Andy Burnham was accused of 'Brexit hypocrisy' last night as Labour's position on free movement descended into chaos.
asserted
position → accuse → chaos
The Daily Mail can reveal that Mr Burnham warned previously that the free movement of people across borders should never be revived after it was 'defeated at the ballot box' in 2016.
asserted
it → reveal → 2016
But yesterday, the Prime Minister doubled down on the idea of returning to open borders with the EU as part of his bid to unpick Brexit.
asserted
Minister → double → Brexit
He suggested a referendum would be needed to revive free movement, saying he would 'never move ahead of the British public when it comes to Brexit'.
uncertain
it → suggest → Brexit
On a shambolic day at Westminster, Downing Street later said the public might not be given a vote on the issue after all – and even claimed that the PM 'isn't proposing a return to free movement'.
uncertain
PM → say → movement
The intervention marks the second time this month that No10 has been forced to 'clarify' the PM's remarks on Brexit after he suggested the 2016 referendum result was influenced by the Kremlin.
uncertain
result → mark → Kremlin
During TV interviews yesterday, Mr Burnham said he wanted to start an 'honest conversation' about the merits of reviving freedom of movement as part of a new deal with the EU.
asserted
he → say → EU
'I don't think things have worked out as they said they would at the time, particularly when it comes to immigration,' he said.
asserted
he → think → immigration
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has been accused of 'Brexit hypocrisy' after doubling down on the idea of returning to open borders with the EU as part of his bid to unpick Brexit
Mr Burnham previously suggested the 2016 referendum result was influenced by the Kremlin (Pictured: Pro Brexit supporters celebrate after the UK left the EU)
He is planning to set out a series of options for a new relationship with Brussels at a UK-EU summit next month.
uncertain
He → accuse → summit
They are expected to include membership of the single market and customs union, as well as fully rejoining the EU.
asserted
They → expect → EU
But in previous remarks unearthed by the Mail, he said respecting the referendum result meant never returning to the EU.
asserted
respecting → unearth → EU
Speaking in December 2016, he said it was 'time to move beyond the re-running of the referendum arguments and accept what people voted for... change on immigration.
asserted
people → speak → immigration
The status quo – full free movement – was defeated at the ballot box, so it is not an option.
asserted
it → defeat → box
Mr Burnham said it was clear that free movement was being used to 'undermine skilled wages' and was 'not working for the more deprived parts of our country'.
'There is nothing socialist about a system of open borders that allows multinationals to treat people as commodities and to move them around Europe to drive down labour costs and create a race to the bottom,' he said.
asserted
he → say → bottom
Nigel Farage said the PM now seemed determined to betray the referendum, despite strong backing for Leave in his own Makerfield constituency.
asserted
PM → say → constituency
'This is the kind of hypocrisy and insincerity I have become accustomed to from Andy Burnham,' the Reform UK leader said.
asserted
leader → become → Burnham
'Quite clearly, he knows the reason why people voted Leave, yet he's still determined to betray that vote.
asserted
he → know → vote
'If Open Borders Burnham wants an election on open borders and Brexit, I say bring it on.'
asserted
I → want → it
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has said Mr Burnham now seemed determined to betray the Brexit referendum
Free movement of people is a cornerstone of the EU's single market, and diplomatic sources insist there is no prospect of the PM achieving his dream of rejoining the EU without accepting it.
He floated the idea of reviving free movement at the weekend, saying the pre-Brexit wave of immigration was not 'as difficult' as the one that followed.
asserted
that → say → one
He repeated the idea yesterday, saying: 'We're seeing a situation where people are coming here to settle permanently in a way that we had more revolving-door migration in the EU.'
At the weekend, Angela Rayner suggested a new deal with the EU could be wrapped up in Labour's next manifesto, sidestepping a second referendum.
uncertain
deal → repeat → referendum
Mr Burnham played down the prospect of an early election yesterday, saying he did not plan to go to the country 'any time soon'.
Asked if free movement could be revived without a referendum, Mr Burnham said: 'No.'
But hours later No10 said the Government was 'not at the stage where we have concrete proposals'.
uncertain
we → play → proposals
Mr Burnham also recently floated the idea of reviving free movement, saying the pre-Brexit wave of immigration was not 'as difficult' as the one that followed
A spokesman for the PM said, 'The Prime Minister isn't proposing a return to freedom of movement or any option,' even though he rolled the pitch for it in an interview with the Sunday Times.
asserted
he → float → Times
'He is saying that it's time for us to discuss what kind of long-term relationship with Europe is best for Britain and he is referring to the types of areas that that agreement and long-term future could cover.'
uncertain
agreement → say → that
The spokesman even suggested Mr Burnham's stated wish to rejoin the EU during his lifetime was a 'personal view' rather than government policy.
uncertain
wish → suggest → lifetime
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said: 'It beggars belief that a man who once said free movement was defeated at the ballot box now wants to bring it back.'
Former foreign secretary Dame Priti Patel said the PM should 'stop treating the public like fools and focus on securing Britain's future outside the EU rather than making us an EU rule-taker again'.
Remainers welcomed the PM's change of heart on free movement and Brexit.
asserted
Remainers → say → movement
London mayor Sir Sadiq Khan said it was time to rejoin a 'reformed' EU.
asserted
it → say → EU
He said the PM was 'right and brave to be having this conversation'.
asserted
PM → say → conversation
Stella Creasy, chairman of the Labour Movement for Europe, said: 'The Prime Minister is right – the UK is long overdue for a grown-up conversation about what EU freedom of movement actually means to our supply chains and for jobs.
asserted
freedom → say → jobs
'
But Mr Farage said the PM had 'no mandate whatsoever to agree anything in that summit'.
asserted
PM → say → summit
He added: 'It will not only be a betrayal of the greatest democratic exercise in the history of this country, but also a betrayal of what he promised the focus of Labour would be just a few short months ago.'
asserted
focus → add → Labour
The Aporia
