Candidates who think they’ve escaped or explained their pasts keep having to explain comments that “resurface” online, again and again.
asserted
that → think → comments
Video of Texas Democratic Senate nominee James Talarico rejecting “tough on crime” policies in 2020 recently “resurfaced,” according to Fox News.
uncertain
Video → reject → News
More video of Talarico later “resurfaced,” this time of him thanking activists who drew the “link between climate change and white supremacy and capitalism.”
asserted
who → resurface → change
He had company when tweets about 9/11, written and then deleted by Michigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed, “resurfaced” in the New York Post.
asserted
tweets → have → Post
Peter Oberacker, a New York state senator running for Congress, watched his party cancel ad reservations after a “resurfaced 2015 Veterans Day Facebook post” appeared in Politico, honoring a grandfather who fought on the wrong side of World War II.
asserted
who → run → II
Colorado gubernatorial nominee Victor Marx’s tale of a meeting with Satan happened many years ago; it “resurfaced” this week, via a podcast he recorded in 2020.
asserted
he → happen → 2020
“Resurfacing” is more than a shortcut for political reporters to explain why they’re serving up something old to their audience.
asserted
they → resurface → audience
It reflects the way so much of our modern discourse is made — by journalists and operatives skimming the waters of social media, noodling out content that long ago stopped getting delivered in a linear form.
asserted
that → reflect → form
The overall progression here is familiar to anyone who read Douglas Rushkoff identifying and diagnosing the “narrative collapse” when Vine was young, TikTok hadn’t been founded, and most YouTube creators weren’t getting paid.
asserted
creators → read → collapse
Interesting information no longer needs to be part of a larger story; it now lives untethered to news or the news cycle.
asserted
it → need → news
The logic is simple: Every online platform is built to keep the user connected, which means getting emotional reactions, which means that the most aggravating material plays best, regardless of when it dates back to.
asserted
it → build → reactions
Witness the people reacting to movie clips as if they’re documentaries and the popularity of YouTube channels that rank and reorder old pop culture.
asserted
that → witness → culture
Political campaigns have always combed a candidate’s old statements and clips for material to be used against them.
asserted
campaigns → comb → them
It’s so standard, and traditional media has given up so much turf, that voters sometimes see work that a reporter dug up on his own and assume it was “opposition research.”
asserted
it → ’ → own
But “resurfaced” information doesn’t need to be obscure.
asserted
information → need → ?
Campaigns I’ve covered this year have been forced to respond to clips turned up by candidates’ friends or family — long after the problems were perceived as resolved.
asserted
problems → cover → friends
An old-fashioned news desk might cover a clip once, ask the candidate about it, and then consider the story over.
uncertain
desk → cover → story
News consumers today, surfing the slurry of free information on their phones and browsers, are constantly being shocked by the old.
asserted
consumers → surf → old
This has been a factor in Texas, where Democrats quickly identified the clips that Republicans would use against Talarico.
asserted
Republicans → identify → Talarico
He’d claimed that there were six biological sexes and that God was “nonbinary” during 2021 debates about gender legislation in the state.
asserted
God → claim → state
When Talarico won his March primary, the clips were shared again on social media.
asserted
clips → win → media
Yes, the word used was “resurfacing.”
asserted
word → use → ?
Weeks later, after Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton won the GOP primary, they “resurfaced” again, this time getting a full explanation from the Democrat.
asserted
they → win → Democrat
Not that it would prevent them popping up again.
asserted
them → prevent → ?
How does a modern candidate get past the resurfaced clips?
asserted
candidate → get → clips
I got different answers from the strategists I talked to, none of them definitive.
asserted
none → get → them
One piece of advice was to build a robust social media rapid-response network that could act quickly when something bad was “resurfacing” — firing back with the context, or maybe a fuller clip.
uncertain
something → build → context
Yet in practice, that’s not so easy to build.
asserted
that → ’ → practice
Candidates with younger, online native support had the advantage.
asserted
Candidates → have → advantage
In Michigan, Democratic Rep. Haley Stevens never lived down the clip of her telling Jewish voters that she sees “Israel in my dreams,” despite explaining it many times to reporters.
asserted
she → live → reporters
One strategist even recalled getting asked, in the final days of the Senate primary, why Stevens was using that clip as her closing message.
asserted
Stevens → recall → message
(It was nearly three years old, and never shared by the campaign.)
asserted
It → share → campaign
Campaigns are naturally resistant to feeding a controversy, especially if they feel it’s been dealt with before.
asserted
it → feed → controversy
But they’re in competition with themselves now — and when future attack ads can time travel, an aggressive approach is needed.
asserted
approach → ’re → themselves
Notable
- The resurfacing game is especially tough on candidates with scant national profiles, like Florida’s Angie Nixon, whose videos advocating left-wing causes were re-shared as soon as she won the Democrats’ Senate nomination.
asserted
she → resurface → nomination
- Resurfacing has its uses, like when politicians don’t have great explanations about why their positions have completely changed.
asserted
positions → have → explanations
In May, Gov. Greg Abbott denounced Austin, the bête noire of every Texas conservative, for not using Flock cameras that could have aided in catching a mass shooter.
uncertain
that → denounce → shooter
The Aporia
