On a Monday afternoon in late September, Donald Trump gathered Iowa Republicans in the Oval Office to make a big announcement: the firm Mesabi Metallics would invest $15bn to make the midwestern state the site of the largest steel mill in the country.
asserted
state → gather → country
One month later, and just days before the midterm election, word has spread in the small town of Wever, population 142, that the mill will be built somewhere nearby.
asserted
mill → spread → Wever
And that’s been about it – no shovels in the dirt, workers on a job site or machinery on the dirt roads leading down towards the Mississippi River.
asserted
that → lead → River
Ask about the project in town, and the reaction isn’t enthusiasm, but skepticism.
asserted
reaction → ask → town
“More jobs,” Missy Pollpeter, 52, said of the project’s potential as she dined at the Green Bay Bar and Grill, Wever’s only restaurant.
asserted
she → say → Bar
“If they bring it here,” her husband, Mike Pollpeter, 60, said as he finished a burger.
asserted
he → bring → burger
On paper, a steel mill seems like a great development for a corner of Iowa that has a long history both of manufacturing and the disinvestment that has struck so much of the industrial midwest.
asserted
that → seem → midwest
According to the White House, the project would create 6,000 jobs during its construction and then 1,750 when it is complete, and generate $95bn in economic activity.
uncertain
it → accord → activity
What people can’t get over is how the project was debuted, and who was announced it.
asserted
who → get → it
The president made the plan public just over a month before Tuesday’s midterm elections, when Iowa will play a major role in determining if Democrats regain control of Congress amid Trump’s downbeat approval ratings.
asserted
Democrats → make → ratings
Wever itself lies in a congressional district that is viewed as the most competitive in the state.
asserted
that → lie → state
And then there’s the fact that Trump has a history of making proclamations that don’t quite pan out.
asserted
that → ’ → proclamations
“Remember Foxconn?” asked Jeff Thompson as he served drinks at Green Bay “Bottoms Up”, the town’s only bar.
asserted
he → remember → Bay
Foxconn is the electronics manufacturing giant that Trump famously declared would build a massive factory in neighboring Wisconsin during his first term, only for the project to wind up flopping.
asserted
project → manufacture → term
A similar situation may be playing out elsewhere this year.
uncertain
situation → play → ?
Just days after debuting plans for the Iowa steel mill, the president said South Korea would invest $54bn in building a long-discussed natural gas pipeline in Alaska, only for officials in Seoul to say they’d agreed to no such deal.
But
asserted
they → debut → deal
Iowa’s Republican-controlled legislature was undeterred, and quickly approved $1.4bn in tax breaks to make the mill happen.
asserted
mill → control → breaks
Charles Sutton, a spokesperson for Mesabi, a Minnesota-based firm that is part of the Indian conglomerate Essar Group, said they are on track to produce steel by 2030 from a site in “eastern Iowa”, the location of which will be announced “in the very near future”.
“The project is in active development with strong momentum,” Sutton said.
asserted
Sutton → base → momentum
“We anticipate being able to make several announcements in the coming weeks in line with the project schedule.”
asserted
We → anticipate → schedule
Mariannette Miller-Meeks, the Republican who represents south-eastern Iowa, said that “the project is for sure happening”.
asserted
project → represent → Iowa
Elected to a third term in 2024 by less than 800 votes, she is a top target of Democrats this year as they vie to regain control of Congress’s lower chamber.
asserted
they → elect → chamber
As she campaigned in Fort Madison, 10 minutes south of Wever, Miller-Meeks credited Trump’s tariff regime and his major domestic policy bill with making the project possible, but said that the details of the mill are under negotiation between the county and Mesabi.
asserted
details → campaign → county
“It will be on the outcome of those negotiations, but it will be coming to south-east Iowa,” she said.
asserted
she → come → Iowa
Blaine Watkins, a Republican who represents the area in the state legislature, said the mill would “completely change” Lee county, where Trump won almost two-thirds of the vote in 2024.
asserted
Trump → represent → 2024
Talks to make it happen had been going on for seven or eight months, he said, and he had a hard time believing they wouldn’t come to fruition.
asserted
they → make → fruition
“As far as I’m concerned, unless someone says we’re not going to do it, they’re doing it, and we’re negotiating like they’re going to do it,” he said.
asserted
he → concern → it
Just a short drive north from Wever is Burlington, the closest small city to the proposed plant.
asserted
Burlington → propose → plant
It was long known as the “Backhoe Capital of the World”, since the excavators were first produced there.
asserted
excavators → know → World
Earlier this year, the multinational firm CNH closed the plant that made the machines, putting about 200 people out of work.
asserted
that → close → work
Burlington’s mayor, Jon Billups, said many who lost jobs found other work at manufacturers in the area, and welcomed the idea of a steel mill being built within commuting distance.
asserted
mill → say → distance
“What happens that’s good for the region is good for Burlington, and what happens in Burlington is normally good for the region,” he said.
asserted
he → happen → region
To the Democrats hoping to win statewide office in Iowa after years of losses, the plant is a good idea to them as well – if it happens.
asserted
it → hop → them
“I hope so,” Josh Turek, the Democratic state representative running for US Senate, replied, when asked if he thought the facility would get built.
asserted
facility → hope → Senate
Noting that he had voted for the tax breaks in the legislature, Turek said: “We need the jobs and we need American manufacturing to return here, and return here to Iowa because this is a state that is uniquely hurting and struggling.”
asserted
that → note → Iowa
Rob Sand, the Democratic nominee for governor, said: “A good deal for Iowans that gets the steel plant done would be a priority.
asserted
plant → say → Iowans
But I’m not going to give away the farm to get there.
asserted
I → go → farm
Local trade unions would normally be excited about such a massive project, but have their doubts about this one.
“I want it to be real, right?
asserted
it → have → one
I think it’d be great for the area.
asserted
it → think → area
I think it’s great for the workers, but I’m skeptical,” said Chris Tucker, the international representative for the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, which has endorsed Turek and Sand.
asserted
which → think → Turek
For Ryan Drew, president of the Des Moines-Henry County Labor Alliance, seeing Trump announce the news in the Oval Office along with Miller-Meeks and Ashley Hinson, the US congresswoman facing Turek in the Senate race, gave him pause.
asserted
Trump → see → pause
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
