People in a west London borough fear it will become covered in dog poo after their cash-strapped council decided to remove 700 dog-waste bins to save money.
asserted
council → fear → money
“People are worried there’s going to be dog shit everywhere,” said Daniel O’Neill, the chief road steward at Ruislip Residents’ Association.
asserted
O’Neill → worry → Association
Hillingdon’s pet dogs produce about 174 tonnes of faeces each year, which, until now, has been generally bagged up by their owners and deposited in dog-waste bins.
asserted
which → produce → bins
The Conservative-run council believes it will save £100,000 in waste collection costs by removing the bins.
asserted
it → run → bins
It hopes dog owners will use general litter bins instead, but O’Neill and many other people are unconvinced.
asserted
O’Neill → hop → bins
“Everybody’s going to have a Christmas tree of dog-shit baubles in their front garden because there’ll be nowhere else to put the bags of it,” O’Neill said.
asserted
O’Neill → go → it
“I got one of those AI generators to make me a Christmas tree with dog-shit bags in different colours, to show what’s going to happen.”
asserted
what → get → colours
Sital Punja who walks Marley, her springer-poodle, every day in Ruislip woods, said the “preposterousness” of the bin removals have dominated chat between dog walkers.
asserted
preposterousness → walk → walkers
“People are really unhappy about it, it’s going to be dumped everywhere,” said Punja, who is an opposition Labour councillor.
asserted
who → go → it
“The dog bins in the woods are already overflowing and there aren’t enough general bins.
asserted
bins → overflow → woods
The dog bins have lids so the smell stays inside.
asserted
smell → have → lids
General bins don’t, so they stink and can be got at by foxes.”
Hillingdon is not the first council to remove dog-waste bins to try to save money.
asserted
Hillingdon → do → money
Similar plans have prompted outrage in Cornwall, Kent, North Somerset and elsewhere.
asserted
plans → prompt → Cornwall
Hillingdon borough’s large debts are increasing by £5.6m a year.
asserted
debts → increase → m
Its schools grant deficit alone is £101.5m and the government has “serious concerns” about the borough’s finances, which could jeopardise its chances of continuing to rely on exceptional financial support grants from Whitehall.
uncertain
which → have → Whitehall
At the same time, Hillingdon prides itself on having frozen council tax for years.
asserted
Hillingdon → pride → years
This was the root of the problem, according to O’Neill, who said he had observed the last 150 council meetings.
uncertain
he → accord → meetings
“If they put the council taxes up, even to just the average in London, then they would bring in £26m,” he said, “but what they’re actually doing instead is not emptying the dog-shit bins to save £100,000.”
O’Neill said it was this issue that had really cut through with residents.
asserted
that → put → residents
“I tell people about the deficit, or about the audit problems, and nobody cares.
asserted
nobody → tell → problems
When I tell them that their bins are going to get taken away, they go nuts.”
asserted
they → tell → them
Comments on Ruislip’s residents’ association Facebook page appear to bear this out.
asserted
Comments → appear → this
“What an absurd suggestion,” said one person.
asserted
person → say → ?
Another said it was “madness” and added: “Are they trying to completely alienate the residents?
asserted
they → say → residents
There are enough selfish dog owners who already don’t pick up after their dogs so they think removing the bins will improve that?”
asserted
removing → be → that
One resident said: “Sadly this is probably a decision by someone who does not have a clue how much shit is created by dogs.
asserted
shit → say → dogs
Punja said Hillingdon had a lot of dog owners.
asserted
Hillingdon → say → owners
She added: “This is just one of the council’s harebrained ideas they have come up with when they can’t balance the books …
asserted
they → add → books
It probably would be simpler to put up council tax.
asserted
It → put → tax
I can only describe it as dog-shit, excuse my language – but to have to scramble to such a level where you have to take away dog bins; it’s desperate.”
asserted
it → describe → bins
A council report setting out the plan said it would save £160,000, of which £60,000 would be reinvested in street cleaning.
asserted
60,000 → set → cleaning
Wayne Bridges, the council’s cabinet member for residents’ services, said: “We do understand that some residents have concerns about these changes.
asserted
residents → say → changes
We are simply changing how it is collected, making better use of the nearly 1,500 ordinary litter bins already available across Hillingdon.
asserted
it → change → Hillingdon
“By allowing dog waste to be placed in ordinary public litter bins, which can already be used safely for this purpose, more than doubling existing capacity, we can bring collections into our existing street cleansing arrangements and remove the cost of running two separate services.
“Many councils across the country already allow dog waste to be disposed of through general waste arrangements.”
asserted
waste → allow → arrangements
The Aporia
