Lawyers for two former FBI officials asked a federal judge on Thursday to throw out a criminal complaint accusing them of lying to Congress about Hunter Biden.
asserted
Lawyers → ask → Biden
The defense argued the prosecution is openly political, brought to satisfy President Donald Trump.
asserted
prosecution → argue → Trump
The case against Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides is one of a series of high-profile Justice Department actions filed ahead of next week's midterm voting.
asserted
case → file → voting
Their legal team spent days at a hearing trying to portray the case as both legally flawed and politically contaminated.
asserted
team → spend → case
Testimony at the hearing included an account that FBI Director Kash Patel ordered the investigation.
asserted
Patel → include → investigation
The hearing also heard that the case was opened shortly after a primetime election security speech by Trump, in which the Republican revisited long-standing grievances about his 2020 election loss to Democrat Joe Biden.
asserted
Republican → hear → Biden
“A political prosecution is always going to make for a shaky foundation for a criminal case,” said Mary Dohrmann, a lawyer for Floris.
asserted
Dohrmann → go → Floris
Floris and Benavides are accused of downplaying what they knew about a laptop.
asserted
they → accuse → laptop
The Justice Department says Hunter Biden dropped the laptop off at a computer repair shop in 2019.
asserted
Biden → say → 2019
It was publicized a year later, in a revelation that shook the final weeks of the presidential race.
asserted
that → publicize → race
The FBI director was said to be keenly interested in the investigation
The hearing this week featured testimony from Bryan Witt, an FBI special agent who investigated the case.
asserted
who → say → case
He said he regarded it as a “huge distraction” from his other work and appreciated that the investigation could be seen as political.
uncertain
investigation → say → work
Witt said Patel had mandated the investigation and taken an unusual interest in it, requesting and receiving regular updates.
He also testified that the FBI had been directed to investigate Floris after a July primetime speech in which Trump amplified debunked theories about his 2020 election loss.
asserted
Trump → say → loss
Among the grievances the White House raised at the time was a disputed FBI intelligence report about an alleged effort by China to influence the election on Biden's behalf.
asserted
report → raise → behalf
The FBI recalled the memo after concluding the information was not sufficiently corroborated.
asserted
information → recall → memo
Floris has long been singled out by Trump's Republican allies for her role in that recall decision.
asserted
Floris → single → decision
A key decision looms next week
U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui did not immediately rule on the defense lawyers' request.
asserted
Faruqui → loom → request
A dismissal of the complaint would not prevent the Justice Department from seeking an indictment.
asserted
dismissal → prevent → indictment
But that could be a challenge, given that grand juries in the nation's capital have repeatedly refused to approve charges in politically sensitive cases.
uncertain
juries → give → cases
Even if the judge sustains the complaint, prosecutors would presumably still need to secure a grand jury indictment for the case to proceed.
asserted
case → sustain → indictment
The alleged false statements were made in 2023 before the House Judiciary Committee.
asserted
statements → allege → Committee
The Republican-led panel was conducting its own investigation into Hunter Biden at the time.
asserted
panel → lead → time
According to the complaint, both officials downplayed their knowledge of the laptop while taking part in numerous discussions about it.
uncertain
officials → accord → it
A Justice Department prosecutor, James Kirkpatrick, argued Thursday that the two officials had a motive to minimize what they knew about Hunter Biden and the laptop, because his father was president when they were questioned.
asserted
they → argue → Biden
Kirkpatrick noted that both led a since-disbanded FBI task force set up to monitor foreign influence in elections.
asserted
both → note → elections
He suggested the two may have been leery of discussing Hunter Biden and the laptop since, he said, the task force did not publicly correct a narrative from some Democrats and former intelligence officials that the laptop might have been connected to Russian disinformation.
uncertain
laptop → suggest → disinformation
Trump's then-intelligence director, John Ratcliffe, said after the laptop was publicized that there were no signs of foreign involvement in any way.
asserted
laptop → say → way
“At the end of the day, the FITF got it wrong,” Kirkpatrick said, referring to the Foreign Intelligence Task Force.
asserted
Kirkpatrick → get → Force
“They didn’t quash the narrative that this laptop was the product of Russian disinformation.
asserted
laptop → quash → disinformation
They didn't correct the record.”
asserted
They → correct → record
The Aporia
