For almost three decades, dark energy has been the standard explanation for why the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate.
asserted
universe → expand → rate
Now, a team of mathematicians is challenging this widely accepted theory.
asserted
team → challenge → theory
The mathematicians at the University of California, Davis, argue that the answer may already lie within Einstein’s own equations and that an invisible form of energy may not be needed at all.
uncertain
form → argue → energy
The findings are published in the journal
Proceedings of the Royal Society A.
asserted
findings → publish → Society
The researchers worked with the Einstein-Euler equations, which combine Einstein’s general relativity with the rules that govern how fluids move.
asserted
fluids → work → rules
They used these tools to test the leading framework for explaining the universe’s evolution since the Big Bang, known as the Lambda-cold dark matter model, and found a weak spot in its very foundation.
asserted
They → use → foundation
Einstein’s equations may explain
Blake Temple, the study’s corresponding author and a professor emeritus of mathematics at UC Davis, offered a simple comparison: a pencil balanced vertically on its tip.
uncertain
Temple → explain → tip
“All the forces are in balance when a pencil is standing on end, so it is a ‘solution’ of the equations.
asserted
it → stand → equations
But it’s unstable.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Any breath of air and it falls away,” Temple said in a release.
asserted
Temple → fall → release
According to him, the standard model behaves in a similar way.
uncertain
model → accord → way
The mathematical structures at its core, known as Friedmann spacetimes, are unstable, and the standard solution is unusually fragile.
asserted
solution → know → spacetimes
Physicists tend to treat unstable solutions as unphysical.
asserted
Physicists → tend → solutions
“Unstable solutions in physics and science are considered not physical.
asserted
solutions → consider → physics
You’ll never observe them in nature,” Temple said.
asserted
Temple → observe → nature
If the real universe drifts away from that model, the team argues, the accelerating expansion may not require a separate source of energy.
uncertain
expansion → drift → energy
The researchers say the answer is already contained in Einstein’s original theory of gravity.
asserted
answer → say → gravity
"The instability of all Friedmann spacetimes to accelerated expansion suggests a simpler, more natural explanation for the acceleration of the universe than dark energy," he said.
uncertain
he → accelerate → energy
Early expansion linked to a shockwave?
asserted
expansion → link → shockwave
The research did not begin as a rethink of cosmology.
asserted
research → begin → cosmology
According to Temple, the team first wondered whether a massive shockwave could explain the early expansion, with the unexpected acceleration coming from a wave trailing behind it.
uncertain
acceleration → accord → it
This very question led them to these findings.
asserted
question → lead → findings
"Our first idea was that maybe the universe was expanding because there was a shockwave, and the anomalous acceleration was the expanding wave behind that shockwave.
asserted
acceleration → expand → shockwave
Then we realised there's a family of self-similar solutions during the radiation epoch of the Big Bang, which might model that expanding wave,” Temple said.
uncertain
Temple → realise → wave
The researchers used Einstein’s equations to examine whether the standard model of the universe remains stable when slightly disturbed.
asserted
model → use → universe
They found that these disturbances grow rather than fade away during the period when matter dominated the universe.
asserted
matter → find → universe
They suggest that the conventional mathematical descriptions of the expanding universe are vulnerable to disturbances that grow rather than fade.
asserted
that → suggest → disturbances
"We prove that, like Einstein's static model, the Friedmann spacetimes are all unstable to radial perturbation at large length scales.
asserted
spacetimes → prove → scales
This appears to rule out the Lambda-cold dark matter model as a viable stable solution of the Einstein equations of general relativity, with or without dark energy,” Temple said.
asserted
Temple → appear → energy
The researchers found that radial disturbances could cause the universe to expand differently from what the standard model predicts.
uncertain
model → find → what
"This means that the Big Bang should generically look exactly like a Friedmann spacetime near the centre of symmetry, but generically one should observe accelerations away from Friedmann far from the centre,” he explained.
asserted
he → mean → centre
The researchers also raise an older idea: the Copernican principle.
asserted
researchers → raise → idea
Named after Nicolaus Copernicus, it holds that Earth and its observers do not occupy a special position in the universe.
asserted
Earth → name → universe
The Copernican principle must be applied consistently when evaluating competing explanations of the universe, Temple argues.
asserted
Temple → apply → universe
"Both the Lambda-cold dark matter model and a spherically symmetric spacetime produce a special place where we must lie for the model to be physically plausible.
asserted
model → produce → place
If this principle rules out one, it has to rule out the other,” Temple said.
asserted
Temple → rule → other
The research was supported by the United Kingdom’s Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council and the American Institute of Mathematics SQuaREs Program.
asserted
research → support → Mathematics
The Aporia
