Angus Taylor has been criticised for his response to the alleged attack on Helen Haines, with crossbenchers Monique Ryan and Zali Steggall labelling a speech by the opposition leader “tone deaf” and saying he did not “read the room”.
asserted
he → criticise → room
Parliament returned in Canberra on Monday, a week after an alleged attack outside the Indi MP’s northern Victorian electorate office, which led to her losing both legs.
asserted
her → return → legs
A 43-year-old man has been charged and the incident continues to be investigated.
asserted
incident → charge → ?
The episode has sparked debate about the safety of MPs and the state of the political environment, including the culture of parliamentary debates.
asserted
episode → spark → debates
But the opposition leader, Angus Taylor, and the One Nation MP Barnaby Joyce have rejected calls for a change in practice to cool Australia’s political debate.
asserted
leader → reject → debate
“In the past week, it has been suggested by some there is a causal connection between robust parliamentary debate and political violence,” Taylor said.
uncertain
Taylor → suggest → debate
“I disagree with this view.
asserted
I → disagree → view
“The Westminster system is about settling differences through robust and rigorous debate, not violence.
asserted
system → settle → debate
“Importantly, we debate with adversarial vigour, but we never allow that vigorous parliamentary debate to spill over into violence.
asserted
debate → debate → violence
People who resort to intimidation and violence cross a line that must never be crossed.”
asserted
that → resort → line
He said Labor had been correct to call out far-right extremism in Australia but called for all extremism to be rejected.
asserted
extremism → say → Australia
He said judges should “come down harder” on people found guilty of intimidation or violence.
asserted
judges → say → intimidation
“Another thing we must do is celebrate Australia more readily.
asserted
we → do → Australia
Too many Australians have been taught to feel guilty and shame about our country and about our history.
asserted
Australians → teach → history
“Is it any wonder that some feel deep animosity towards our democracy, our institutions, and our nation?”
Joyce told News24 his thoughts and prayers remained with Haines and her family, calling the alleged attack “so unAustralian”.
“Unfortunately what we’re seeing in Australia and around the world is a change in dynamics,” Joyce said.
asserted
Joyce → feel → dynamics
“I think parliament has got its part to play but I don’t think it’s going to be a solution to the problem.
asserted
it → think → problem
“The issues, such as the Palestinian march across the [Sydney Harbour] Bridge, the vindictive, arsenic type of rhetoric that we see in the public realm, these are all part of it.
asserted
these → see → it
“I think it’s foolish to think if question time changes, Australia changes.
asserted
Australia → think → ?
Steggall, the independent Warringah MP, who sits next to Haines in the lower house, said she was personally disappointed by Taylor’s speech.
asserted
she → sit → speech
“There is a link between our words and actions,” she said.
asserted
she → be → words
“I did not feel that Angus Taylor read the room when it comes to the lesson that Helen would like us all to learn.
asserted
us → feel → that
“To make what’s happened to her, the utter tragedy of it, make sense to all of us, make sense for Australia, then we have to be able to take responsibility for the impact our words and our debate has beyond the walls of parliament.”
asserted
words → make → parliament
She said the same caution should be applied to media reporting, election advertising and social media posts.
asserted
caution → say → reporting
Steggall referenced conversations with Haines’ husband, Phil Haines, in Canberra on Monday.
asserted
Steggall → reference → Monday
“His words to us, asking us to raise the bar so that when Helen does come back to this place, there’s been a meaningful shift in how we can have a respectful debate,” she said.
asserted
she → ask → debate
“We can disagree respectfully, but words matter and have an impact.”
asserted
words → disagree → impact
Ryan, the Kooyong independent, called Taylor’s response “tone deaf” and “hugely disappointing”.
asserted
Ryan → call → response
“If Angus Taylor doesn’t think that the words that we use matter, I don’t understand how he aspires to lead a political party,” she told ABC TV.
asserted
she → think → TV
“If we can’t rise to the occasion now after something as unthinkable as what happened to Helen and think about how we behave in the house and in the public space … we’re never going to do that.”
asserted
we → rise → that
The Aporia
