Websites masquerading as independent, local news sources are promoting Democratic candidates to unsuspecting ChatGPT users, according to a report.
uncertain
Websites → masquerade → report
The revelations stoke concern about voter manipulation just days ahead of the crucial midterm elections.
asserted
revelations → stoke → elections
Digital security firm VisionHeight uncovered 37 phony websites, a number of them “thinly veiled political ads made to look like reporting from local news outlets,” according to NPR.
uncertain
number → uncover → NPR
They were cited in ChatGPT answers to questions about congressional candidates and their positions on issues like affordability and public safety — potentially misinforming voters in favor of Dems.
asserted
They → cite → Dems
In one example, the network of sites tilted ChatGPT answers in favor of Sean McCann, the Democratic candidate in Michigan’s tight race for the 4th congressional district, NPR reported Friday.
asserted
NPR → tilt → district
Asked which candidates in that race “care about affordability,” ChatGPT gave an answer favoring McCann, citing the “Kalamazoo Beacon.”
asserted
ChatGPT → ask → Beacon
But the “Beacon” appears to be a phony site devoted to boosting McCann — every one of the 16 stories it’s published to date were about him, NPR reported.
asserted
NPR → appear → him
“The McCann campaign has no knowledge of or involvement with these websites,” a spokesperson for the candidate told The Post.
asserted
spokesperson → have → Post
The “Beacon” is one of 10 purported local news outlets in the 37-site network, each promoting a different Democrat in a competitive congressional race, according to NPR and VisionHeight.
uncertain
each → purport → NPR
In Pennsylvania’s 8th congressional district, the “Scranton Beacon” published a news-style candidate profile of Dem Paige Cognetti, while “Electric City Watch” urged readers to support the same candidate, according to VisionHeight.
uncertain
Watch → publish → VisionHeight
In all, the network of 37 phony sites consists of 10 local news outlets, 10 local opinion blogs, 12 statewide websites and five national political outlets — all of them aimed at promoting mostly Democratic candidates, according to VisionHeight.
uncertain
all → consist → VisionHeight
They focus on 10 candidates from coast to coast by providing info that bots like ChatGPT are likely to pick up and share with users, NPR found.
asserted
NPR → focus → users
About half the time it was asked about one of the 10, ChatGPT cited the network of phony sites, according to the broadcaster.
uncertain
ChatGPT → ask → broadcaster
It’s not clear who is running the ring.
asserted
who → ’ → ring
But “multiple indicators suggest that all 37 websites share a common operator,” NPR reported.
asserted
NPR → suggest → operator
Each of their domains were registered on Sept. 15 — 36 of them within an eight-minute span — according to registration and digital-certificate data gathered by VisionHeight and Andreas Sjöstedt, co-founder of cybersecurity firm Erebus.
uncertain
Each → register → Erebus
The pattern “points to sites most likely written by AI, written for AI, and meant to be passed on by AI to voters.
asserted
pattern → point → voters
That is what makes the approach so cheap and so fast: machines do the writing, and machines do the reading,” according to VisionHeight.
uncertain
machines → make → VisionHeight
The network published hundreds of articles in September and October, with new material appearing in waves, according to NPR.
uncertain
material → publish → NPR
On Sept. 30 alone, about 100,000 words of candidate-related content were posted using a single template presented in four different layouts, VisionHeight found.
asserted
VisionHeight → relate → layouts
The cybersecurity firm said the volume and uniformity suggest artificial intelligence may have been used to generate the content, although that has not been established for sure.
uncertain
that → say → content
All 37 websites enable 17 AI and search crawlers — including those operated by OpenAI, Google and Anthropic — to access their content.
asserted
crawlers → enable → content
VisionHeight found that favored candidates received profiles running roughly 5,000 words, along with similarly lengthy voter guides containing 50 to 63 questions and answers.
asserted
candidates → find → questions
The cybersecurity firm counted more than 360 instances of the phrase “is the stronger choice” across the network –wording apparently aimed at manipulating AI bots.
asserted
firm → count → bots
The phrase popped up 34 times about a single Democratic congressional candidate covered by “Wolverine State Report,” a site posing as a Michigan political news outlet.
asserted
phrase → pop → outlet
Google’s Gemini chatbot did not cite any of the network’s websites in NPR’s testing.
asserted
chatbot → cite → testing
Google search did not display the sites on the first page of its ordinary results during the tests, either.
asserted
search → display → tests
An exception came earlier this month, according to VisionHeight, but Google spokesman Davis Thompson told NPR the company detected a policy violation and took “swift action.”
uncertain
company → come → action
“ChatGPT’s search tools cite from a range of sources so people can explore and make their own judgements,” an OpenAI spokesperson told The Post.
asserted
spokesperson → cite → Post
“Around elections, our integration with Democracy Works brings up-to-date information about registration, deadlines, voting locations and other election requirements directly into ChatGPT.”
asserted
integration → bring → ChatGPT
“When issues are brought to our attention, we take action to improve our model responses.”
asserted
we → bring → responses
The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee denied involvement, according to NPR.
uncertain
Committee → deny → NPR
The Post has sought comment from the DCCC and from Cognetti.
asserted
Post → seek → Cognetti
The Aporia
