A campaign to uncover any documents relating to whether Australian spies bugged Timor-Leste to gain the upper hand in sensitive oil and gas negotiations will be a little less secret after a critical win by the former senator Rex Patrick.
asserted
spies → uncover → senator
The politician turned transparency advocate is trying to finally lift the lid on the top-secret mission in 2004 that became a public scandal years later after an ex-spy and a former attorney general attempted to mount a case in The Hague.
asserted
spy → turn → Hague
But the Australian government stands by its Glomar response – to neither confirm nor deny first that the bugging took place and second that any relevant documents exist.
asserted
documents → stand → place
On Friday, the administrative review tribunal (ART) ruled in Patrick’s favour, forcing the commonwealth to hold unclassified parts of the three-day hearing in late November in public.
asserted
tribunal → rule → public
Government lawyers argued the whole saga is so sensitive that even sections of the hearing open to the public should remain behind closed doors in case someone accidentally says something they shouldn’t.
asserted
they → argue → something
Patrick told Guardian Australia the situation was a farce, arguing the bugging scandal is the “most open secret in the history of Australian spying”, maybe even the world.
asserted
scandal → tell → spying
A ‘very high-stakes’ game
Patrick’s bid to gain further insight into the affair began with a request for cabinet documents from 2004 held by the National Archives of Australia.
The Australian government’s position, along with the responsible agency, the Australian Secret Intelligence Service (Asis), remains
asserted
position → gain → agency
any such documents cannot be publicly confirmed or denied
asserted
documents → confirm → ?
Asis contends that alone the records could undermine national security and Australia’s standings with other countries.
uncertain
records → contend → countries
The documents would relate to Australia’s strategy for settling how much of the Timor Sea it could maintain control over after Timor-Leste officially gained independence from Indonesia in 2002.
uncertain
Leste → relate → 2002
The negotiations determined the countries’ shared control over the Greater Sunrise gasfields, which hold resources estimated to be worth more than $50bn.
asserted
which → determine → resources
Patrick’s win on Friday means at least some of the government’s defence over why it cannot publicly reveal details of the 2004 bugging – which preceded to a commercially favourable agreement for Australia against the impoverished nation – will be heard in public.
asserted
which → mean → public
At a preliminary ART hearing last week to rule on whether part of the hearings should remain open, lawyers for the archives argued the matter is so sensitive that even sections of the hearing open to the public should remain behind closed doors in case someone accidentally says something they shouldn’t.
asserted
they → rule → something
Parts of the hearing will already remain closed so top-secret details can be debated, but the commonwealth had argued the open hearings should also be debated in secret.
asserted
hearings → remain → secret
The commonwealth unsuccessfully proposed the media and the public should be barred from the open hearings but would be able to view a transcript after careful review by the nation’s foreign intelligence agency.
asserted
media → propose → agency
The deputy chief solicitor, Justin Davidson, argued last Thursday the stakes are “very high” and it would be nearly impossible to mitigate the risk of an intelligence official revealing something they shouldn’t.
asserted
they → argue → something
“I’m not, frankly, beyond making a mistake,” Davidson said.
asserted
Davidson → ’m → mistake
Ewan McMillan, an Asis deputy director general, and Michelle Chan, a deputy secretary at the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Dfat), will offer their testimonies in late November when the case is heard in full.
asserted
case → offer → November
Davidson had argued the unclassified details they share in an open hearing might be “interesting to the public” but not necessarily in the public interest.
uncertain
they → argue → interest
On Friday, the ART deputy president Peter Britten-Jones ruled against the commonwealth, noting officials were “highly qualified and experienced” enough not to let national secrets slip in an open forum.
“The risk of an inadvertent disclosure of certificated material is negligible,” he wrote in his ruling.
asserted
he → rule → ruling
Patrick said the whole administrative saga felt like a replay of an Austin Powers movie.
asserted
saga → say → movie
“Only Asis and Dfat think the operation is still a secret,” Patrick said.
asserted
Patrick → think → ?
“It’d be funny if it wasn’t so serious, or if the taxpayer wasn’t paying for the silk, barristers and lawyers arguing the government’s case.
asserted
taxpayer → pay → case
A decades-long international affair
Patrick’s latest push to reveal historical documents, or at least the existence of them, comes after years of attempts.
asserted
push → reveal → attempts
In 2021, the former senator took the archives to the tribunal for heavily redacting a cabinet submission from 2000 outlining Australia’s negotiating strategy for bartering with its impoverished ally on the Timor Sea maritime boundary and a related minute.
asserted
senator → take → boundary
The negotiations, which predated the bugging scandal by four years, were critical for Timor-Leste and Australia, because they dictated access to the Greater Sunrise gasfields.
asserted
they → predate → gasfields
The tribunal later released the document with fewer redactions, which showed cabinet in 2000 was concerned that Timor-Leste’s independence process may disrupt access to the oil and gas reserves in the Timor Sea, because Australia’s prior agreement with Indonesia for a 50/50 revenue split would be void.
uncertain
agreement → release → split
The bugging operation occurred in 2004 when Asis operatives planted listening devices in key Timor-Leste government offices to uncover Timor-Leste’s bottom line, its negotiating tactics and the competing views of cabinet members.
asserted
operatives → occur → members
In 2006, Australia ended up securing a 50/50 split of the Greater Sunrise fields, positioned 450km north-west of Darwin and 150km south of Timor-Leste.
asserted
Australia → end → Leste
The deal was a boon for the joint venture of multinationals, led by Woodside, seeking to exploit the Timor Sea.
asserted
deal → lead → Sea
The bugging operation was later revealed after a former Asis officer, known as Witness K, approached the lawyer and former ACT attorney general Bernard Collaery, who was also acting for Timor-Leste, in 2013 about his knowledge of the operation.
asserted
who → reveal → operation
Together, the two attempted to help Timor-Leste’s dispute against the maritime boundary agreement in The Hague, the international permanent court of arbitration, before Collaery’s office was raided and Witness K’s passport seized.
asserted
passport → attempt → arbitration
Timor-Leste withdrew its Australian espionage claims in The Hague in 2017 as a “confidence-building measure”, and a new maritime border was signed in 2018.
uncertain
border → withdraw → 2018
In a 2019 affidavit for the proceedings against Collaery, which were dropped in 2022, the Timor-Leste president, Jose Ramos-Horta, said he believed the disclosure of further details of the operation would not create any new or additional problems for Australia.
asserted
disclosure → drop → Australia
“I believe the relationship between Timor-Leste and Australia would benefit from, rather than be prejudiced by, a full and open disclosure in this of what may or may not have occurred in 2004,” he said.
uncertain
he → believe → 2004
The Aporia
