It’s a good time to be a coal plant in the US.
asserted
It → ’ → US
The Trump administration has given support to almost half of the nation’s coal plants, helping them to continue operating despite economic and regulatory headwinds, according to a new analysis by the Environmental Defense Fund.
uncertain
them → give → Fund
The analysis, which looked at the 184 operating coal plants that are connected to the grid, found that 90 received support from the Trump administration through “cash handouts, free passes to pollute, and requirements to stay online past their retirement dates”.
asserted
90 → look → dates
The administration provided $950m in taxpayer dollars to 24 coal plants and handed Clean Air Act exemptions from toxic pollution limits to 70 coal plants, according to the EDF analysis.
uncertain
administration → provide → analysis
“It’s extending the life of these coal plants,” said Surbhi Sarang, director and senior attorney at the Environmental Defense Fund.
asserted
Sarang → extend → Fund
“The administration has leveraged a multitude of tools to prop up coal plants, and ultimately all of that is harming Americans even more by increasing electricity costs, by increasing pollution – it’s like Americans are getting hit twice.”
asserted
Americans → leverage → pollution
In 2015, the EPA’s Mercury and Air Toxics Standards first took effect, driving down dangerous pollution from power plants by more than 90%.
asserted
Standards → take → %
In 2024, the EPA updated the standards to further reduce harmful pollution from coal-fired power plants.
asserted
EPA → update → plants
In the early days of the second Trump term, companies were invited to email the administration to request an exemption from the 2024 standards.
asserted
companies → invite → standards
According to emails obtained by the EDF through Freedom of Information Act requests, companies expressed concern that the standards would cost them too much money.
uncertain
standards → accord → money
The Colstrip plant in Montana has operated for more than 40 years, affecting nearby communities like the Northern Cheyenne reservation by releasing toxic chemicals like mercury, arsenic, lead and nickel.
asserted
plant → operate → mercury
“That’s one of the dirtiest coal plants that’s still operating in the nation,” Sarang said.
asserted
Sarang → ’ → nation
In 2024, the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards for coal-fired power plants was strengthened in several ways.
asserted
Standards → fire → ways
For example, the standard for fine particulate matter, or fPM, reduced allowable emissions of nickel, arsenic, lead and other toxic metals from coal plants by two-thirds.
asserted
standard → reduce → thirds
According to the EDF, NorthWestern Energy and Talen Energy, which own and operate the Colstrip plant, requested an exemption from the fPM requirement.
uncertain
which → accord → requirement
Brian Bird, president and CEO of NorthWestern, wrote an email to the Department of Energy in March 2025 asking for a 15-minute chat about the standards with administrator Lee Zeldin.
asserted
Bird → write → Zeldin
In the email, obtained by EDF, he argued that it would cost $500m to comply with the new rule: “It is ludicrous that our customers would have to cover the costs of a $500m investment for such a slight improvement to particulate matter capture,” he wrote.
asserted
he → obtain → capture
The Trump administration gave NorthWestern an exemption from complying with the 2024 updated standards, which the administration went on to repeal in February.
asserted
administration → give → February
Sarang said the Colstrip plant had not installed modern pollution controls that could reduce emissions.
uncertain
that → say → emissions
If it had been required to comply with the 2024 updated standards, it would have had to upgrade its equipment, she said: “It would have had pretty significant impacts on air pollution.”
asserted
It → require → pollution
NorthWestern, which became Colstrip’s majority owner earlier this year, describes the coal plant as a “dependable bridge to a cleaner energy future” that supplies reliable energy “until viable, equivalent, carbon-free energy resources are commercially available”.
asserted
resources → become → energy
Asked to comment on EDF’s report, NorthWestern said its technology at the Colstrip plant is “state of the art” for removing sulphur dioxide, and is 99.6% efficient in removing filterable particulate emissions.
asserted
technology → ask → emissions
The company said if the updated 2024 federal standards had taken effect, it would have required it to become 99.8% efficient by 2028, costing hundreds of millions of dollars.
asserted
it → say → dollars
The company said its mercury emission control at the Colstrip plant meets current state and federal requirements.
asserted
control → say → requirements
Another coal plant that received a pass from the Trump administration is the WA parish coal plant outside of Houston, Texas.
asserted
that → receive → Houston
Community members living nearby have called for it to be shut down due to its planet-heating CO2 emissions and what they say are ‘hazardous’ levels of particulate matter.
asserted
they → live → matter
The plant’s owner, NRG, asked the Department of Energy for an exemption for all of its coal-fired facilities including the WA parish plant, arguing that its facilities wouldn’t be able to comply with the new standards and would need to “derate in order to comply”, taking megawatts off the grid in “critical areas”, according to an email obtained by EDF.
uncertain
facilities → ask → EDF
NRG wrote that complying with the regulations “with razor thin margins” would risk the affordability and reliability of the grid.
asserted
complying → write → grid
A 2018 Rice University study found that the plant is responsible for as many as 177 premature deaths each year from PM 2.5, which are particles small enough to enter the bloodstream through the lungs, causing increased rates of respiratory diseases, heart attacks and strokes.
asserted
which → find → diseases
“Our research has shown that WA parish is the deadliest power plant in Texas,” explained Rice professor Daniel Cohan.
asserted
Cohan → show → Texas
NRG did not respond to a request to comment.
asserted
NRG → respond → request
Cohan said plants across the country were supposed to meet the 2024 updated standards.
asserted
plants → say → standards
“Trump is letting them off the hook from the more stringent version of the standard,” he said.
asserted
he → let → standard
“It lets them stay open longer,” Cohan explained.
asserted
Cohan → let → ?
“Many coal plants in this country are barely on the edge of breaking even, and so any regulations that force them to spend more money to clean up their pollution is likely to cause some of them to choose to retire and be replaced by cheaper and cleaner sources.”
asserted
some → break → sources
The administration defended its support for the coal industry in a statement.
asserted
administration → defend → statement
“The Democrats’ energy-subtraction policies shuttered American coal plants that provided reliable, affordable power to families and businesses when they needed it most.
asserted
they → shutter → it
President Trump promised to revive America’s coal industry, and the Trump Administration has backed and saved more than 100 coal plants this term.
asserted
Administration → promise → plants
By championing beautiful, clean coal, President Trump has prevented the retirement of more than 17 gigawatts of power and saved lives during heightened demand periods,” White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers wrote in a statement.
asserted
Rogers → champion → statement
The Aporia
