FBI agents charged with lying about Hunter Biden probes accuse DOJ of 'serious abuse'
asserted
agents → charge → abuse
Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides have been charged with lying to Congress.
asserted
Floris → charge → Congress
A magistrate judge blasted Justice Department attorneys during a hearing Tuesday after the department, in an overnight court filing, added a charge of obstruction to two charges of lying to Congress that were brought Friday against two former FBI agents who investigated Hunter Biden.
asserted
who → blast → Biden
The Justice Department on Friday charged Nikki Floris, the former deputy assistant director for FBI's Counterintelligence Division, and Bradley Benavides, another former senior counterintelligence official, with allegedly making false statements to Congress stemming from a probe into whether investigators in the lead-up to the 2020 election sought to suppress or discredit the veracity of material on the laptop of former President Joe Biden's son that included embarrassing photos and videos.
uncertain
that → charge → photos
The DOJ early Tuesday added an obstruction of a congressional proceeding charge -- but in a contentious hearing, magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui slammed the Justice Department for the overnight filing, which prosecutors posted to the case docket without receiving signoff from the judge.
asserted
prosecutors → add → judge
The FBI agent who swore out the complaint also did not include his signature.
"I think they should have filed nothing," Judge Faruqui said.
asserted
Faruqui → swear → nothing
"They never had complaints filed on their record that are unsigned, waiting for a judge to make a probable cause finding.
asserted
judge → have → finding
I think that it is inappropriate and harms the defendant.
asserted
it → think → defendant
I'm frustrated that I got it in the middle of the night, but I'm much more concerned that it's filed on the public record."
The assistant U.S. attorney in the hearing, John Borchert, struggled repeatedly as Faruqui asked him to explain the government's conduct, which the judge said was unlike any case he had ever seen in the history of D.C.'s district court.
Faruqui ultimately granted the request from Flores' and Benavides' attorneys to strike the amended complaint from the docket and said he would continue Tuesday's hearing to determine whether prosecutors established probable cause in their initial complaint filed last week.
"Why today on this one case have you changed the entire history of how you charge cases?" Faruqui asked of Borchert.
asserted
Faruqui → get → Borchert
It appears that -- it makes it look like the United States is afraid of me trying to find probable cause."
asserted
me → appear → cause
"Let me address that squarely.
asserted
me → let → that
We are not afraid of a probable cause finding," Borchert said.
asserted
Borchert → say → finding
The Justice Department alleges that Floris and Benavides knowingly lied to Congress on two separate occasions -- on July 19, 2023, for Floris, and on Sept. 28, 2023, for Benavides.
asserted
Floris → allege → Benavides
"The evidence further establishes that probable cause exists to believe that Floris and Benavides made these statements for the purpose of minimizing or concealing [the FBI Foreign Influence Task Force's] engagement with, and communications about, the Hunter Biden investigations and to impede the Congressional investigation," according to the documents filed overnight.
uncertain
Floris → establish → documents
The affidavit alleges that both congressional and FBI witnesses, along with FBI documents, prove that the pair were aware of the Hunter Biden investigation.
asserted
pair → allege → investigation
"The government's last-ditch filing before the pre-scheduled preliminary hearing in this case is not merely procedurally improper and substantively deficient," Floris' attorneys said.
asserted
attorneys → say → case
"It represents a serious abuse of the criminal charging process, a troubling disregard for the judicial safeguards governing the initiation of criminal proceedings, and a calculated effort to evade judicial scrutiny and shield the government's allegations from adversarial testing at the scheduled preliminary hearing."
"In our combined decades of DOJ service, we have never seen or even heard of something like this being filed.
asserted
something → represent → this
That's because the public lodging of criminal charges must be authorized by the grand jury, a judge, or the defendant herself," the attorneys said.
asserted
attorneys → authorize → jury
"We have asked to address this outrageous government conduct against a decorated public servant at today's court hearing."
asserted
We → ask → hearing
Judge Faruqui appeared on Friday to be skeptical of the charges -- saying the "facts appear to be old" and there are "questions that need to be answered" -- before setting a hearing for Tuesday to consider whether the government established probable cause in its complaint.
asserted
government → appear → complaint
Faruqui said the judge who signed off on the complaint needed extra time to determine if there was probable cause or not.
asserted
who → say → time
"Rare charges" that are "this old" are never charged by complaint, according to the judge.
uncertain
that → charge → judge
It was not immediately clear why prosecutors chose to charge the pair through a criminal complaint and not an indictment, which would have required approval by a grand jury instead of a magistrate judge.
asserted
which → choose → jury
The Aporia
