What Valéry Giscard d’Estaing called America’s “exorbitant privilege” still seemingly reigns supreme.
asserted
called → call → What
The one-time French president was referring to the commanding position that the American dollar occupies in global finance as the world’s dominant reserve currency, a role that allows the US federal government to borrow almost without limit at relatively favourable interest rates.
asserted
government → refer → rates
With Paris and other major French cities in flames, money has been pouring out of France and into the traditional safe-haven asset of US Treasuries.
asserted
money → pour → Treasuries
Even UK gilts have benefited from France’s misery; the spread with French national debt has narrowed markedly over the last month.
But the big winner is the US, which ignoring exorbitant privilege might count as odd because objectively, America’s fiscal predicament is in some respects no less dire than that of France.
uncertain
predicament → benefit → France
Never mind the UK’s £3 trillion ($5.7 trillion) of sovereign debt and the equally hefty French tally, the US recently surged through $US40 trillion ($56.9 trillion), with seemingly no end in sight to 6 per cent-plus budget deficits.
asserted
US → mind → deficits
The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office projects that these deficits will drive overall federal debt to record-shattering levels relative to national income over the coming decade, and reach a staggering 155 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 30 years if nothing is done to change course.
asserted
nothing → project → course
As things stand, there is no sign of such action.
asserted
things → stand → action
Donald Trump has promised big subsidies to farmers, and – outrageously – an additional $US5000 payment or tax rebate to all Americans, should he succeed in defending Republican majorities in Congress in the coming midterms.
asserted
he → promise → midterms
In other words, the deficits are going to get even worse if voters back Trump.
asserted
voters → go → Trump
The situation scarcely looks any better if the Democrats triumph, committed as they are to reversing Trump’s welfare cuts.
asserted
they → look → cuts
This is the only serious bit of fiscal consolidation the White House proposes.
asserted
House → propose → consolidation
If it’s abandoned without the offset of big tax increases, the public finances will be in an even bigger mess.
asserted
finances → abandon → mess
What’s more, if the Democrats win big, the chances of a government shutdown after the current debt ceiling deal expires on December 11 increase dramatically.
asserted
deal → ’ → December
There is every possibility of the US falling foul of the same political paralysis as has crippled France.
asserted
US → be → France
It is an article of faith in Trump’s White House that superior levels of growth, and in particular American leadership in artificial intelligence – as big as the industrial revolution, according to Trump – will in time make the debt problem go away.
uncertain
problem → accord → time
Maybe the champions of AI are right about its potential, but the fact is that any plan for debt reduction which rests entirely on make-believe levels of AI-driven growth is not worth the paper it is written on.
asserted
it → rest → growth
It’s wing-and-a-prayer stuff, and simply not credible.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Recent developments, moreover, do not support the idea that AI is about to come riding to the rescue.
asserted
AI → support → rescue
AI-related stock prices have come seriously off the boil over the past several weeks, and there are growing signs of stress in AI-associated debt markets, with the cost of buying insurance against default soaring in many cases.
asserted
cost → relate → cases
Only last week, Jensen Huang, the leather-jacketed boss of Nvidia, warned of a funding crunch, with many companies struggling to raise the capital needed to sustain the current breakneck level of investment.
“The demand for capital is much greater than the availability of capital,” Jensen said, adding: “That’s going to get solved.”
asserted
That → warn → capital
You’ve got to admire his optimism, because there is a good reason why capital is drying up.
asserted
capital → get → optimism
And it’s not got much to do with the inability of the capital markets to cope with AI’s insatiable appetite for funds.
asserted
it → get → funds
If they can fund the US deficit to the humongous degree currently required, they can certainly accommodate the AI boom.
asserted
they → fund → boom
Rather, it’s about growing doubts over likely rates of return.
asserted
it → ’ → return
There are of course lots of starry-eyed projections out there, my all-time favourite being the one endorsed by Elon Musk to the effect that AI might eventually allow GDP to double every year.
uncertain
GDP → be → effect
Even the more considered Dario Amodei, the chief executive of Anthropic, talks in terms of 10 to 15 per cent overall economic growth.
asserted
Amodei → talk → growth
He might not be aware of it, but this would be far higher than occurred during the industrial revolution, and is therefore deeply unlikely.
uncertain
this → occur → revolution
In any case, if these forecasts are anywhere near correct, you would by now expect to be seeing some sign of it.
asserted
you → expect → it
Crowding out has become a real problem for other parts of the economy.
asserted
Crowding → crowd → economy
Monetisation of AI is meanwhile struggling, certainly on the scale needed to justify the amount of money being spent on it.
asserted
Monetisation → struggle → it
Fast looming into view is a further, hitherto largely unanticipated negative – that AI frontier labs could be held liable for any damage they inflict.
uncertain
they → loom → damage
Just imagine the tsunami of lawsuits that would follow if, say, Anthropic’s Claude was used to breach banking cybersecurity to steal depositors’ money or otherwise disable it.
asserted
Claude → imagine → it
Admittedly, you would be hard-pressed to sue the makers of a gun used to hold up a bank, but AI is virgin territory, and not only is there no telling what mischief it might enable, but unlike gun manufacturers, it enjoys no blanket immunity from prosecution.
uncertain
it → press → prosecution
People will be coming after Silicon Valley, no doubt about it.
asserted
People → come → it
Already, it’s virtually impossible for AI frontier labs to get liability insurance, for the obvious reason that they are seen as simply too high risk to insure.
asserted
they → ’ → risk
It’s a bit like insuring a house built on a flood plain.
asserted
It → ’ → plain
Insurers would be out of their minds to provide cover.
asserted
Insurers → provide → cover
For the moment, the US government is able to rely on the dollar’s exorbitant privilege to help fund itself, but it is becoming ever trickier, and investors are demanding a lot more for the privilege.
asserted
investors → rely → privilege
Never mind the continued deficits, around a quarter of the national debt – or $US10 trillion – matures in the next 12 months and has to be refinanced.
asserted
quarter → mind → months
Many of the traditional buyers of US Treasuries, in particular foreign governments and central banks, are in retreat, leaving the market increasingly dependent on domestic retail investors and heavily leveraged international hedge funds.
asserted
Many → leave → investors
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
