and DOJ's goal of segregating ballots based on voter intent is no longer possible.
asserted
goal → argue → intent
"I've litigated against the USDOJ for over thirteen years in federal court.
asserted
I → litigate → court
I've practiced law in Durham, NC for 43 years.
asserted
I → practice → years
The USDOJ filed a case without legal merit and its appeal is likely to fail," he said.
asserted
he → file → merit
"In addition, voting ends [Tuesday].
asserted
voting → end → addition
The relief they seek isn't possible - ballots already case can't be segregated.
asserted
ballots → seek → ?
Also, one cannot tell why any voter voted in a particular way.
asserted
voter → tell → way
In a statement from the DOJ's "Rapid Response" office, a spokesperson said the court "dismissed the case on procedural grounds but did not dispute the argument of the United States that Daniel J. Sullivan (a/k/a Decoy Dan) entered the race as a frivolous candidate to confuse voters.
asserted
Sullivan → say → voters
"Alaskan voters deserve a fair election, not to be misled in an attempt to rig outcomes," DOJ-RR said, announcing their appeal.
asserted
RR → deserve → appeal
Stimson cautioned that the outcome of the civil litigation would have little bearing on the separate criminal investigation, which could uncover evidence supporting additional legal action even if DOJ's appeal fails.
uncertain
appeal → caution → action
"As long as that criminal investigation is going on, you're not breathing easy," he said, adding that evidence uncovered by federal investigators could potentially provide grounds for a separate civil lawsuit.
uncertain
evidence → go → lawsuit
The Aporia
