Indigenous leaders have launched a new volley of court challenges against Prime Minister Mark Carney’s push to rapidly approve the Pacific Link oil pipeline, arguing Ottawa failed to adequately consult an array of First Nations.
asserted
Ottawa → launch → Nations
Two new applications for judicial review, representing nine First Nations, call on the Federal Court to quash Ottawa’s declaration of the proposed oil pipeline as a project of national interest.
asserted
applications → represent → interest
At a Monday press conference in the Vancouver suburb of Richmond, Indigenous leaders asserted that Ottawa’s plan is unconstitutional and effectively pre-approved the pipeline after cursory talks with some First Nations over three months through the summer.
asserted
- → assert → summer
“It bypasses the meaning of what consultation is,” said Terry Teegee, regional Chief of the British Columbia Assembly of First Nations.
asserted
Teegee → bypass → Nations
“Other First Nations should all be concerned across this country.”
asserted
Nations → concern → country
The federal government, at the start of October, announced the national-interest designation for the Pacific Link oil pipeline, from the Edmonton area to a port in the Vancouver region.
asserted
government → announce → region
This plan provides Ottawa’s backing at the start of the process and will enable it to grant many necessary and varied permits much more quickly than in the past.
asserted
plan → provide → past
It also marked the first such move under the Building Canada Act, a centrepiece of Mr. Carney’s work to shift Canada’s economy away from the capricious whims of the United States.
asserted
It → mark → States
The latest court challenges up the stakes against the national-interest designation.
asserted
challenges → up → designation
In October, Cold Lake First Nations in Alberta filed the first case in Federal Court, focused on inadequate consultation and the related Pathways carbon capture project in the oil sands that Mr. Carney has tied to the Pacific Link pipeline.
asserted
Carney → file → pipeline
The federal Liberals want the Pacific Link review process done by September and the pipeline built and moving oil by 2032, at an estimated cost of about $40-billion.
asserted
pipeline → want → billion
This is an unprecedented timetable for such major infrastructure work in recent decades and more so echoes pipeline building in the 1950s.
asserted
This → echo → 1950s
While Mr. Carney aims to transform the Canadian economy in a handful of years, the risk looming over these ambitions has always been legal challenges against the fast-track pipeline review process.
asserted
risk → aim → process
In the 2010s, before the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion was eventually built, setbacks in court because of inadequate Indigenous consultations delayed the plan for years.
asserted
setbacks → build → years
The legal losses followed former Conservative prime minister Stephen Harper’s legislative changes to speed pipeline approvals.
asserted
losses → follow → approvals
As of last year, Canada produced 5.4 million barrels of oil a day – double the output of the mid-2000s when the oil sands boom began.
asserted
boom → produce → mid-2000s
The country is the world’s fourth-largest oil producer, with 3.9 million barrels a day going to the United States.
asserted
barrels → go → States
In the federal government’s official order on Oct. 1 declaring the Pacific Link pipeline in the national interest, it stated it had “taken into account the concerns” identified in consultations with Indigenous people.
asserted
it → declare → people
It also described “meaningful dialogue” and concluded “Canada has fulfilled the duty to consult, consistent with the honour of the Crown,” invoking key pillars of constitutional obligations affirmed in several Supreme Court of Canada rulings.
asserted
Canada → describe → rulings
As Ottawa prioritized Pacific Link, Energy Minister Tim Hodgson acknowledged legal challenges were coming.
asserted
challenges → prioritize → Link
“Whether they’ll be successful or not is a very different question,” he said on Oct. 1.
asserted
he → say → Oct.
Pacific Link would carry a million barrels a day, on the same terrain and with about the same capacity as Trans Mountain.
asserted
Link → carry → Mountain
On Monday, a spokeswoman for Intergovernmental Affairs Minister Dominic LeBlanc said Ottawa had “conducted rigorous consultations” with more than 110 Indigenous communities near or along the potential pipeline route.
asserted
Ottawa → say → route
“Canada will continue to uphold its duty to meaningfully consult with Indigenous peoples,” spokeswoman Eve Loignon-Giroux said in a statement.
asserted
Giroux → continue → statement
In the new Federal Court challenges, the Cheam First Nation alleged that “Cabinet erred in law by proceeding without adequate consultation.”
asserted
Cabinet → allege → consultation
The Cheam – located on the Fraser River east of Vancouver near the Trans Mountain pipeline and proposed Pacific Link – filed as an applicant on behalf of itself and seven other First Nations.
asserted
Cheam → locate → itself
“We stand up to hold the Federal Crown accountable,” Cheam Chief Michael Victor said.
asserted
Victor → stand → ?
“Our Nation believes in Nation-building but it must treat First Nations as equal constitutional partners.”
asserted
it → believe → partners
The Tsartlip First Nation, near Victoria, also announced on Monday that it had filed a Federal Court challenge, stating that Ottawa’s Major Projects Office only provided “very general information” about the proposed pipeline and calling the consultation process “defective.”
asserted
Office → announce → process
Experts have forecasted details of the legal challenges the federal government would face.
asserted
government → forecast → challenges
In early October before the first legal challenge, University of Calgary law professor David Wright described the Building Canada Act as “experimental deregulation,” a law that had come into force in June “after a virtually unprecedented expedited legislative process.”
asserted
that → describe → process
The key question is whether Ottawa fulfilled its duty to consult and accommodate each First Nation involved.
asserted
Ottawa → fulfil → Nation
Prof. Wright cited a 2020 Federal Court of Appeal decision, which Ottawa won, after the Trans Mountain project had been challenged a second time over inadequate Indigenous consultation.
asserted
project → cite → consultation
The ruling, in its look at meaningful consultation, spoke of “two-way dialogue” that leads to “demonstrably serious consideration of accommodation.”
asserted
that → speak → accommodation
“How the government will try to achieve this in such an extremely compressed timeframe remains to be seen,” Prof. Wright said in his analysis of the goal to complete the Pacific Link review by September.
asserted
Wright → try → September
“The term ‘mission impossible’ comes to mind.”
asserted
mission → come → mind
Last week, Dawn Farrell, chief executive officer of Ottawa’s Major Projects Office, told MPs on Parliament Hill that her team compiled the concerns of affected First Nations this summer and is still consulting with them.
asserted
team → tell → them
She said she understands some First Nations are critical of the accelerated approval process.
asserted
Nations → say → process
“We haven’t been able to show them what our intentions are and we haven’t been able to follow through and make sure that the work that we do is as we say it’s going to be,” Ms. Farrell told a meeting of the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development.
asserted
Farrell → show → Environment
The Aporia
