Supreme Court hears religious freedom case centered on universal pre-K program
asserted
Court → hear → program
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court hears arguments in a case that pits the Catholic Church against taxpayer funded school programs for all 4-year-olds in Colorado.
asserted
that → hear → Colorado
At issue is whether religious schools may refuse to admit the children of gay and trans parents in violation of a state law that bars discrimination.
uncertain
that → refuse → discrimination
The first line of the Bill of Rights says: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."
asserted
Congress → say → exercise
As early as the founding of this country, Thomas Jefferson described the clause as creating a "wall of separation between church and state."
asserted
Jefferson → describe → church
The Supreme Court formally embraced that idea in the 1940s, making it the law of the land — until roughly 10 years ago.
asserted
it → embrace → land
That's when the court's new conservative majority made an increasingly dramatic doctrinal U-turn, focusing not on the separation of church and state, but on that second clause in the First Amendment: protecting the free exercise of religion.
asserted
majority → make → religion
It is just a complete shift," says Michigan State University law professor Frank Ravitch, who has written extensively about the Constitution's religion clauses.
asserted
who → say → clauses
To cite just one example, the Supreme Court, by an 8-to-1 vote, ruled in 1983 that that Bob Jones University should lose its tax exempt status because it prohibited interracial dating and interracial marriage on religious grounds, and that constitutes racial discrimination that the government money may not support.
uncertain
money → cite → that
That said, it's unclear if the court will reach a similar conclusion now.
uncertain
court → say → conclusion
Because race has a "unique" place in U.S. history, contends professor Douglas Laycock, emeritus professor of law at the University of Texas at Austin and the University of Virginia.
asserted
Laycock → have → Virginia
Nothing like that for any other group," he says.
asserted
he → say → group
As for the Colorado case, Laycock acknowledges that the Denver archdiocese is discriminating, but he adds, "The question is whether that discrimination is a protected exercise of religion."
asserted
discrimination → acknowledge → religion
Rather than focusing on separation of church and state, the current court instead has focused on the rights of religious groups when pitted against state and federal laws that ban discrimination based on race, sex, religion or other categories.
asserted
that → focus → race
It's the sex part that has thrown a monkey wrench into Colorado's broad program aimed at ensuring that virtually all 4-year-olds in the state get a pre-K education.
asserted
olds → throw → education
"The law really was about implementing a program that said we want every kid, no matter where you live, to be able to have access to universal preschool," says Steve Fenberg, who served as president of the Colorado state Senate when the pre-k program was enacted, complete with a $6,300 benefit for each child enrolled in the program every year, money that comes from a tobacco tax.
asserted
that → implement → tax
To accomplish that, the state did something most other states have not.
asserted
states → accomplish → something
It created a broad plan, including religious schools, as long as the schools abide by a state law that bars discrimination based on race, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity.
asserted
that → create → race
Colorado state Rep. Emily Sirota, a prime sponsor of the universal pre-K bill, emphasizes that the state wanted parents to have "a robust choice" about where their 4-year-olds would go to school.
asserted
olds → emphasize → school
Indeed, she notes that the Catholic Church initially endorsed the program, and Catholic Charities continues to participate, along with other religious groups, including at least 35 Christian schools, one Muslim and three Jewish schools.
"The caveat is that you can't discriminate, and you need to allow all students to participate," says former state Sen. Fenberg.
asserted
Fenberg → note → schools
That caveat is where things went awry.
asserted
things → go → ?
The Denver Archdiocese and two parishes challenged the law in court, represented by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and its CEO, Mark Rienzi.
asserted
Archdiocese → challenge → Liberty
He maintains that the Colorado law flatly discriminates against Catholic schools.
asserted
law → maintain → schools
"They're only excluding religious schools that are organized around beliefs that Colorado doesn't like.
asserted
Colorado → exclude → that
And that's the constitutional problem," says Rienzi.
asserted
Rienzi → say → ?
"Not everybody has to be Catholic to show up, but they do have to agree to support Catholic teachings and not publicly contradict Catholic teachings.
asserted
they → have → teachings
That's the way these schools are set up.
asserted
schools → set → ?
"
Therefore, the church wants an exemption from the state's anti-discrimination law, which makes it illegal to refuse entrance to school for 4-year-olds whose parents or potentially other family members are gay or trans.
asserted
parents → want → olds
Of course, not all Catholic programs march to the same drummer.
asserted
programs → march → drummer
"I don't agree with the sky is falling," says Tim Uhl, who has held multiple leadership positions for Catholic school systems in seven states.
asserted
who → agree → states
He is currently the interim director of mission and ministry at Notre Dame High School in San Jose, Calif., and is among a group of Catholic school directors who has filed a brief siding with Colorado.
asserted
who → file → Colorado
"We do admit students that are not Catholic and families that are not Catholic," Uhl notes, adding that non-Catholic families "understand that even if they don't agree with certain doctrine, that doesn't mean they're going to be disruptive …
asserted
they → admit → doctrine
You know, diversity of opinion and diversity of thought is part of an educational experience.
asserted
diversity → know → experience
But the archdiocese of Denver has a different viewpoint.
asserted
archdiocese → have → viewpoint
In an article published in the Denver Post, Archbishop James R. Golka wrote that as a result of the Colorado pre-K program, enrollment in Catholic schools is down 20% across the archdiocese and two preschools have closed, including one which serves "minority and low income families."
asserted
which → publish → families
But the larger "tragedy," said the archbishop, is that "Colorado's attack on Catholic education threatens the broader culture.
asserted
attack → say → culture
In our age of hyper- secularization, moral relativism, and technical reductionism, we urgently need schools that teach students who they truly are: immortal souls, beloved by God."
asserted
they → need → God
Instead, he added, "The predictable result is a culture unmoored from truth, adrift in confusion."
asserted
result → add → confusion
Scott Elmer, superintendent of Catholic schools for the Archdiocese, says "it's very rare" for LGBTQ parents to try to enroll their children.
asserted
parents → say → children
"This is not something we deal with regularly," he adds.
asserted
he → deal → ?
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
