Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
From the complaint in Piker v. Jennings; of course, this is just Piker's side of the story—I expect we'll get Jennings' in a forthcoming motion to dismiss:
asserted
we → expect → motion
On August 11, 2026, Scott Jennings falsely told a nationwide podcast audience that Hasan Piker was "out there calling for Black voters to be lynched."
asserted
voters → tell → audience
He falsely told his listeners that Mr. Piker had a "plan of returning our country to lynchings."
asserted
Piker → tell → lynchings
And then he falsely told his social media followers that Mr. Piker "says the USA should resume lynchings against black people."
asserted
USA → tell → people
Mr. Piker has never advocated the lynching of Black Americans, or anyone else.
asserted
Piker → advocate → Americans
He has never called for a return to lynchings.
asserted
He → call → lynchings
And he has never proposed anything remotely resembling the supposed plan that Mr. Jennings falsely attributed to him.
asserted
Jennings → propose → him
Mr. Jennings did not merely mischaracterize something Mr. Piker said.
asserted
Piker → mischaracterize → something
He took a false, fabricated, and manipulated video of Mr. Piker, added a made-up quotation that Mr. Piker never uttered, and then made accusations that went beyond even what the manipulated footage purported to show.
asserted
footage → take → what
Mr. Jennings presented those accusations as fact, telling his viewers to "[l]isten for yourself" about Mr. Piker, knowing that he was playing a falsified video of Mr. Piker for those viewers, and completely disregarding the truth of Mr. Piker's actual words.
asserted
he → present → words
The underlying footage came from a broadcast nearly two years earlier on Twitch, an online streaming service owned by Amazon.
asserted
footage → underlie → Amazon
On October 29, 2024, Mr. Piker was reacting to a debate between two Black political commentators, one liberal and one conservative.
asserted
Piker → react → commentators
When the conservative commentator blamed "woke DAs" for policies supposedly harming Black Americans, Mr. Piker mocked him by sarcastically portraying that comment as nostalgia for an era before the civil rights movement.
asserted
Piker → blame → movement
Laughing, Mr. Piker said:
He said, "We need more Klansmen, okay?
asserted
We → laugh → Klansmen
Can we go back to a better time when lynchings were happening?
asserted
lynchings → go → time
This is what I like as a Black man.
asserted
I → like → man
My man said, "woke DAs," dude.
asserted
man → say → DAs
What are you saying?
asserted
you → say → What
Mr. Piker was plainly ridiculing the commentator's position.
asserted
Piker → ridicule → position
He was not endorsing it.
asserted
He → endorse → it
The debate video remained visible behind him.
asserted
video → remain → him
Mr. Piker introduced the remarks with "He said," laughed as he delivered them, and concluded by questioning the commentator's argument.
asserted
he → introduce → argument
His viewers understood the sarcasm.
asserted
viewers → understand → sarcasm
Some laughed along.
asserted
Some → laugh → ?
Others expressly described his comments as hyperbole.
asserted
Others → describe → hyperbole
Still others predicted that someone would eventually remove the context and circulate the resulting footage as though Mr. Piker had been speaking sincerely.
asserted
Piker → predict → footage
That is precisely what happened.
asserted
what → happen → ?
In August 2026, a 42-second video began circulating on social media that combined fragments of three separate Twitch broadcasts.
asserted
that → begin → broadcasts
The portions taken from Mr. Piker's October 2024 stream had been cropped, shortened, and rearranged.
asserted
portions → take → stream
The underlying debate was removed from view.
asserted
debate → underlie → view
The words "He said," which identified the object of Mr. Piker's ridicule, were omitted.
asserted
which → say → ridicule
Mr. Piker's laughter and subsequent explanation were also removed.
asserted
laughter → remove → ?
The resulting video portrayed sarcastic criticism of another as though it were an expression of Mr. Piker's own beliefs.
asserted
it → result → beliefs
On August 11, 2026, Mr. Jennings broadcast that false video on The Scott Jennings Show, misrepresenting the manipulated video as authentic.
asserted
Jennings → broadcast → video
But Mr. Jennings did not stop at repeating someone else's misleading edit.
asserted
Jennings → stop → edit
He added his own caption to the video, presented as a direct quotation from Mr. Piker:
PIKER: "LET'S GO BACK TO A BETTER TIME WHEN LYNCHINGS WERE HAPPENING" …
asserted
LYNCHINGS → add → TIME
Mr. Piker never said those words.
asserted
Piker → say → words
The original broadcast does not contain that statement.
asserted
broadcast → contain → statement
Neither does the manipulated video that Mr. Jennings chose to air
asserted
Jennings → do → that
Mr. Jennings converted a sarcastic question, expressly attributed to and directed toward someone else, into a patently false first-person statement of Mr. Piker's own supposed beliefs, and then relayed that false statement to his viewers.
asserted
Jennings → convert → viewers
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
