Trump's increasing support for Russia carries existential danger for Canada
Carney welcomes EU as experts warn of burgeoning Russian-American alliance
In the six weeks between Prime Minister Mark Carney's trip to the European Parliament and top EU officials arriving for a joint summit in Montreal, the United States has moved considerably closer to Russia.
asserted
States → increase → Russia
Just days after Carney returned to Canada, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio invited Russia's Vladimir Putin to December's G20 summit in Miami.
asserted
Rubio → return → Miami
Then on Oct. 9, the U.S. lifted sanctions on Russian oil and announced a deal to buy diesel directly from Russia.
asserted
U.S. → lift → Russia
Some analysts say Trump's rapprochement with Russia poses a clear danger to Canadians — one not easily solved by closer partnerships with allies an ocean away.
asserted
rapprochement → say → allies
"This is not Trump playing footsie with Putin," said Vincent Rigby, national security and intelligence adviser to the prime minister until 2021.
asserted
Rigby → play → 2021
"This is something far, far more serious, and strategically, this can't help but be a concern."
asserted
this → help → ?
Last week on the White House South Lawn, Trump drew his own parallels between Canada and Ukraine, bragging after a call with Carney: "Just like I told Zelenskyy, we have all the cards."
While Trump has increased his swipes at Canada on the campaign trail, his hostility to Ukraine goes beyond words.
asserted
hostility → draw → words
In Trump's one-sided "energy ceasefire," Ukraine was expected to stop hitting Russian refineries but Russia continued to hit Ukrainian electrical plants.
asserted
Russia → expect → plants
Then came the slowdown in Starlink/Starshield, followed by a round of blame-shifting between the White House and Elon Musk as to who ordered it.
asserted
who → come → it
The U.S. also appeared to cut off warnings of incoming ballistic missiles, and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Trump is making it harder to access Patriot missiles.
asserted
it → appear → missiles
"It's been unbelievable," said Rob Huebert, director of the Centre for Military, Security and Strategic Studies at the University of Calgary.
asserted
Huebert → say → Calgary
"These actions can only be characterized as Trump trying to cause Ukraine to lose the war.
asserted
Ukraine → characterize → war
"
Washington also reportedly leaned on European countries to release billions of Euros in frozen Russian assets, and Trump signed an executive order waiving sanctions against Russia due to take effect two days later.
uncertain
Trump → lean → effect
Maria Popova, an expert on Russia at McGill University and author of Russia and Ukraine: Entangled Histories, Diverging States, says the second Trump administration worked in its first year to make the U.S. more of a neutral party in Russia's war with Ukraine.
asserted
U.S. → diverge → Ukraine
She says it now appears Trump is working up to openly allying with Putin.
asserted
Trump → say → Putin
"We have to start thinking about where this trajectory ends up eventually," she said.
asserted
she → have → ?
"And it ends in the U.S. directly helping Russia's war effort."
asserted
U.S. → end → effort
Rigby says U.S.-Russian closeness raises immediate fears about Arctic sovereignty, and "could be the end of NORAD in a worst-case scenario," referring to the joint Canada-U.S. partnership to protect sovereign airspace.
uncertain
closeness → say → airspace
Huebert says the lifted oil sanctions and diesel deal could be seen cynically as a temporary move to mollify American voters angry about gas prices.
uncertain
Huebert → say → prices
"For him to try to reduce the price of diesel just before the midterms, you may disagree with it entirely but you can at least understand it
uncertain
you → try → it
," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
A proposed summit between Trump, Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping next month has revived longstanding concerns that Trump is keen to replace America's postwar network of alliances with a new global carve-up between three strongmen.
asserted
Trump → propose → strongmen
Trump has expressed openness to the Russian proposal.
asserted
Trump → express → proposal
"Obviously, this is music to Putin's ears," said Popova.
asserted
Popova → say → ears
Kremlin foreign policy aide Yuri Ushakov said on Sunday that preparations have begun for the three-way summit on the sidelines of the Nov. 18-19 APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.
asserted
preparations → say → Shenzhen
Huebert says the Russians have long pitched the idea of superpower spheres of influence, in which Washington, Moscow and Beijing would all agree to stay out of each other's backyards.
asserted
Washington → say → backyards
Lesser powers would have to find a modus vivendi with the regional hegemon.
asserted
powers → have → hegemon
"We really need to be pushing against such a travesty," said Popova, "because the next meeting of the three of them will be to decide the fate of Canada or Taiwan.
asserted
meeting → need → Canada
So we don't want this pattern to even start."
asserted
pattern → want → ?
Trump has already made it clear that he sees the entire Western Hemisphere as the domain of the United States.
asserted
he → make → States
"We don't want a world that's run by superpowers," said Rigby.
asserted
Rigby → want → superpowers
"If this is where we're headed — spheres of influence, Russia, China and the United States — this goes back to what Prime Minister Carney said at Davos: that middle powers are effectively going to be marginalized.
asserted
powers → head → Davos
Living with threats
Canada is pursuing new alliances and rearming, while seeking to keep the U.S.-Canada temperature low and bilateral institutions functioning where possible.
asserted
institutions → live → temperature
Popova sees parallels in this to Ukraine's past "multi-vector" approach to build connections with other countries, including Canada, that proved invaluable in 2014 when Russia took Crimea.
asserted
Russia → see → Crimea
"In a world that is really becoming a world à trois to a considerable extent, Russia, China, United States, we're going to have to reach out to Europe," said Rigby.
asserted
Rigby → become → Europe
That alliance can strengthen Canadian sovereignty if it leads to deeper integration of defence-industrial bases, greater exchanges of technology, the creation of a payments system less vulnerable to U.S. interference or the launching of new satellites that allow Canadians and Europeans to develop communications and navigational systems that don't depend on Musk or the Pentagon.
asserted
that → strengthen → Musk
But Canada can't alter its geography.
asserted
Canada → alter → geography
It lacks one key advantage of Ukraine, which has land borders with four EU nations, allowing easy resupply.
asserted
which → lack → resupply
Fortunately for Canadians, Trump's hostility toward Canada and fondness for Russia aren't shared by most Americans.
asserted
hostility → share → Americans
For some time, Americans have not trusted Trump to do the right thing on Russia, and that is true also within his own party.
asserted
that → trust → party
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
