More than two decades ago, Gurnam Dodd ran as a Progressive Conservative candidate in southeast Edmonton.
asserted
Dodd → run → Edmonton
He narrowly lost, but spent the ensuing years as a loyal conservative and devoted supporter of Danielle Smith, even before she became Alberta’s Premier.
asserted
she → lose → Smith
A few weeks ago, he decided he had enough.
asserted
he → decide → enough
He sent a letter to Patrick Malkin, vice-president of membership for the United Conservative Party of Alberta.
asserted
He → send → Alberta
“I ask that my membership be cancelled, that no renewal be processed, and that written confirmation be provided,” he wrote.
asserted
he → ask → ?
Over nearly a thousand words, he sketched out his reasons.
asserted
he → sketch → reasons
The political decisions that enabled last week’s provincial referendum, in which Albertans overwhelmingly voted to remain in Canada, risked “normalizing separation as an ordinary instrument of provincial bargaining,” he wrote.
asserted
he → enable → bargaining
And, he added, a series of immigration-related questions brought to the referendum vote by Ms. Smith’s government were “deeply concerning.”
asserted
series → add → government
Decisions about who is eligible for provincial services or preferential employment should be made carefully, he said, not reduced to “slogans that divide established Albertans from newcomers.”
asserted
that → make → newcomers
Those slogans prevailed.
asserted
slogans → prevail → ?
Albertans voted for the province to assert more control over immigration and restrict access to public services to some new arrivals.
asserted
province → vote → arrivals
One measure said Albertans should be given “first priority on new employment opportunities.”
asserted
Albertans → say → opportunities
In the aftermath of the bruising referendum, separatists seeking to entrench themselves as a political force have pledged to remove her from leadership of the United Conservative Party.
asserted
separatists → seek → Party
Ms. Smith has sought to bolster her internal support, and her party said this week it did not expect any success from attempts to unseat her.
asserted
it → seek → her
Some former backers are nonetheless abandoning the Premier.
“People are upset,” said Gursharan Buttar, whose family owns My Radio 580, an Edmonton AM station that broadcasts largely in Punjabi.
asserted
that → abandon → Punjabi
He hosts three hours of weekday morning radio, a mix of political discussion and call-in talk shows.
asserted
He → host → discussion
Ms. Smith’s actions, he said, are “putting insecurity into the minority communities.”
asserted
he → say → communities
Over the past few weeks, a half-dozen people have called in to describe taking steps similar to Mr. Dodd’s.
asserted
people → call → Dodd
“Immigrants are submitting their resignation,” Mr. Buttar said.
asserted
Buttar → submit → resignation
Any future UCP candidate that reaches out to minority groups in the province, he said, “will face harsh questioning when the next election comes.”
asserted
election → reach → questioning
His listeners, he said, want to know why members of Ms. Smith’s party did not publicly decry anti-immigrant sentiment that arose around the referendum.
asserted
that → say → referendum
“When immigrants were on the receiving end, why did they not speak?” he asked.
asserted
he → speak → end
Nearly a quarter of Albertans said they wanted to pursue separation through a binding referendum, including some who said last week their vote was driven in part by immigration concern.
“We’ve had 600,000 people come into Alberta in the last year, and a lot of them shouldn’t be here,” said George Hartford, a retiree in the southern Alberta village of Carmangay.
asserted
Hartford → say → Carmangay
According to Statistics Canada, 76,500 people arrived in Alberta in the past year.
uncertain
people → accord → year
He moved to Alberta from B.C. four years ago to be in a province governed by the UCP and Ms. Smith.
asserted
He → move → UCP
In the wake of the referendum, Ms. Smith said she will “proceed with caution” on the referendum questions.
asserted
she → say → questions
But Alberta has been one of the fastest growing parts of the country and those now seeking to take command of the UCP have said changing immigration is a primary objective.
asserted
changing → grow → immigration
“Alberta is working on taking control of our sovereignty so we can, among other things, stop the insane immigration that’s threatening western civilization,” podcaster Chris Scott, who has said he intends to compete for the UCP board, wrote last year on X.
Mr. Scott later said his concern lies with mass migration, not legal immigration.
asserted
concern → work → migration
The prospect of Alberta turning against immigration has, however, already raised the alarm for business groups.
asserted
Alberta → turn → groups
A recent survey by the Calgary Chamber of Commerce found that more than two-thirds of large businesses said immigrant employees are important to their business.
asserted
employees → find → business
The need to bring in foreign workers will only grow if the province succeeds in expanding its industrial base as Prime Minister Mark Carney seeks to speed construction of major new projects, said Deborah Yedlin, president of the Calgary Chamber.
asserted
Yedlin → bring → Chamber
“We need to be competitive for global and Canadian talent.
asserted
We → need → talent
That is just absolutely critical if we’re going to meet the labour needs of the projects that we want to build,” she said.
asserted
she → go → that
The province has already forecast shortfalls over the next decade of more than 100,000 workers across different sectors.
asserted
province → forecast → sectors
In the referendum, Albertans said they want the province to create a separate class of services for non-permanent immigrants and their families, charging for access to health care and education.
asserted
province → say → care
Referendum voters also supported a measure to bar those without citizenship, permanent residency or “Alberta-approved immigration status” from provincially funded programs.
asserted
voters → support → programs
Such change, if enacted by Ms. Smith’s government, could create additional financial burdens for employers that cover those expenses for employees.
“If there is a world where it’s more expensive to bring labour here because businesses have to bear the extra cost to enable access to health care and education – then, all of a sudden, how competitive are we as a jurisdiction for investment?” Ms. Yedlin said.
uncertain
Yedlin → enact → investment
Others are preparing to fight Ms. Smith if she pursues the issues passed in the referendum.
asserted
she → prepare → referendum
Avnish Nanda, an Edmonton lawyer, created Our Alberta Advantage as a pro-federalist third-party advertiser prior to the referendum.
asserted
Nanda → create → referendum
He is now pivoting that group to advocate on other issues, including immigration.
asserted
He → pivot → immigration
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
