The 21st Canada-European Union Summit kicked off in Montreal this week, and so far, it looks like Prime Minister Mark Carney and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen forgot to compare notes.
asserted
Carney → kick → notes
What is that supposed to mean?
asserted
that → suppose → What
Von der Leyen stated the obvious about Canada not being able to become a full member, due to our geography, but said, “We are discussing the idea of Canada becoming the first associate member of the European Union,” adding that it would be “association without accession.
asserted
it → state → accession
She made it sound simple, suggesting the arrangement would be mutually beneficial, without downsides.
asserted
arrangement → make → downsides
Canada would simply work with the EU on policies relating to “everything,” including student-mobility programs, energy, security, artificial intelligence, climate and “more work shared” between the two, which could include co-operation between parliaments, courts and “closer alignment in each other’s programs.”
uncertain
which → work → programs
Which programs they are considering aligning on were left unclear, like the definition of our membership.
uncertain
considering → consider → membership
Von der Leyen’s explanation did not clarify how European or Canadian citizens may be affected by this new kind of membership.
uncertain
citizens → clarify → membership
If the EU members overwhelmingly vote for something, will Canada be required to go along?
asserted
Canada → vote → something
How will it be defined?
asserted
it → define → ?
And the last time I checked, Canadians hadn’t voted on any of this.
asserted
Canadians → check → this
Who says Canadians want to be in line with EU policies?
asserted
Canadians → say → policies
At a press conference Thursday, Carney told reporters, in his characteristically dismissive way, “This new alliance is not a marketing exercise.
asserted
alliance → tell → way
The name doesn’t matter.
asserted
name → matter → ?
What matters is that the complementarities of our two jurisdictions strengthen our sovereignty.”
asserted
complementarities → matter → sovereignty
Of course, we know that’s not true.
asserted
that → know → ?
Members of the EU are bound to certain requirements and responsibilities because they are “members.”
asserted
they → bind → requirements
You can guarantee that “associate member,” or whatever Canada ends up being labelled, will have its own detailed requirements, which will likely never be run by Canadians for approval.
asserted
which → guarantee → approval
We continue to be Carney’s mushrooms, left in the dark, whether it be about the specifics of why he walked away from a U.S. trade deal at the last minute or what the specifics of Canada being wrapped up in an EU membership will actually entail.
asserted
specifics → continue → membership
Deepening integration appears to have been Carney’s plan from the get-go.
asserted
Deepening → deepen → go
In October 2025, Carney created a new position, “personal representative of the prime minister to the EU,” appointing former privy council clerk John Hannaford to “prioritize increased trade and investment levels with EU partners, and new and deeper security arrangements that reinforce our already strong ties — ensuring that commitments by Canada and our partners are quickly delivered upon and implemented.”
asserted
commitments → create → Canada
One has to wonder whether Ottawa put half as much effort into negotiations with the United States.
asserted
Ottawa → have → States
Earlier this week, one premier started to object to how the summit would be conducted.
asserted
summit → start → ?
On Wednesday, Quebec Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon officially withdrew from the summit after his request to address it was declined by the federal government, which he referred to as a “serious lack of respect.”
asserted
he → withdraw → respect
Before doing so, he posted a letter he’d wrote to the members of the summit on X, writing, “The reality is that we are facing a strategy of marginalizing Quebec on the international stage and subordinating Quebec’s areas of jurisdiction to the will of the federal government.”
asserted
we → do → government
Plamondon pointed out that topics discussed at the summit — including education, health care and natural resources — all fall under provincial jurisdiction.
asserted
topics → point → jurisdiction
He said that any deal Ottawa makes without Quebec’s consent “will simply not be implemented,” and accused the federal government of withholding “critical information” about the negotiations from the province.
“
asserted
Ottawa → say → province
The federal government has chosen to prevent Quebec from having a say on its own territory.
asserted
government → choose → territory
This is a fundamental lack of respect toward Quebec and a denial of the role of our legislature,” she said.
asserted
she → say → legislature
On Thursday, over-seasoned Globe and Mail journalist Andrew Coyne took to X to mock Plamondon for standing alone for his province.
asserted
Coyne → season → province
Standing alone in Canada’s consensus culture should be applauded, not mocked.
asserted
Standing → stand → culture
All provinces and territories should feel the same way.
asserted
provinces → feel → ?
It’s one thing for the PM to make deals on behalf of Canada with other nations.
asserted
PM → ’ → nations
It’s another thing entirely for him to bind our country closer to these nations, including whatever that might entail, without voters’ consent.
uncertain
that → ’ → consent
The Aporia
