- Published
At the heart of the debate around legal migration are contested notions of fairness.
asserted
notions → publish → fairness
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has talked of her parents coming to the UK from rural Kashmir.
asserted
Mahmood → talk → Kashmir
Now, this daughter of immigrants is responsible for reshaping the very system that brought them here decades ago – and doing so in a way that both her party and the country regard as fair.
asserted
party → reshape → that
"Fair to those who seek a new and better life here, like my parents did.
asserted
parents → seek → life
And fair to those already here, including British workers, and especially the young," is how Mahmood put it in her speech to the Labour Party conference in September.
asserted
Mahmood → include → September
The debate has come at a time of huge legal immigration in recent years and during a period in which Reform UK have been particularly prominent in the national political conversation.
asserted
UK → come → conversation
Both of these things are factors in Labour wanting to be seen to be taking people's concerns about the scale of arrivals seriously.
asserted
Labour → want → arrivals
But her political opponents smell what they see as weakness and retreat, with parts of her original plan now being revised, as the BBC's Iain Watson reported over the weekend.
asserted
Watson → smell → weekend
It is worth examining this policy throughout the last year or so, as it is instructive in how we have arrived at today's announcement.
asserted
we → examine → announcement
In November last year, Mahmood set out a plan called "a fairer pathway to settlement".
asserted
Mahmood → set → settlement
The idea was opinions on her instincts would be sought in a consultation.
asserted
opinions → seek → consultation
And boy, were their plenty of opinions offered.
asserted
plenty → offer → opinions
Around 200,000 people contributed to the consultation, of which 140,000 responses came from visa holders themselves I'm told.
asserted
I → contribute → holders
"It's been a colossal exercise and a genuine one," is how one Whitehall source put it to me, claiming: "We have taken the time to get this right."
Or is the real truth that they have buckled under political pressure from their own side – and a change of prime minister?
asserted
they → put → minister
Mahmood said last year that she felt compelled to act because "between 2021 and 2024, we have seen net migration of an additional 2.6 million people.
asserted
we → say → people
Around one in every 30 people in this country today arrived in these four years."
asserted
people → arrive → years
It is what critics have labelled "the Boriswave", named for the changes made under former Prime Minister Boris Johnson.
asserted
critics → label → Johnson
And, Mahmood argued, it was important to act with urgency, as very soon significant numbers of those recent arrivals would start qualifying for indefinite leave to remain, or ILR.
asserted
numbers → argue → leave
"Migrants on lower wages who bring non-working dependants and children are likely to present significant fiscal costs to the UK.
asserted
who → bring → UK
"It is therefore right that we apply more stringent controls for this group before they qualify for settled status," she said, adding: "Under our current rules, they will usually qualify for benefits payments and council housing five years after arrival.
asserted
they → apply → arrival
"As the majority of this group began arriving from 2022 onwards, this is currently set to begin in 2027.
asserted
this → begin → 2027
We consult here on a separate baseline qualifying period, of 15 years, for this group.
asserted
We → consult → group
"
But plenty within the Labour Party and beyond were uncomfortable – and yes, they cited fairness, or the perceived lack of it, in mounting their criticisms.
asserted
they → cite → criticisms
As the now Housing Secretary Angela Rayner put it in March, before she returned to government, the ideas were "un-British" because they involved "moving the goalposts" - migrants who had arrived in good faith under one set of rules would have their future in the UK determined by the new ones.
asserted
future → put → ones
Just a few weeks before Rayner's intervention, Mahmood had doubled down on her plans.
asserted
Mahmood → double → plans
Addressing the centre left IPPR think tank, she said "in just four years, this country experienced levels of migration it had previously seen across four decades.
asserted
it → address → decades
There was more, and with a big number attached.
"
asserted
number → be → ?
We have never, in the history of this country, had so much low-skilled migration in so little time.
asserted
We → have → time
We estimate, based on findings from the Migration Advisory Committee, that the lifetime cost to the taxpayer will be £10bn.
asserted
cost → estimate → taxpayer
That figure would be paid for by working people in this country."
asserted
figure → pay → country
She added: "It is an affront to the idea of fairness within our migration system."
asserted
It → add → system
Incidentally, the £10bn figure is contested by some – or at least placed in a wider context.
asserted
figure → contest → context
The aforementioned IPPR argue that the original plans were "never in reality going to create a £10bn long-term saving, given they were meant to delay care workers' eligibility for ILR rather than prevent them from settling altogether.
"Delaying ILR would save money on welfare, whereas the £10bn figure includes much broader long run costs once care workers enter retirement, claim the state pension, and make greater use of health and social care."
uncertain
workers → argue → health
Nonetheless, Mahmood's message in March left senior Conservatives privately agreeing with her – and struck by her willingness to be unflinching in her approach to the subject.
asserted
message → leave → subject
But around 100 of her Labour colleagues were not happy – and making their views known publicly.
asserted
views → make → colleagues
By the time I found myself in the dusty car park of a sports club near Wigan in May, waiting to talk to an ambitious by-election candidate by the name of Andy Burnham, it was clear changes were highly likely.
uncertain
changes → find → Burnham
He told me it was important to "work hard to get the balance right" but that the "broad thrust" of what the home secretary was doing "is right".
asserted
secretary → tell → what
"Broad thrust" will be the words that account for the gap between what Mahmood used to say and what she is saying today.
asserted
she → account → what
The Conservatives and others will seize upon the change.
asserted
Conservatives → seize → change
The Tories will argue it amounts to an "excruciating U-turn" as one senior figure described it to me, claiming it would be "deeply personally embarrassing" for the home secretary.
asserted
it → argue → secretary
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
